Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-28T18:22:11Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Erisana Celia Sanches Victoriano.pdf: 3011444 bytes, checksum: 0077e3316d46d2f7b287c64a52b1f91d (MD5) Previous issue date: 2010-10-26 / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / The new ICTs have been used in face-to-face and distance courses to support and enrich teaching-learning processes. However, their use demands planning and adequacy so that it corresponds to educational goals. For this reason, many studies have been developed. They usually focus on the use of the tools, or on the roles teachers and students play during the interactions (Gervai, 2007; Costa, 2005; Leal, 2005). However, these investigations do not seem to consider language as central in teaching-learning processes; they do not discuss the importance of pedagogic practice and the knowledge structure that are involved in the interactions. In order to contribute to the filling of these gaps, this research was suggested. Therefore, the general objective of this study is to contribute to the improvement on the use of ICTs, more specifically to the use of synchronous communication tools in educational contexts, by considering language as central in teaching-learning processes. In order to reach this goal, seven synchronous sessions (chats) were collected from a distance course that was offered for teachers of English. In addition, the data were analysed under two theoretical frameworks: the systemic-functional theory and the Bernstenian social theory. The analysis developed during this research favoured detailed comprehension about some kinds of interactions that can take place in online synchronous communication in educational contexts, as it highlighted differences in the pedagogic and discursive practices, and in the knowledge structure during the sessions. The analysis developed with the support of the systemic-functional approach for the description of conversations, exchange structure (Martin, 1992), allowed a detailed study of some discursive practices that can take place during this kind of communication. This analysis, combined with the concepts of regulative and instructional discourse suggested in the Bernsteinian theory (Bernstein, 1990), allowed reflections about pedagogic practices that had been involved in the online synchronous sessions. Finally, the concept of entity (Martin and Rose, 2003) and the concepts of horizontal and vertical discourse (Bernstein, 1990) contributed to the comprehension about the nature of knowledge which had been involved in the interactions. This research indicates that the combination of the systemic-functional theory and the Bernsteinian theory can be powerful for the comprehension of language, pedagogic practices and different nature of knowledge that were brought to the interactions; and, it presents results which can contribute to an adequate use of chats in educational contexts , and to the quality of distance education / As tecnologias de informação e comunicação (TICs) vêm sendo usadas em cursos presenciais e a distância com o objetivo apoiar e enriquecer o ensino-aprendizagem. Porém, seu uso exige planejamento e adequação para que corresponda aos objetivos educacionais. Por esse motivo, muitos estudos vêm sendo conduzidos. Esses estudos geralmente focam o uso das próprias ferramentas, ou o papel de professores e alunos durante as interações (Gervai, 2007; Costa, 2005; Leal, 2005). No entanto, essas investigações não consideram a centralidade da linguagem no ensino-aprendizagem, e não discutem a importância da prática pedagógica e das naturezas do conhecimento envolvidas nas interações. Para contribuir com o preenchimento dessas lacunas, esta pesquisa foi proposta. Dessa forma, o objetivo geral deste trabalho é contribuir para o aprimoramento do uso das TICs, mais especificamente com o uso de ferramentas de comunicação síncrona, em contexto educacional considerando a centralidade lingüística em contextos de ensino-aprendizagem. Para tal, sete sessões síncronas online (bate-papos) foram coletadas de um curso a distância, oferecido para professores de inglês. Além disso, os dados foram analisados sob duas perspectivas teóricas: a teoria sistêmico-funcional e a teoria social Bernsteiniana. Ao apontar diferenças nas práticas discursivas e pedagógicas, e na estrutura do conhecimento durante as sessões, a análise conduzida durante essa pesquisa ajudou a compreender mais detalhadamente o tipo de interação que pode acontecer em comunicações síncronas online em contexto educacional. A análise conduzida com ajuda do conceito sistêmico-funcional de estrutura da troca (Martin, 1992) possibilitou um estudo detalhado de algumas práticas discursivas que podem acontecer neste tipo de comunicação online. Essa análise, combinada com os conceitos de discurso regulador e instrucional propostos na teoria bernsteiniana (Bernstein, 1990) permitiu reflexões sobre as práticas pedagógicas que estiveram envolvidas nas sessões síncronas online. Por fim, o conceito de entidade (Martin e Rose, 2003) e os conceitos de discurso horizontal e discurso vertical (Bernstein, 1990), colaboraram para o entendimento sobre a natureza dos conhecimentos envolvidos nas interações. Esta pesquisa indica que a combinação da teoria sistêmico-funcional com a teoria Bernsteiniana mostra-se ferramenta poderosa para a compreensão da linguagem, da prática pedagógica e das diferentes naturezas de conhecimentos trazidos para contextos educacionais; e, apresenta resultados que podem contribuir com usos adequados de ferramentas síncronas digitais em contexto educacional e, assim, com a melhoria da qualidade da educação a distância.

Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-28T18:22:12Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Erisana Celia Sanches Victoriano.pdf: 3011444 bytes, checksum: 0077e3316d46d2f7b287c64a52b1f91d (MD5) Previous issue date: 2010-10-26 / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior / The new ICTs have been used in face-to-face and distance courses to support and enrich teaching-learning processes. However, their use demands planning and adequacy so that it corresponds to educational goals. For this reason, many studies have been developed. They usually focus on the use of the tools, or on the roles teachers and students play during the interactions (Gervai, 2007; Costa, 2005; Leal, 2005). However, these investigations do not seem to consider language as central in teaching-learning processes; they do not discuss the importance of pedagogic practice and the knowledge structure that are involved in the interactions. In order to contribute to the filling of these gaps, this research was suggested. Therefore, the general objective of this study is to contribute to the improvement on the use of ICTs, more specifically to the use of synchronous communication tools in educational contexts, by considering language as central in teaching-learning processes. In order to reach this goal, seven synchronous sessions (chats) were collected from a distance course that was offered for teachers of English. In addition, the data were analysed under two theoretical frameworks: the systemic-functional theory and the Bernstenian social theory. The analysis developed during this research favoured detailed comprehension about some kinds of interactions that can take place in online synchronous communication in educational contexts, as it highlighted differences in the pedagogic and discursive practices, and in the knowledge structure during the sessions. The analysis developed with the support of the systemic-functional approach for the description of conversations, exchange structure (Martin, 1992), allowed a detailed study of some discursive practices that can take place during this kind of communication. This analysis, combined with the concepts of regulative and instructional discourse suggested in the Bernsteinian theory (Bernstein, 1990), allowed reflections about pedagogic practices that had been involved in the online synchronous sessions. Finally, the concept of entity (Martin and Rose, 2003) and the concepts of horizontal and vertical discourse (Bernstein, 1990) contributed to the comprehension about the nature of knowledge which had been involved in the interactions. This research indicates that the combination of the systemic-functional theory and the Bernsteinian theory can be powerful for the comprehension of language, pedagogic practices and different nature of knowledge that were brought to the interactions; and, it presents results which can contribute to an adequate use of chats in educational contexts , and to the quality of distance education / As tecnologias de informação e comunicação (TICs) vêm sendo usadas em cursos presenciais e a distância com o objetivo apoiar e enriquecer o ensino-aprendizagem. Porém, seu uso exige planejamento e adequação para que corresponda aos objetivos educacionais. Por esse motivo, muitos estudos vêm sendo conduzidos. Esses estudos geralmente focam o uso das próprias ferramentas, ou o papel de professores e alunos durante as interações (Gervai, 2007; Costa, 2005; Leal, 2005). No entanto, essas investigações não consideram a centralidade da linguagem no ensino-aprendizagem, e não discutem a importância da prática pedagógica e das naturezas do conhecimento envolvidas nas interações. Para contribuir com o preenchimento dessas lacunas, esta pesquisa foi proposta. Dessa forma, o objetivo geral deste trabalho é contribuir para o aprimoramento do uso das TICs, mais especificamente com o uso de ferramentas de comunicação síncrona, em contexto educacional considerando a centralidade lingüística em contextos de ensino-aprendizagem. Para tal, sete sessões síncronas online (bate-papos) foram coletadas de um curso a distância, oferecido para professores de inglês. Além disso, os dados foram analisados sob duas perspectivas teóricas: a teoria sistêmico-funcional e a teoria social Bernsteiniana. Ao apontar diferenças nas práticas discursivas e pedagógicas, e na estrutura do conhecimento durante as sessões, a análise conduzida durante essa pesquisa ajudou a compreender mais detalhadamente o tipo de interação que pode acontecer em comunicações síncronas online em contexto educacional. A análise conduzida com ajuda do conceito sistêmico-funcional de estrutura da troca (Martin, 1992) possibilitou um estudo detalhado de algumas práticas discursivas que podem acontecer neste tipo de comunicação online. Essa análise, combinada com os conceitos de discurso regulador e instrucional propostos na teoria bernsteiniana (Bernstein, 1990) permitiu reflexões sobre as práticas pedagógicas que estiveram envolvidas nas sessões síncronas online. Por fim, o conceito de entidade (Martin e Rose, 2003) e os conceitos de discurso horizontal e discurso vertical (Bernstein, 1990), colaboraram para o entendimento sobre a natureza dos conhecimentos envolvidos nas interações. Esta pesquisa indica que a combinação da teoria sistêmico-funcional com a teoria Bernsteiniana mostra-se ferramenta poderosa para a compreensão da linguagem, da prática pedagógica e das diferentes naturezas de conhecimentos trazidos para contextos educacionais; e, apresenta resultados que podem contribuir com usos adequados de ferramentas síncronas digitais em contexto educacional e, assim, com a melhoria da qualidade da educação a distância

Over the past twenty years, the idea that planning and development practices should be ‘sustainable’ has become a key tenet of discourses characterising the field of planning and development. As part of the agenda to balance and integrate economic, environmental and social interests, democratic participatory governance arrangements are frequently purported to be necessary to achieve ‘sustainable development’ at both local and global levels. Despite the theoretical disjuncture between ideas of democratic civic participation, on the one hand, and civic participation as a means to achieve pre-determined sustainability goals on the other, notions of civic participation for sustainability have become integral features of sustainable development discourses. Underpinned by a conceptual and methodological intent to perform an epistemological ‘break’ with notions of civic participation for sustainability, this thesis explicates how citizens are enrolled in the sustainable development agenda in the discourse of policy. More specifically, it examines how assumptions about civic participation in sustainable development policy discourses operate, and unpacks some discursive strategies through which policy language ‘enrols’ citizens in the same set of assumptions around their normative requirement for participation in sustainable development. Focussing in on a case study sustainable development policy document – a draft regional plan representing a case of ‘enrolling the citizen in sustainability’ - it employs three sociological perspectives/methods that progressively highlight some of the ways that the policy language enjoins citizens as active participants in ‘sustainable’ regional planning. As a thesis-by-publication, the application of each perspective/method is reported in the form of an article prepared for publication in an academic journal. In a departure from common-sense understandings of civic participation for sustainability, the first article examines the governmentality of sustainable development policy. Specifically, this article explores how civic community – particularly community rights and responsibilities – are deployed in the policy discourse as techniques of government that shape and regulate the conduct of subjects. In this respect, rather than seeing civic community as a specific ‘thing’ and participation as corresponding to particular types of ‘activities’, this paper demonstrates how notions of civic participation are constructed and mobilised in the language of sustainable development policy in ways that facilitate government ‘at a distance’. The second article begs another kind of question of the policy – one concerned more specifically with how the everyday practices of subjects become aligned with the principles of sustainable development. This paper, therefore, investigates the role of pedagogy in establishing governance relations in which citizens are called to participate as part of the problematic of sustainability. The analysis suggests that viewing the case study policy in terms of relationships of informal pedagogy provided insights into the positioning of the citizen as an ‘acquirer’ of sustainability principles. In this instance, the pedagogic values of the text provide for low levels of discretion in how citizens could position themselves in the moral order of the discourse. This results in a strong injunction for citizens to subscribe to sustainability principles in a participatory spirit coupled with the requirement for citizens to delegate to the experts to carry out these principles. The third article represents a further breakdown of the ways in which citizens become enrolled in ‘sustainable’ regional planning within the language of the case study policy. Applying an ethnomethodological perspective, specifically Membership Categorization Analysis, this article examines the way ‘the citizen’ and ‘civic values and obligations’ are produced in the interactional context of the text. This study shows how the generation of a substantive moral order that ties the citizen to sustainable values and obligations with respect to the region, is underpinned by a normative morality associated with the production of orderliness in ‘text-in-interaction’. As such, it demonstrates how the production and positioning of ‘the citizen’ in relation to the institutional authors of the policy, and the region more generally, are practical accomplishments that orient the reader to identify him/herself as a ‘citizen’ and embrace the ‘civic values and obligations’ to which he/she is bound. Together, the different conceptual and methodological approaches applied in the thesis provide a more holistic picture of the different ways in which citizens are discursively enrolled in the sustainability agenda. At the substantive level, each analysis reveals a different dimension of how the active citizen is mobilised as a responsible agent for sustainable development. In this respect, civic participation for sustainability is actualised and reproduced through the realms of language, not necessarily through applied occasions of civic participation in the ‘taken-for-granted’ sense. Furthermore, at the conceptual and methodological level, the thesis makes a significant contribution to sociological inquiry into relationships of governance. Rather than residing within the boundaries of a specific sociological perspective, it shows how different approaches that would traditionally be applied in a mutually exclusive manner, can complement each other to advance understanding of how governance discourses operate. In this respect, it provides a rigorous conceptual and methodological platform for further investigations into how citizens become enrolled in programmes of government.