Mild Traumatic Brain Injury (mTBI), often called concussion, has become a growing public health concern, prevalent in both athletic and military settings. In response, many researchers have explored cognitive outcomes post-mTBI, with a plethora of meta-analyses summarizing these findings; however, these meta-analyses examine solely mean performances on cognitive tasks, ignoring intra-individual variability (IIV) in cognitive performance that may elucidate neuropsychological impairment following mTBI. The current thesis involved two studies, responding to both the growing meta-analytic research and limited IIV findings.
Study 1: Many meta-analyses have amalgamated individual study results on post-mTBI neuropsychological outcomes. With the abundance of meta-analyses, a systematic review of meta-analyses stands as the next logical step. Method: A systematic literature search yielded 11 meta-analyses meeting inclusion criteria (i.e., English-language systematic reviews/meta-analyses covering post-mTBI observational cognitive research on late adolescents/adults), with their findings qualitatively synthesized based on moderator variables (i.e., cognitive domain, time since injury, past head injury, participant characteristics, comparison group, assessment technique, and persistent symptoms). Results: The overall effect sizes ranged for both general (range: .07-.61) and sports-related mTBI (range: .40-.81) and differed both between and within cognitive domains, with executive functions appearing most sensitive to multiple mTBI. Cognitive domains varied in recovery rates, but overall recovery occurred by 90 days post-injury for most individuals and by seven days post-injury for athletes. Greater age/education and male gender produced smaller effects sizes, while high school athletes suffered the largest deficits post-mTBI. Control-group comparisons yielded larger effects than within-person designs, while assessment techniques had limited moderating effects. Conclusions: Overall, meta-analytic review quality remained low with few studies assessing publication or study quality bias. Meta-analyses consistently identified adverse acute mTBI-related effects and fairly rapid symptom resolution.
Study 2: The long-term outcomes of executive functions and IIV following mTBI are unclear due to inconsistent and limited research, respectively. Further, the relationship between physical activity (PA) and cognitive performance at young adulthood remains almost fully unexplored. In turn, the current study aimed to (a) assess the diagnostic utility of both executive functions and IIV at predicting mTBI history and (b) evaluate the interaction between PA levels and mTBI on both of these cognitive metrics. Method: Altogether 138 self-identified athletes (Mage = 19.9 ± 1.91 years, 60.8% female, 19.6% 1 mTBI, 18.1% 2+ mTBIs) completed three executive-related cognitive tasks (i.e., N-Back, Go/No-go, Local-Global). Ordinal logistic regression analyses examined the joint effect of person-mean and IIV as predictors of mTBI status. Multi-level models examined mTBI and PA levels as predictors of trial-to-trial changes in performance. Results: Only mean response time (RT) for the Local-Global task predicted mTBI status, while no IIV variables reached unique significance. PA levels predicted subtle within-task decreases in RT across Local-Global trials. Conclusions: IIV research on mTBI remains limited; however, the preliminary results do not indicate any additional predictive value of IIV indices above mean performances. For executive functions, shifting appeared most affected, with past researchers identifying post-mTBI impairment in attentional processing. Higher PA levels minutely benefited within-task shifting and mean inhibitory performance, although these finding require cautious interpretation. / Graduate / 0622 / jkarr@uvic.ca
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:uvic.ca/oai:dspace.library.uvic.ca:1828/4716 |
| Date | 01 August 2013 |
| Creators | Karr, Justin Elliott |
| Contributors | Garcia-Barrera, Mauricio A. |
| Source Sets | University of Victoria |
| Language | English |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Thesis |
| Rights | Available to the World Wide Web |
Page generated in 0.0021 seconds