Sepsis is a clinical syndrome characterized by the systemic activation of inflammatory and coagulation pathways in response to microbial infection of normally sterile parts of the body. Despite considerable advances in our understanding of sepsis pathophysiology, sepsis remains the leading cause of death in non-coronary intensive care units (ICU) with a global disease burden between 15 and 19 million cases per year (Dellinger et al., 2008). Severe sepsis, defined as sepsis associated with organ dysfunction is associated with mortality rates of 33% to 45%. The incidence of severe sepsis continues to increase by 1.5% per annum due to the aging population, a rise in the prevalence of comorbidities, and the wider use of immunosuppressive agents and invasive procedures (Angus et al., 2001). Over the past several decades, many potential treatments for sepsis have shown early promise, yet have failed to improve survival in over 100 Phase II and Phase III clinical trials (Marshall, 2014) suggesting that some fundamental knowledge is lacking in our understanding of sepsis pathophysiology.
Emerging studies on cell-free DNA (cfDNA), DNA released extracellularly into the circulation, demonstrate that cfDNA is a crucial link between inflammation and coagulation . In various conditions characterized by excessive inflammatory responses or aberrant prothrombotic responses, cfDNA has been implicated in exacerbating disease pathology (Atamaniuk, Kopecky, Skoupy, Säemann, & Weichhart, 2012; Fuchs, Brill, & Wagner, 2012; Swystun, Mukherjee, & Liaw, 2011). In clinical sepsis, levels of cfDNA upon admission into the ICU have strong prognostic value in predicting mortality (Dwivedi et al., 2012; Saukkonen et al., 2008). However, it is unclear whether these increases in cfDNA are an epiphenomenon during sepsis progression, or whether cfDNA actively plays a role in sepsis pathophysiology. In this work, in vivo studies were conducted to characterize the role of cfDNA in sepsis, the effects of DNase administration, and the potential mechanism by which cfDNA is released during experimental sepsis. In addition, mortality studies were conducted to identify surrogate markers of death to promote the design of humane and ethical animal studies in conducting sepsis research.
Polymicrobial sepsis was induced via a surgical procedure whereby the cecum is exteriorized, ligated and punctured twice to introduce a continuous source of microorganisms, a model termed cecal ligation and puncture (CLP). In our CLP sepsis model, levels of cfDNA increased in a time-dependent manner. These increases accompanied an early pro-inflammatory response marked by increased pro-inflammatory IL-6, a transient increase in anti-inflammatory IL-10, and elevated lung myeloperoxidase (MPO) activity. Septic mice with elevated cfDNA levels also had high bacterial loads in the lungs, blood, and peritoneal cavity fluid. Organ damage was also observed in mice following CLP surgery versus mice subjected to the non-septic sham control surgery marked by increased levels of creatinine and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) indicative of kidney and liver injury, respectively. Histological analyses further confirmed lung and kidney damage following CLP surgery. Changes in coagulation were also observed in septic mice as mice subjected to CLP had sustained increases in thrombin-antithrombin (TAT) complexes. In addition, plasma from CLP-operated mice had increased thrombin generation (i.e. increased endogenous thromin potential, increased peak thrombin, decreased time to peak, and decreased lag time) mediated by FXIIa and enhanced by platelets. Following CLP-induced sepsis, elevations in cfDNA levels accompanied pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant responses.
The effects of in vivo DNase treatment in septic mice were time-dependent. Early DNase treatment when cfDNA levels were low resulted in an exaggerated pro-inflammatory response marked by increased plasma IL-6 levels and increased lung damage. In contrast, delayed DNase treatment at time-points when cfDNA levels were elevated suppressed inflammation characterized by an increase in anti-inflammatory IL-10 and reductions in cfDNA, IL-6, lung MPO, and ALT activity. Furthermore, delayed DNase administration resulted in decreased bacterial load in the lungs, blood, and peritoneal cavity fluid. Delayed DNase treatment also resulted in blunted pro-coagulant responses as levels of TAT complexes were suppressed and thrombin generation from septic mouse plasma was normalized. Moreover, DNase treatment when cfDNA levels were elevated increased survival in CLP-operated mice by 80% and reduced lung and liver damage. These findings suggest that administration of DNase when cfDNA levels are elevated may reduce pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant responses and that delayed DNase treatment may infer protection in the CLP model of sepsis.
One mechanism by which cfDNA is released is via the formation of neutrophil extracellular traps (NETs). Upon inflammatory stimulation, some neutrophils release chromatin material and antimicrobial proteins (i.e. neutrophil elastase, MPO, and histones) in an active process termed NETosis. Although NETs ensnare bacteria and exert antimicrobial properties, NETs may also exert harmful effects on the host by activating inflammation and coagulation. While some in vitro evidence suggest that neutrophils are the main source of cfDNA released following inflammatory stimulation, others have reported that neutrophils are not the main source of circulating cfDNA following septic challenge. To determine whether NETs contribute to cfDNA released during CLP sepsis, genetically modified mice that are incapable of forming NETs, PAD4-/- mice, were used. Levels of cfDNA in PAD-/- mice were significantly lower than cfDNA levels in C57Bl/6 mice following CLP surgery, suggesting that NETs were a source of cfDNA in our model. Levels of IL-6, MPO, and bacterial load in the lungs, blood, and peritoneal cavity were significantly reduced, indicating that NETs exert pro-inflammatory effects in CLP sepsis. Thrombin generation was also suppressed in PAD4-/- mice which suggests that NETs contribute to thrombin generation following CLP sepsis. NETs contribute to increases in circulating cfDNA and may exacerbate pathology by driving pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant responses in CLP-induced sepsis.
Appreciating the implications of conducting research using animals, it is pertinent that researchers ensure the highest ethical standards and design animal studies in the most humane, yet scientifically rigorous manner. Using mortality studies, we validated the utility of physiological and phenotypic markers to assess disease severity and predict death in murine sepsis. Temperature via a rectal probe monitor and sepsis scoring systems which assess components such as orbital tightening, level of consciousness, and activity were effective surrogate markers of death. These tools offer a non-invasive assessment of disease progression which do not artificially exacerbate sepsis pathology and immediate information regarding any changes in the health status. Surrogate markers of death also provide reliable monitoring to meet increasing standards of ethical, humane animal research and a feasible and cost-efficient means to obtain vital signs in small rodents. We have proposed a scoring system which can be used for assessing disease severity, endpoint monitoring, and predicting death to obviate inhumane methods of using death as an endpoint in sepsis studies.
In summary, cfDNA levels are elevated in CLP-induced sepsis and these elevations accompany pro-inflammatory and pro-coagulant responses. NETosis may be a mechanism by which cfDNA is released and NETs may drive inflammation and coagulation in CLP sepsis. Delayed DNase administration may suppress inflammation and coagulation and may be protective in polymicrobial sepsis. In future animal sepsis studies, surrogate markers of death and a sepsis scoring system can be used in place of death as an endpoint to raise the standards in conducting ethical, humane sepsis research. / Thesis / Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:mcmaster.ca/oai:macsphere.mcmaster.ca:11375/18719 |
| Date | January 2016 |
| Creators | Mai, Safiah Hwai Chuen |
| Contributors | Liaw, Patricia C., Medical Sciences (Blood and Cardiovascular) |
| Source Sets | McMaster University |
| Language | English |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Thesis |
Page generated in 0.003 seconds