The problem of this study was to investigate the strategies used by high school students of limited estimation ability for the estimation of the answers to computational problems. The Assessing Computational Estimation Test was administered to 460 students, and 40 of them were selected for interviews. Each student interviewed was asked to estimate the answers to fourteen computation and application problems.

<p>Competence in mental arithmetic is recognised by many as essential to be active participants in the fast flowing, high technological society we live in today.  Many have noticed pupils’ unwillingness to set their calculators aside and practice this aspect of mathematics when possible.  Furthermore, some studies show that pupils’ ability to compute mentally deteriorates as they pass through the school system.  Through testing classes in a Swedish obligatory school and an upper secondary school, the aim of this thesis is to see if the goals set by The National [Swedish] Agency for Education regarding mental arithmetic, are being fulfilled.  Through using questionnaires to collect the strategies and ideas of the pupils, a wide range of problematic mathematical misconceptions became evident.  These are highlighted since they are important aspects teachers should be aware of.  The results of this study show that the obligatory school classes are far from reaching the goals set for them whereas the upper secondary classes show good results.  Furthermore, there is an apparent improvement in their progression, resulting in a fulfilment the official goals.  Many pupils however, seem reluctant to rely on their mental arithmetic capabilities and resort to algorithmic strategies.  Other problems to emerge are in carrying out table calculations and in a lack of number sense when deeming if the answers are reasonable.   </p>

Competence in mental arithmetic is recognised by many as essential to be active participants in the fast flowing, high technological society we live in today.  Many have noticed pupils’ unwillingness to set their calculators aside and practice this aspect of mathematics when possible.  Furthermore, some studies show that pupils’ ability to compute mentally deteriorates as they pass through the school system.  Through testing classes in a Swedish obligatory school and an upper secondary school, the aim of this thesis is to see if the goals set by The National [Swedish] Agency for Education regarding mental arithmetic, are being fulfilled.  Through using questionnaires to collect the strategies and ideas of the pupils, a wide range of problematic mathematical misconceptions became evident.  These are highlighted since they are important aspects teachers should be aware of.  The results of this study show that the obligatory school classes are far from reaching the goals set for them whereas the upper secondary classes show good results.  Furthermore, there is an apparent improvement in their progression, resulting in a fulfilment the official goals.  Many pupils however, seem reluctant to rely on their mental arithmetic capabilities and resort to algorithmic strategies.  Other problems to emerge are in carrying out table calculations and in a lack of number sense when deeming if the answers are reasonable.

Thesis (M.A.)--Carleton University, 2001. / Includes bibliographical references (p. 39-41). Also available in electronic format on the Internet.

La présente thèse a pour objectif de clarifier la nature de la relation entre les habiletés numériques innées – le Sens du Nombre – et les compétences en arithmétique apprises à l’école. L’originalité de cette recherche consiste en l’attention particulière que je porterai au rôle que jouent les habiletés numériques innées dans les différentes manières de résoudre une addition complexe, telle que 48 + 25, c’est-à-dire les stratégies de résolution. Dans le présent travail, je m’attèlerai à déterminer si la possession de compétences numériques plus développées favorise l’utilisation de procédures de calcul qui tiennent compte des propriétés numériques des opérandes du calcul, et si, inversement, la possession d’habiletés numériques plus imprécises entrave leur application, au profit de stratégies de calcul plus basiques. <p><p>À cette fin, j’axerai la présente thèse en trois volets distincts. Dans un premier volet, je vérifierai que les habiletés numériques sont essentielles à l’implémentation de toutes les stratégies de calcul, malgré le fait qu’elles soient engagées à des degrés d’élaboration différents en fonction de la stratégie exécutée. Ensuite, dans un second volet, je confirmerai que les compétences numériques orientent les préférences stratégiques ;comme je le supposais, les calculateurs possédant les habiletés numériques les plus développées ont davantage recours à des stratégies basées sur la magnitude complète des nombres, alors que ceux qui ont des capacités plus limitées les évitent. Enfin, dans un dernier volet, je mettrai en évidence que l’application de telles stratégies qui impliquent de traiter les numérosités entières engendre au niveau cérébral une activité accrue au sein des régions intrapariétales, aires dédiées au traitement des magnitudes numériques, par rapport aux autres procédures de calcul.<p><p>Les résultats que je rapporte dans la présente thèse mettent ainsi en évidence que les habiletés numériques sont critiques dans la résolution d’additions complexes non seulement au niveau de l’exécution de la stratégie de calcul, mais aussi dans l’établissement à long terme de la préférence stratégique des individus. Outre ces observations, la présente recherche plaide plus généralement en faveur de la prise en considération des stratégies de résolution dans les tâches arithmétiques, car les compétences numériques peuvent y être associées à des degrés différents. Au-delà de la simple performance, s’intéresser plus qualitativement aux stratégies de résolution constitue selon moi une étape cruciale dans la compréhension de la nature du lien entre le Sens du Nombre inné et les compétences en arithmétique.<p><p>/<p><p>The current thesis aims at clarifying the nature of the relationship between innate numerical abilities – the Number Sense – and arithmetic skills acquired at school. I will particularly focus in this research on the role played by these innate numerical abilities in selecting and executing the different procedures that could be used to solve a complex addition such as 48 + 27. In the current thesis, I will attempt to determine whether more elaborated numerical competence favours the utilisation of solving strategies that take into account the numerical properties of the addends, and conversely, whether inaccurate numerical representations discourage from using these strategies, for the benefit of more basic solving strategies.<p><p>In the current thesis, I will more specifically cover three different aspects. First of all, I will demonstrate that numerical abilities are crucial in implementing every solving strategy, but that they are engaged to a different extent as a function of the executed strategy. Secondly, I will show that numerical competence determine strategic preference; as I hypothesized, adults who possess the best numerical abilities would use more frequently solving strategies that are based on the entire numerical magnitude of the addends, whereas adults with more limited abilities would rather avoid them and execute basic procedures. Finally, in the third section, I will emphasize that the use of such elaborated solving strategies do imply at the cerebral level a stronger activity within the intraparietal regions, which are dedicated to the numerical magnitude processing, in comparison to other basic solving strategies.<p><p>The data I report here thus highlight that numerical abilities are essential in solving complex additions, not only in the execution of the solving strategy, but also in the long-term establishment of the preferred strategy. Besides this observation, the current thesis claims more generally in favour of the consideration of solving strategies when assessing arithmetic tasks, because numerical abilities are involved to a distinct extent in these tasks. Over and above regular performance, investigating through a qualitative perspective the solving strategies constitutes, according to me, a fundamental step in understanding the nature of the relationship between the innate Number Sense and arithmetic skills.<p> / Doctorat en Sciences Psychologiques et de l'éducation / info:eu-repo/semantics/nonPublished

Doctorat en sciences psychologiques / info:eu-repo/semantics/nonPublished

<p>This study examined the idea that each mathematical operation (addition, subtraction, multiplication and division) is mainly linked to one of the components of working memory as proposed by Baddeley. The phonological loop, visual-spatial sketchpad and central executive have been studied using a dual-task methodology with 7 different secondary tasks. 35 undergraduate and graduate students were timed in their response time for mental calculation and error rates were calculated. Results show clear differences of operations and of number pairs. Interaction between conditions and operations was just approaching significance. Results did not give support to the idea that operations can be linked to a certain working memory component. Several factors, such as language, problem size, lack for detail in the working memory model, difficulty of the secondary tasks, and internal validity problems are discussed with regard to the results and mental arithmetic.</p>

L'arithmétique est une des inventions majeures de l'humanité, mais il nous manque encore une compréhension globale de la façon dont le cerveau calcule les additions et soustractions. J'ai utilisé une nouvelle méthode comportementale basée sur un suivi de trajectoire capable de disséquer la succession des étapes de traitement impliquées dans les calculs arithmétiques. Les résultats sont compatibles avec un modèle de déplacement pas à pas sur une ligne numérique mentale, en commençant par l'opérande le plus grand et en ajoutant ou soustrayant de manière incrémentielle l'opérande le plus petit. Ensuite, j'ai analysé les signaux électrophysiologiques enregistrés à partir du cortex humain pendant que les sujets résolvaient des additions. L'activité globale dans le sillon intrapariétal augmentait au fur et à mesure que les opérandes grossissaient, prouvant son implication dans le calcul et la prise de décision. Étonnamment, les sites dans le gyrus temporal inférieur postérieur ont montré que l’activation initiale diminuait en fonction de la taille du problème, suggérant un engagement dans l'identification précoce de la difficulté de calcul. Enfin, j'ai enregistré des signaux de magnétoencéphalographie pendant que les sujets vérifiaient les additions et soustractions. En appliquant des techniques d'apprentissage automatique, j'ai étudié l'évolution temporelle des codes de représentation des opérandes et fourni une première image complète d'une cascade d'étapes de traitement en cours sous-jacentes au calcul arithmétique. Ainsi, cette dissertation fournit-elle plusieurs contributions sur la façon dont les concepts mathématiques élémentaires sont mis en œuvre dans le cerveau. / Arithmetic is one of the most important cultural inventions of humanity, however we still lack a comprehensive understanding of how the brain computes additions and subtractions. In the first study, I used a novel behavioral method based on trajectory tracking capable of dissecting the succession of processing stages involved in arithmetic computations. Results supported a model whereby single-digit arithmetic is computed by a stepwise displacement on a spatially organized mental number line, starting with the larger operand and incrementally adding or subtracting the smaller operand. In a second study, I analyzed electrophysiological signals recorded from the human cortex while subjects solved addition problems. I found that the overall activity in the intraparietal sulcus increased as the operands got larger, providing evidence for its involvement in arithmetic computation and decision-making. Surprisingly, sites within the posterior inferior temporal gyrus showed an initial burst of activity that decreased as a function of problem-size, suggesting an engagement in the early identification of the calculation difficulty. Lastly, I recorded magnetoencephalography signals while subjects verified additions and subtractions. By applying machine learning techniques, I investigated the temporal evolution of the representational codes of the operands and provided a first comprehensive picture of a cascade of unfolding processing stages underlying arithmetic calculation. Overall, this dissertation provides several contributions to our knowledge about how elementary mathematical concepts are implemented in the brain.

Syftet med denna studie är att identifiera lärares reflektioner om en specifik uppgift om olika additionsstrategier som har genomförts i en matematiklektion i Shanghai. Den frågeställning som studien syftar att besvara är: ·         Vad karaktäriserar lärarnas reflektioner? Studien är genomförd med kvalitativa intervjuer som metod och fyra lärare som undervisar i matematik har intervjuats. Lärarna som intervjuats har olika undervisningserfarenheter med avseende att bredda studiens urval. För att fånga och fokusera på lärarnas reflektioner har det teoretiska ramverket six-lens framework (SLF) använts som inspiration till intervjufrågorna. Ramverket består av olika linser, det vill säga olika aspekter av matematikundervisningen.  I resultatet anser lärarna vikten av att elever behöver behärska flera olika strategier. Detta för att elever ska ha möjlighet att utveckla taluppfattning och nå målen i matematik. Det framgår även att tals del-helhetsrelationer är en viktig del inom grundläggande taluppfattning för att elever ska utveckla strategier. Vidare framgår det i resultatet att det är effektivt att lyfta flera strategier tidigt i undervisningen samt jämföra likheter och skillnader mellan dessa. / The purpose of this study is to identify teachers' reflections on a specific task about different addition strategies that have been implemented in a mathematics lesson in Shanghai. The question that the study aims to answer is: • What characterizes teachers' reflections?  The study was conducted with qualitative interviews as a method and four teachers who teach mathematics were interviewed. The teachers who have been interviewed have different teaching experiences with regard to broaden the study selection. To capture and focus on teachers' reflections, the theoretical framework six-lens framework (SLF) has been used as inspiration for the interview questions. The framework consists of different lenses, which are different aspects of mathematics teaching.  The results shows that students need to know several different strategies because they should have the opportunity to develop knowledge of number sens and achieve the goals in mathematics. It is also clear that part-whole relationships of numbers are basic knowledge for students to develop strategies. Furthermore, it appears effective to teach multiple strategies early in the teaching and compare similarities and differences between these.

This study was conducted to analyse aspects of mental computation within primary school mathematics curricula and to formulate recommendations to inform future revisions to the Number strand of mathematics syllabuses for primary schools. The analyses were undertaken from past, contemporary, and futures perspectives. Although this study had syllabus development in Queensland as a prime focus, its findings and recommendations have an international applicability. Little has been documented in relation to the nature and role of mental computation in mathematics curricula in Australia (McIntosh, Bana, & Farrell, 1995,p. 2), despite an international resurgence of interest by mathematics educators. This resurgence has arisen from a recognition that computing mentally remains a viable computational alternative in a technological age, and that the development of mental procedures contributes to the formation of powerful mathematical thinking strategies (R. E. Reys, 1992, p. 63). The emphasis needs to be placed upon the mental processes involved, and it is this which distinguishes mental computation from mental arithmetic, as defined in this study. Traditionally, the latter has been concerned with speed and accuracy rather than with the mental strategies used to arrive at the correct answers. In Australia, the place of mental computation in mathematics curricula is only beginning to be seriously considered. Little attention has been given to teaching, as opposed to testing, mental computation. Additionally, such attention has predominantly been confined to those calculations needed to be performed mentally to enable the efficient use of the conventional written algorithms. Teachers are inclined to associate mental computation with isolated facts, most commonly the basic ones, rather than with the interrelationships between numbers and the methods used to calculate. To enhance the use of mental computation and to achieve an improvement in performance levels, children need to be encouraged to value all methods of computation, and to place a priority on mental procedures. This requires that teachers be encouraged to change the way in which they view mental computation. An outcome of this study is to provide the background and recommendations for this to occur. The mathematics education literature of relevance to mental computation was analysed, and its nature and function, together with the approaches to teaching, under each of the Queensland mathematics syllabuses from 1860 to 1997 were documented. Three distinct time-periods were analysed: 1860-1965, 1966-1987, and post-1987. The first of these was characterised by syllabuses which included specific references to calculating mentally. To provide insights into the current status of mental computation in Queensland primary schools, a survey of a representative sample of teachers and administrators was undertaken. The statements in the postal, self-completion opinionnaire were based on data from the literature review. This study, therefore, has significance for Queensland educational history, curriculum development, and pedagogy. The review of mental computation research indicated that the development of flexible mental strategies is influenced by the order in which mental and written techniques are introduced. Therefore, the traditional written-mental sequence needs to be reevaluated. As a contribution to this reevaluation, this study presents a mental-written sequence for introducing each of the four operations. However, findings from the survey of Queensland school personnel revealed that a majority disagreed with the proposition that an emphasis on written algorithms should be delayed to allow increased attention on mental computation. Hence, for this sequence to be successfully introduced, much professional debate and experimentation needs to occur to demonstrate its efficacy to teachers. Of significance to the development of efficient mental techniques is the way in which mental computation is taught. R. E. Reys, B. J. Reys, Nohda, and Emori (1995, p. 305) have suggested that there are two broad approaches to teaching mental computation,,Ya behaviourist approach and a constructivist approach. The former views mental computation as a basic skill and is considered an essential prerequisite to written computation, with proficiency gained through direct teaching. In contrast, the constructivist approach contends that mental computation is a process of higher-order thinking in which the act of generating and applying mental strategies is significant for an individual's mathematical development. Nonetheless, this study has concluded that there may be a place for the direct teaching of selected mental strategies. To support syllabus development, a sequence of mental strategies appropriate for focussed teaching for each of the four operations has been delineated. The implications for teachers with respect to these recommendations are discussed. Their implementation has the potential to severely threaten many teachersf sense of efficacy. To support the changed approach to developing competence with mental computation, aspects requiring further theoretical and empirical investigation are also outlined.