Master of Science / Biology / Michael Tobler / Environmental variation can shape phenotypic variation in organisms. Most evidence for trait differentiation along environmental gradients comes from analyses of dichotomous habitat types that differ in only one or few environmental factors. In reality, however, environmental variation is often more subtle, gradual, and multifarious. I investigated geographic variation in body shape, trophic resource use, and individual diet specialization in two species of darters (Etheostoma spectabile and E. flabellare; Percidae) that occur along river gradients. I explicitly tested how abiotic and biotic environmental factors shape trait variation within and between species. Results indicated significant among population variation in the body shape of both species. Population differences in body shape were correlated with variation in substrate composition. Although body shape analyses revealed a small but significant signal of convergent evolution of body shape when both species occur in sympatry, E. spectabile and E. flabellare mostly exhibited unique responses to shared sources of selection. The analyses of darter trophic resource use uncovered significant resource partitioning between the two species and geographic variation in diets that is likely driven by differences in resource availability. Furthermore, the majority of populations exhibited significant individual specialization. Variation in individual specialization in populations of E. flabellare was related to invertebrate density and competitor richness, and in E. spectabile to the combined effects of invertebrate density and invertebrate diversity. My results indicate substantial variation in trophic resource use among individuals, populations, and species of small-bodied fishes that are typically assumed to be generalist insectivores. Variation in diet specialization may be more widespread than previously considered, and ecological opportunity is an important factor in shaping trophic resource use of individuals and populations. Overall, the results indicate that even subtle and gradual environmental variation can induce substantial variation in phenotypes on a relatively small spatial scale.

Orientador: Márcio Silva Araújo / Resumo: A variação individual no uso de recursos alimentares pode depender de fatores ecológicos como a competição intra e interespecífica, predação, além da diversidade e abundância de recursos. O objetivo deste trabalho foi identificar as causas da variação individual no uso de recursos alimentares em populações do peixe Characidium schubarti, conh’ecido como “charutinho” e descrito como insetívoro bentônico. O estudo foi realizado em riachos de Mata Atlântica no Parque Estadual Carlos Botelho, núcleo São Miguel Arcanjo, região sudeste do Estado de São Paulo. Os charutinhos foram coletados ao longo de transectos em 11 riachos diferentes. Foram coletadas amostras da comunidade de invertebrados bentônicos em cada riacho para a obtenção de estimativas da diversidade e abundância de recursos alimentares. Identificamos e quantificamos todas as possíveis espécies de peixes competidoras (insetívoros bentônicos). Nossos resultados sugerem significativa variação na dieta dos indivíduos de todas as populações, porém com baixo grau de especialização individual. Nós não encontramos efeito significativo da oportunidade ecológica (diversidade de recursos), produtividade secundária (biomassa de recursos) e competição (densidade de charutinhos e competidores) sobre o grau de variação na dieta nas populações estudadas. / Abstract: Individual variation in food resource use can depend on ecological factors such as intra and interspecific competition, predation, and the diversity and abundance of resources. Our main goal in this study was to identify the ecological causes of individual variation in the use of food resources in natural populations of the fish Characidium schubarti, part of a group popularly known as “South American darters”, described as benthic insectivores. The study was conducted in Atlantic Forest streams at the Carlos Botelho State Park, at São Miguel Arcanjo, in the southeast of the state of São Paulo. Specimens were collected along transects in 11 streams. We collected samples from the benthic invertebrate community in each stream to estimate the diversity and abundance of food resources. We identified and quantified all possible competing species of fishes (benthic insectivores). Our results suggest significant variation in the diet of individuals from all populations, however, with a low degree of individual specialization. We found no significant effect of ecological opportunity (resource diversity), secondary productivity (resource biomass) and competition (density of charutinhos and competitors) on the degree of dietary variation in the studied populations. / Mestre