There are currently many statements about the effects of hemispheric specialization of the brain upon children's cognitive processing and therefore, upon content or modes of instruction. Before educators can accept or even test these statements, it is important to devise easy-to-use measures of hemispheric functioning and to study their relationship to established measures of achievement and linguistic and cognitive development.
Current research in brain functioning has indicated that conjugate-lateral eye movement direction (the direction in which a person looks while thinking) can be a sensitive indicator of which cerebral hemisphere is initially activated. The central purpose of this investigation was to analyze the effects of the stimulus characteristics of reflective questions of verbal and spatial nature on the conjugate-lateral eye movement (CLEM) behavior of right-handed children from fourth, fifth, and sixth grades. A major objective was to determine whether data on children’s CLEM responses would better support a model of characteristic individual differences or a model of differentiation by question type. The testing instrument devised for this purpose was the Reflective Questions Test (RQT) which included both Verbal and Spatial subtests. In an experimenter-facing-subject paradigm with a sample of 60 (30 boys, 30 girls), conjugate-lateral eye movement was found to be easily observable and question type was found to influence the direction of eye movement, thus supporting a differentiation by question type model. Verbal questions elicited significantly more rightward CLEMs than spatial questions and spatial questions elicited significantly more leftward CLEMs than verbal questions fn the sample studied. No significant sex differences were found. These results seem to be consistent with the neuropsychological theory that once hemispheric specialization has occurred with normal right-handed children, the left hemisphere mediates language functions and the right hemisphere mediates spatial functions.
Examining the number of directionally appropriate CLEM responses, a two-way analysis of variance (verbal and spatial question type by grade level) yielded no main or interaction effects. The results suggest that although children in grades four, five, and six tended to gaze in different directions while responding to verbal than while responding to spatial questions, the rate of responses appropriate to the question (gazing in the direction predicted) was no greater for verbal than for spatial questions. Further, the means for question types were almost identical across grade levels for CLEM responses to verbal and to spatial questions, supporting a no-change model of neuropsychological function, which contends that within the later childhood years, hemispheric specialization is well developed.
The Reflective Questions Test was found to have high inter-rater reliability (.94) and temporal stability (.78). These results indicate that the RQT produced reliable and stable results for the sample studied and support the appropriateness of the RQT for future refinement and use in educational research of this type. Correlations of the RQT with other measures of linguistic and cognitive development, and educational ability were found to be nonsignificant. These results suggest that hemispheric activation as indexed by the RQT at this age range may be largely independent of measures traditionally associated with school performance.
The results of this investigation have provided normative data on normal right-handed children, thereby providing a comparative basis for future research with children of the same age from other populations such as the learning disabled. / Ed. D.
Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:VTETD/oai:vtechworks.lib.vt.edu:10919/76561 |
Date | January 1981 |
Creators | Daly, Jo Ann Elizabeth |
Contributors | Curriculum and Instruction |
Publisher | Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University |
Source Sets | Virginia Tech Theses and Dissertation |
Language | en_US |
Detected Language | English |
Type | Dissertation, Text |
Format | ix, 111, [3] leaves, application/pdf, application/pdf |
Rights | In Copyright, http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/ |
Relation | OCLC# 8126930 |
Page generated in 0.0024 seconds