Interest has grown over the last two decades in the health benefits of polyphenols, with
particular relation to degenerative diseases. The Kei apple (Dovyalis caffra) is an indigenous
plant to South Africa, thought to be rich in polyphenols. This study aimed to produce a
functional beverage from the Kei apple, with demonstrable nutritional benefits, which should
also be found acceptable by consumers due to its sensory attributes. A long term aim of the
study is to assist in improving income of farmers in rural and urban areas by encouraging the
participation of small holders in growing the Kei apple for subsequent economic benefit. A
thorough literature review was conducted on functional foods, trends for beverages, legislation
and on polyphenols as a class of functional ingredients, specifically focusing on fruits and the
fate of polyphenols in the body. A review of fruit processing procedures, preservation
techniques and legislation, followed by new product development (NPD) and the types of
consumers desiring functional foods were investigated as well as the role of sensory evaluation
and consumer research were examined.
Methods
Kei apples were collected from two areas of South Africa, namely Bloemhof in the North West
Province in the 200212003 growing season and from the Eastern and Western Cape in the
200412005 growing season. The first set of Kei apples were used to produce a prototype
functional beverage, from which future development would take place. The second set of Kei
apples were used for pulping on an industrial scale and then a small-scale commercial
production batch of the Kei apple beverages for consumer panel testing was produced.
Various flavours were used to mask the strong characteristic taste and aroma of the Kei apple
for the beverage and these were narrowed down to apple, vanilla and mint 8. vanilla.
Consumer panel testing was undertaken with 152 consumers with a pre-tested questionnaire
using hedonic scales for overall acceptance, ranking for preference, a Fwd Action Rating
Scale (FACT) for consumption intent, and a ranking test for purchase intent. All evaluations
were carried out under strictly controlled sensory evaluation requirement and respondents were
asked to fill in anonymous questionnaires at North West University, Potchefstroom Campus.
Results and Discussion
Statistical analysis of the results were determined by the Statistic* programme, version 7. In
summary for all of the consumer testing, it was found that consumers regarded the apple
flavoured Kei apple beverage statistically significantly more acceptable than the other flavours.
The apple flavoured beverage was found to be rated practically significantly higher for the
attributes of taste and overall acceptance, as well as for consumption intent, purchase intent
and preference. There was, however, no significant differences in any of the attributes or
evaluated consumption and purchase intent between the vanilla and mint & vanilla. The total
polyphenols, determined by UV spectrophotometry as gallic acid equivalents per litre (GAE/I),
were found to be slightly less then expected, with the apple and mint & vanilla showing similar
results (as GAEII) 101.7 versus 106.1 for the latter two, whilst vanilla was 143.0 which may
have been attributed to the vanillic acid molecule itself which also has a phenolic structure.
This lower-than-expected level of total polyphenols may have been due to degradation during
processing. There was a clear difference in the polyphenol content between the different
harvests from the two regions. The former showed greater acidity as determined by total citric
acid 4.81% w/w and sugar 16.3% versus 2.54% w/w and 8.4% This may be due to various
factors of climate, soil and ripeness. For comparison purposes, a commercial product from the
USA, Ocean Spray ® Cranberry, was also found to have more polyphenols present than the Kei
apple beverage. This was also demonstrated by the amount of ascorbic acid, free and bound.
The Kei apple beverage subjected to pasteurization probably lost most of its vitamin C content
due to the heat treatment and the exposure to oxygen during pulping.
Conclusion and Recommendations
The development of a functional beverage from the Kei apple is feasible. As with most new
product developments, further formulation modifications which are not insurmountable are
required. The consumer panel was positive towards the apple flavoured beverage and this
flavour should be taken forward for future development. The key stumbling block to the
success of this project is the lack of an effective organizing body that could liaise with the
growers to form a cooperative and provide a consistent supply of Kei apples. The effect of
variations in harvesting time, soil conditions and climate must also be evaluated. The
improvement of income of farmers may only be achieved by the involvement of other stake
holders and the formation of a Kei apple grower's co-operative / Thesis (M.Sc. (Nutrition))--North-West University, Potchefstroom Campus, 2006.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:netd.ac.za/oai:union.ndltd.org:nwu/oai:dspace.nwu.ac.za:10394/1198 |
| Date | January 2005 |
| Creators | Gore, Mary Jane Cook |
| Publisher | North-West University |
| Source Sets | South African National ETD Portal |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Thesis |
Page generated in 0.0024 seconds