Staphylococcus schleiferi, Staphylococcus lugdunensis, and Staphylococcus epidermidis produce a high incidence of abscesses in a mouse model with an implanted foreign body. We investigated the significance of the foreign body in this process. Fourteen strains of S. schleiferi, S. epidermidis, and S. lugdunensis were tested in our model. A preadhered foreign body was implanted into one mouse group, followed by injection of a test strain. Another group received injection without implant. Abscesses were assessed at 7 days; foreign bodies and infected tissues were cultured. The percent of samples that developed abscesses or were culture positive was compared for each strain. Nearly all mice infected with S. schleiferi developed abscesses and were culture positive. The foreign body made no difference in abscess formation for three of four S. schleiferi but increased the incidence of both organism recovery and abscess for three of five S. epidermidis. The foreign body enhanced abscess formation for four of five S. lugdunensis, with all five strains yielding significantly more culture recovery. Although the pathogenicity of nine strains was increased by the foreign body, five strains yielded high abscess and culture recovery rates that were not enhanced by its presence.