The problem of vibration induced structural faults has been a real one in engineering over the years. If left unchecked it has led to the unexpected failures of so many structures. Needless to say, this has caused both economic and human life losses. Therefore for over forty years, structural damage identification has been one of the important research areas for engineers. There has been a thrust to develop global structural damage identification techniques to complement and/or supplement the long-practised local experimental techniques. In that respect, studies have shown that vibration-based techniques prove to be more potent. Most of the existing vibration-based techniques monitor changes in modal properties like natural frequencies, damping factors and mode shapes of the structural system to infer the presence of structural damage. Literature also reports other techniques which monitor changes in other vibration quantities like the frequency response functions, transmissibility functions and time-domain responses. However, none of these techniques provide a complete identification of structural damage. This study presents a damage detection technique based on operational response monitoring, which can identify all the four levels of structural damage and be implemented as a continuous structural health monitoring technique. The technique is based on monitoring changes in internal data variability measured by a test statistic <font face="symbol">c</font>2Ovalue. Structural normality is assumed when the <font face="symbol">c</font>2Om value calculated from a fresh set of measured data is within the limits prescribed by a threshold <font face="symbol">c</font>2OTH value . On the other hand, abnormality is assumed when this threshold value has been exceeded. The quantity of damage is determined by matching the <font face="symbol">c</font>2Om value with the <font face="symbol">c</font>2Op values predicted using a benchmark finite element model. The use of <font face="symbol">c</font>2O values is noted to provide better sensitivity to structural damage than the natural frequency shift technique. The analysis carried out on a numerical study showed that the sensitivity of the proposed technique ranged from three to thousand times as much as the sensitivity of the natural frequencies. The results from a laboratory structure showed that accurate estimates of damage quantity and remaining service life could be achieved for crack lengths of less than 0.55 the structural thickness. This was due to the fact that linear elastic fracture mechanics theory was applicable up to this value. Therefore, the study achieved its main objective of identifying all four levels of structural damage using operational response changes. / Dissertation (MSc (Mechanics))--University of Pretoria, 2007. / Mechanical and Aeronautical Engineering / unrestricted

Structural Health Monitoring (SHM) is the sensing and analysis of a structure to detect abnormal behavior, damage and deterioration during regular operations as well as under extreme loadings. SHM is designed to provide objective information for decision-making on safety and serviceability. This research focuses on the SHM of bridges by developing and integrating novel methods and techniques using sensor networks, computer vision, modeling for damage indices and statistical approaches. Effective use of traffic video synchronized with sensor measurements for decision-making is demonstrated. First, some of the computer vision methods and how they can be used for bridge monitoring are presented along with the most common issues and some practical solutions. Second, a conceptual damage index (Unit Influence Line) is formulated using synchronized computer images and sensor data for tracking the structural response under various load conditions. Third, a new index, Nd , is formulated and demonstrated to more effectively identify, localize and quantify damage. Commonly observed damage conditions on real bridges are simulated on a laboratory model for the demonstration of the computer vision method, UIL and the new index. This new method and the index, which are based on outlier detection from the UIL population, can very effectively handle large sets of monitoring data. The methods and techniques are demonstrated on the laboratory model for damage detection and all damage scenarios are identified successfully. Finally, the application of the proposed methods on a real life structure, which has a monitoring system, is presented. It is shown that these methods can be used efficiently for applications such as damage detection and load rating for decision-making. The results from this monitoring project on a movable bridge are demonstrated and presented along with the conclusions and recommendations for future work.

The objective of this work was to employ artificial neural networks (NN) to solve inverse problems in different engineering fields, overcoming various obstacles in applying NN to different problems and benefiting from the experience of solving different types of inverse problems. The inverse problems investigated are: 1) damage detection in structures, 2) detection of an anomaly in a light-diffusive medium, such as human tissue using optical imaging, 3) structural optimization of fiber optic sensor design. All of these problems require solving highly complex inverse problems and the treatments benefit from employing neural networks which have strength in generalization, pattern recognition, and fault tolerance. Moreover, the neural networks for the three problems are similar, and a method found suitable for solving one type of problem can be applied for solving other types of problems. Solution of inverse problems using neural networks consists of two parts. The first is repeatedly solving the direct problem, obtaining the response of a system for known parameters and constructing the set of the solutions to be used as training sets for NN. The next step is training neural networks so that the trained neural networks can produce a set of parameters of interest for the response of the system. Mainly feed-forward backpropagation NN were used in this work. One of the obstacles in applying artificial neural networks is the need for solving the direct problem repeatedly and generating a large enough number of training sets. To reduce the time required in solving the direct problems of structural dynamics and photon transport in opaque tissue, the finite element method was used. To solve transient problems, which include some of the problems addressed here, and are computationally intensive, the modal superposition and the modal acceleration methods were employed. The need for generating a large enough number of training sets required by NN was fulfilled by automatically generating the training sets using a script program in the MATLAB environment. This program automatically generated finite element models with different parameters, and the program also included scripts that combined the whole solution processes in different engineering packages for the direct problem and the inverse problem using neural networks. Another obstacle in applying artificial neural networks in solving inverse problems is that the dimension and the size of the training sets required for the NN can be too large to use NN effectively with the available computational resources. To overcome this obstacle, Principal Component Analysis is used to reduce the dimension of the inputs for the NN without excessively impairing the integrity of the data. Orthogonal Arrays were also used to select a smaller number of training sets that can efficiently represent the given system. / Ph. D.

As pontes de concreto armado são obras de arte de extrema importância para a infraestrutura de transportes do Brasil. Portanto sua inspeção e manutenção são atividades estratégicas. A inspeção visual, ensaios destrutivos e não destrutivos fornecem informações sobre a sua integridade estrutural e auxiliam na tomada de decisões relativas à necessidade de reparos e reforços. Entre os ensaios não destrutivos, avalia-se neste trabalho a aplicação da identificação modal estocástica na detecção de danos em pontes. A técnica baseia-se na medição das vibrações ambientais da estrutura, aquelas que ocorrem durante seu uso, identificação de suas propriedades modais, comparação com as propriedades modais da estrutura íntegra e consequente detecção de danos. Diferentemente da análise dinâmica experimental clássica, na identificação modal estocástica as ações dinâmicas não são medidas e nem controladas durante o ensaio. Por este motivo foram adotadas técnicas de identificação modal baseadas apenas nas vibrações medidas em alguns pontos da estrutura, funções de densidade espectral de potência e transmissibilidades de vibrações entre os pontos. Desta forma as frequências naturais e modos de vibração experimentais puderam ser precisamente identificados em modelos íntegros e danificados de pontes em escala reduzida. Em cada modelo, uma danificação foi imposta em uma de suas longarinas no meio do vão ou no segundo quarto de vão. Após a realização dos ensaios dinâmicos nas condições íntegra e danificada, duas técnicas de identificação de danos foram utilizadas: Diferença de Curvatura Modal (DCM) e Índice de Dano (ID). Ambas as técnicas tiveram sucesso na detecção de danos nos modelos de pontes avaliados. / Reinforced concrete bridges are extremely important elements of Brazilian transportation infrastructure. Consequently their inspection and maintenance are strategic activities. Visual inspection, destructive or nondestructive tests offer relevant information on their structural integrity and support the decision on the need of retrofitting or strengthening. Among existing types of nondestructive tests, this work focuses on the application of stochastic modal identification in damage detection of bridges. This technique is based on the measurement of environmental vibrations that occur during normal operation of the structure, modal identification, comparison of modal properties between damaged and undamaged bridge and finally damage detection. Opposed to classical dynamic experimental analysis, in stochastic modal identification the loads are not measured or known during the test. For this reason modal identification was only based in vibrations measured in selected points of the structure, power spectral density functions and vibration transmissibilities between these points. With this method natural frequencies and experimental modal shapes could be precisely identified in damaged and undamaged small scale models of bridges. The damage was induced in the middle of the span or in the second quarter of the span in one of the girders. After dynamic testing in undamaged and damaged conditions two damage identification techniques were used: Modal Curvature Difference (MCD) and Damage Index (ID). Both techniques detected successfully the damages imposed to the bridge models.

Countries world-over have thousands of critical structures and bridges which have been built decades back when strength-based designs were the order of the day. Over the years, magnitude and frequency of loadings on these have increased. Also, these structures have been exposed to environmental degradation during their service life. Hence, structural health monitoring (SHM) has attracted the attention of researchers, world over. Structural health monitoring is recommended both for vulnerable old bridges and structures as well as for new important structures. Structural health monitoring as a principle is derived from condition monitoring of machinery, where the day-to-day recordings of sound and vibration from machinery is compared and sudden changes in their features is reported for inspection and trouble-shooting. With the availability of funds for repair and retrofitting being limited, it has become imperative to rank buildings and bridges that require rehabilitation for prioritization. Visual inspection and expert judgment continues to rule the roost. Non-destructive testing techniques though have come of age and are providing excellent inputs for judgment cannot be carried out indiscriminately. They are best suited for evaluating local damage when restricted areas are investigated in detail. A few modern bridges, particularly long-span bridges have been provided with sophisticated instrumentation for health monitoring. It is necessary to identify local damages existing in normal bridges. The methodology adopted for such identification should be simple, both in terms of investigations involved and the instrumentation. Researchers have proposed various methodologies including damage identification from mode shapes, wavelet-based formulations and optimization-based damage identification and instrumentation schemes and so on. These are technically involved but may be difficult to be applied for all critical bridges, where the sheer volume of number of bridges to be investigated is enormous. Ideally, structural health monitoring has to be carried out in two stages: (a) Stage-1: Remote monitoring of global damage indicators and inference of the health of the structure. Instrumentation for this stage should be less, simple, but at critical locations to capture the global damage in a reasonable sense. (b) Stage -2: If global indicators show deviation beyond a specified threshold, then a detailed and localized instrumentation and monitoring, with controlled application of static and dynamic loads is to be carried out to infer the health of the structure and take a decision on the repair and retrofit strategies. The thesis proposes the first stage structural health monitoring methodology using natural frequencies and static deflections as damage indicators. The idea is that the stage-1 monitoring has to be done for a large number of bridges and vulnerable structures in a remote and wire-less way and a centralized control and processing unit should be able to number-crunch the in-coming data automatically and the features extracted from the data should help in determining whether any particular bridge warrants second stage detailed investigation. Hence, simple and robust strategies are required for estimating the health of the structure using some of the globally available response data. Identification methodology developed in this thesis is applicable to distributed smeared damage, which is typical of reinforced concrete structures. Simplified expressions and methodologies are proposed in the thesis and numerically and experimentally validated towards damage estimation of typical structures and elements from measured natural frequencies and static deflections. The first-order perturbation equation for a dynamical system is used to derive the relevant expressions for damage identification. The sensitivity of Eigen-value-cumvector pair to damage, modeled as reduction in flexural rigidity (EI for beams, AE for axial rods and Et 12(1 2 )3− μ for plates) is derived. The forward equation relating the changes in EI to changes in frequencies is derived for typical structural elements like simply-supported beams, plates and axial rods (along with position and extent of damage as the other controlling parameters). A distributed damage is uniquely defined with its position, extent and magnitude of EI reduction. A methodology is proposed for the inverse problem, making use of the linear relationship between the reductions in EI (in a smeared sense) to Eigen-values, such that multiple damages could be estimated using changes in natural frequencies. The methodology is applied to beams, plates and axial rods. The performance of this inverse methodology under influence of measurement errors is investigated for typical error profiles. For a discrete three dimensional structure, computationally derived sensitivity matrix is used to solve the damages in each floor levels, simulating the post-earthquake damage scenario. An artificial neural network (ANN) based Radial basis function network (RBFN) is also used to solve the multivariate interpolation problem, with appropriate training sets involving a number of pairs of damage and Eigen-value-change vectors. The acclaimed Cawley-Adams criteria (1979) states that, “the ratio of changes in natural frequencies between two modes is independent of the damage magnitude” and is governed only by the position (or location) and extent of damage. This criterion is applied to a multiple damage problem and contours with equal frequency change ratios, termed as Iso_Eigen_value_change contours are developed. Intersection of these contours for different pairs of frequencies shows the position and extent of damage. Experimental and analytical verification of damage identification methodology using Cawley-Adams criteria is successfully demonstrated. Sensitivity expressions relating the damages to changes in static deflections are derived and numerically and experimentally proved. It is seen that this process of damage identification from static deflections is prone to more errors if not cautiously exercised. Engineering and physics based intuition is adopted in setting the guidelines for efficient damage detection using static deflections. In lines of Cawley-Adams criteria for frequencies, an invariant factor based on static deflections measured at pairs of symmetrical points on a simply supported beam is developed and established. The power of the factor is such that it is governed only by the position of damage and invariant with reference to extent and magnitude of damage. Such a revelation is one step ahead of Caddemi and Morassi’s (2007) recent paper, dealing with static deflection based damage identification for concentrated damage. The invariant factor makes it an ideal candidate for base-line-free measurement, if the quality and resolution of instrumentation is good. A moving damage problem is innovatively introduced in the experiment. An attempt is made to examine wave-propagation techniques for damage identification and a guideline for modeling wave propagation as a transient dynamic problem is done. The reflected-wave response velocity (peak particle velocity) as a ratio of incident wave response is proposed as a damage indicator for an axial rod (representing an end-supported pile foundation). Suitable modifications are incorporated in the classical expressions to correct for damping and partial-enveloping of advancing wave in the damage zone. The experimental results on axial dynamic response of free-free beams suggest that vibration frequency based damage identification is a viable complementary tool to wave propagation. Wavelet-multi-resolution analysis as a feature extraction tool for damage identification is also investigated and structural slope (rotation) and curvatures are found to be the better indicators of damage coupled with wavelet analysis. An adaptive excitation scheme for maximizing the curvature at any arbitrary point of interest is also proposed. However more work is to be done to establish the efficiency of wavelets on experimentally derived parameters, where large noise-ingression may affect the analysis. The application of time-period based damage identification methodology for post-seismic damage estimation is investigated. Seismic damage is postulated by an index based on its plastic displacement excursion and the cumulative energy dissipated. Damage index is a convenient tool for decision making on immediate-occupancy, life-safety after repair and demolition of the structure. Damage sensitive soft storey structure and a weak story structure are used in the non-linear dynamic analysis and the DiPasquale-Cakmak (1987) damage index is calibrated with Park-Ang (1985) damage index. The exponent of the time-period ratio of DiPasquale-Cakmak model is modified to have consistency of damage index with Park-Ang (1985) model.

This thesis is about using structural-dynamics based methods to address the existing challenges in the field of Structural Health Monitoring (SHM). Particularly, new structural-dynamics based methods are presented, to model areas of damage, to do damage diagnosis and to estimate and predict the sensitivity of structural vibration properties like natural frequencies to the presence of damage. Towards these objectives, a general analytical procedure, which yields nth-order expressions governing mode shapes and natural frequencies and for damaged elastic structures such as rods, beams, plates and shells of any shape is presented. Features of the procedure include the following: 1. Rather than modeling the damage as a fictitious elastic element or localized or global change in constitutive properties, it is modeled in a mathematically rigorous manner as a geometric discontinuity. 2. The inertia effect (kinetic energy), which, unlike the stiffness effect (strain energy), of the damage has been neglected by researchers, is included in it. 3. The framework is generic and is applicable to wide variety of engineering structures of different shapes with arbitrary boundary conditions which constitute self adjoint systems and also to a wide variety of damage profiles and even multiple areas of damage. To illustrate the ability of the procedure to effectively model the damage, it is applied to beams using Euler-Bernoulli and Timoshenko theories and to plates using Kirchhoff's theory, supported on different types of boundary conditions. Analytical results are compared with experiments using piezoelectric actuators and non-contact Laser-Doppler Vibrometer sensors. Next, the step of damage diagnosis is approached. Damage diagnosis is done using two methodologies. One, the modes and natural frequencies that are determined are used to formulate analytical expressions for a strain energy based damage index. Two, a new damage detection parameter are identified. Assuming the damaged structure to be a linear system, the response is expressed as the summation of the responses of the corresponding undamaged structure and the response (negative response) of the damage alone. If the second part of the response is isolated, it forms what can be regarded as the damage signature. The damage signature gives a clear indication of the damage. In this thesis, the existence of the damage signature is investigated when the damaged structure is excited at one of its natural frequencies and therefore it is called ``partial mode contribution". The second damage detection method is based on this new physical parameter as determined using the partial mode contribution. The physical reasoning is verified analytically, thereupon it is verified using finite element models and experiments. The limits of damage size that can be determined using the method are also investigated. There is no requirement of having a baseline data with this damage detection method. Since the partial mode contribution is a local parameter, it is thus very sensitive to the presence of damage. The parameter is also shown to be not affected by noise in the detection ambience.

This research study presents a new vibration-based non-destructive global structural damage identification and condition monitoring technique that can be used for detection, localization and quantification of damage. A two-stage damage identification process that combines non-model based and model-based damage identification approaches is proposed to overcome the main difficulties associated with the solution of structural damage identification problems. In the first stage, performance assessment of various response parameters obtained from the time-domain, frequency-domain and spectral-domain analysis is conducted using a non model-based damage detection and localization approach. In addition, vibration response parameters that are sensitive to local and global damage and that possess strong physical relationships with key structural dynamic properties are identified. Moreover, in order to overcome the difficulties associated with damage identification in the presence of structural nonlinearity and response nonstationarity, a wavelet transform based damage-sensitive parameter is presented for detection and localization of damage in the space domain. The level of sensitivity and effectiveness of these parameters for detection and localization of damage are demonstrated using various numerical experimental data determined from one-dimensional and two-dimensional plate-like structures.

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / O presente trabalho apresenta um estudo referente à aplicação da abordagem Bayesiana como técnica de solução do problema inverso de identificação de danos estruturais, onde a integridade da estrutura é continuamente descrita por um parâmetro estrutural denominado parâmetro de coesão. A estrutura escolhida para análise é uma viga simplesmente apoiada do tipo Euler-Bernoulli. A identificação de danos é baseada em alterações na resposta impulsiva da estrutura, provocadas pela presença dos mesmos. O problema direto é resolvido através do Método de Elementos Finitos (MEF), que, por sua vez, é parametrizado pelo parâmetro de coesão da estrutura. O problema de identificação de danos é formulado como um problema inverso, cuja solução, do ponto de vista Bayesiano, é uma distribuição de probabilidade a posteriori para cada parâmetro de coesão da estrutura, obtida utilizando-se a metodologia de amostragem de Monte Carlo com Cadeia de Markov. As incertezas inerentes aos dados medidos serão contempladas na função de verossimilhança. Três estratégias de solução são apresentadas. Na Estratégia 1, os parâmetros de coesão da estrutura são amostrados de funções densidade de probabilidade a posteriori que possuem o mesmo desvio padrão. Na Estratégia 2, após uma análise prévia do processo de identificação de danos, determina-se regiões da viga potencialmente danificadas e os parâmetros de coesão associados à essas regiões são amostrados a partir de funções de densidade de probabilidade a posteriori que possuem desvios diferenciados. Na Estratégia 3, após uma análise prévia do processo de identificação de danos, apenas os parâmetros associados às regiões identificadas como potencialmente danificadas são atualizados. Um conjunto de resultados numéricos é apresentado levando-se em consideração diferentes níveis de ruído para as três estratégias de solução apresentadas. / This work presents a study on the application of Bayesian approach as a technique for solving the inverse problem of structural damage identification, where the integrity of the structure is continuously described by a structural cohesion parameter. The structure chosen for analysis is a simply supported Euler - Bernoulli beam. The damage identification is based on changes in the impulse response of the structure caused by the presence thereof. The direct problem is solved by the finite element method (FEM), which, in turn, is parameterized by the cohesion parameter of the structure. The problem of identifying damages is formulated as an inverse problem, whose solution, from the Bayesian framework, is a posteriori probability distribution of the cohesion parameter, obtained using the sampling methodology of Monte Carlo with Markov Chain. The uncertainties inherent to the measured data will be included in the likelihood function. Three solution strategies are presented. In the Strategy 1, the cohesion parameters of the structure are sampled from probability density functions a posteriori that have the same standard deviation. In the Strategy 2, after a previous analysis of the damage identification process, are determined potentially damaged regions and the cohesion parameters associated with these regions are sampled from probability density functions a posteriori that have different deviations. In the Strategy 3, after a preliminary analysis of the damage identification process, only the parameters associated with regions identifed as potentially damaged are updated. A set of numerical results are presented taking into account different noise levels for the three considered strategies.

Fundação Carlos Chagas Filho de Amparo a Pesquisa do Estado do Rio de Janeiro / Neste trabalho são utilizados a técnica baseada na propagação de ondas acústicas e o método de otimização estocástica Luus-Jaakola (LJ) para solucionar o problema inverso relacionado à identificação de danos em barras. São apresentados o algoritmo algébrico sequencial (AAS) e o algoritmo algébrico sequencial aperfeiçoado (AASA) que modelam o problema direto de propagação de ondas acústicas em uma barra. O AASA consiste nas modificações introduzidas no AAS. O uso do AASA resolve com vantagens o problema de identificação de danos com variações abruptas de impedância. Neste trabalho são obtidos, usando-se o AAS-LJ e o AASA-LJ, os resultados de identificação de cinco cenários de danos. Três deles com perfil suave de impedância acústica generalizada e os outros dois abruptos. Além disso, com o objetivo de simular sinais reais de um experimento, foram introduzidos variados níveis de ruído. Os resultados alcançados mostram que o uso do AASA-LJ na resolução de problemas de identificação de danos em barras é bastante promissor, superando o AAS-LJ para perfis abruptos de impedância. / In this work the techniques based on the wave propagation approach and the Luus- Jaakola optimization method to solve the inverse problem of damage identification in bars are applied. The sequential algebraic algorithm (SAA) and the improved sequential algebraic algorithm (ISAA) that model the direct problem of acoustic wave propagation in bars are presented. The ISAA consists on modifications of the SAA. The use of the ISAA solves with advantages the problem of damage identification when the generalized acoustical impedance variations are abrupt. In this work the results of identification of five damage scenarios are obtained using the SAA and the ISAA. Three of them are smooth impedance profiles and the other two are rough ones. Moreover, to simulate signals obtained experimentally, different noise levels were introduced. It is shown that using the ISAA-LJ in solving problems of damage identification in bars is quite promising, furnishing better results than the SAA-LJ, specially when the impedance profiles are abrupt.

Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / O presente trabalho apresenta um estudo referente à aplicação da abordagem Bayesiana como técnica de solução do problema inverso de identificação de danos estruturais, onde a integridade da estrutura é continuamente descrita por um parâmetro estrutural denominado parâmetro de coesão. A estrutura escolhida para análise é uma viga simplesmente apoiada do tipo Euler-Bernoulli. A identificação de danos é baseada em alterações na resposta impulsiva da estrutura, provocadas pela presença dos mesmos. O problema direto é resolvido através do Método de Elementos Finitos (MEF), que, por sua vez, é parametrizado pelo parâmetro de coesão da estrutura. O problema de identificação de danos é formulado como um problema inverso, cuja solução, do ponto de vista Bayesiano, é uma distribuição de probabilidade a posteriori para cada parâmetro de coesão da estrutura, obtida utilizando-se a metodologia de amostragem de Monte Carlo com Cadeia de Markov. As incertezas inerentes aos dados medidos serão contempladas na função de verossimilhança. Três estratégias de solução são apresentadas. Na Estratégia 1, os parâmetros de coesão da estrutura são amostrados de funções densidade de probabilidade a posteriori que possuem o mesmo desvio padrão. Na Estratégia 2, após uma análise prévia do processo de identificação de danos, determina-se regiões da viga potencialmente danificadas e os parâmetros de coesão associados à essas regiões são amostrados a partir de funções de densidade de probabilidade a posteriori que possuem desvios diferenciados. Na Estratégia 3, após uma análise prévia do processo de identificação de danos, apenas os parâmetros associados às regiões identificadas como potencialmente danificadas são atualizados. Um conjunto de resultados numéricos é apresentado levando-se em consideração diferentes níveis de ruído para as três estratégias de solução apresentadas. / This work presents a study on the application of Bayesian approach as a technique for solving the inverse problem of structural damage identification, where the integrity of the structure is continuously described by a structural cohesion parameter. The structure chosen for analysis is a simply supported Euler - Bernoulli beam. The damage identification is based on changes in the impulse response of the structure caused by the presence thereof. The direct problem is solved by the finite element method (FEM), which, in turn, is parameterized by the cohesion parameter of the structure. The problem of identifying damages is formulated as an inverse problem, whose solution, from the Bayesian framework, is a posteriori probability distribution of the cohesion parameter, obtained using the sampling methodology of Monte Carlo with Markov Chain. The uncertainties inherent to the measured data will be included in the likelihood function. Three solution strategies are presented. In the Strategy 1, the cohesion parameters of the structure are sampled from probability density functions a posteriori that have the same standard deviation. In the Strategy 2, after a previous analysis of the damage identification process, are determined potentially damaged regions and the cohesion parameters associated with these regions are sampled from probability density functions a posteriori that have different deviations. In the Strategy 3, after a preliminary analysis of the damage identification process, only the parameters associated with regions identifed as potentially damaged are updated. A set of numerical results are presented taking into account different noise levels for the three considered strategies.