2009年底,台灣蘋果日報推出【動新聞】,因為其以3D動畫的方式詳述性侵、暴力等社會新聞,引發輿論批評,而且國家傳播通訊委員(NCC)也明白指出,電視新聞使用3D動畫非真實呈現,換句話說,民間與官方都一致認為電視新聞使用3D動畫恐怕有損新聞的專業性。有鑑於新聞媒體最重要的價值就是「新聞可信度」,因此,本研究遂將一般閱聽眾視研究對象,採取實驗法進行社會新聞使用3D動畫有無,進行新聞可信度差異研究。
受測者總計52人,依社會新聞次分類分別為突發新聞、犯罪新聞,又依3D動畫有無,共計分為4組,採t檢定檢驗發現,3D動畫有無不會影響新聞可信度,而且突發、犯罪新聞的新聞可信度也無差異;又採二因子變異數檢定發現,新聞可信度不會因為「社會新聞次類型」、「3D動畫有無」或其交互作用產生差異。此外,二因子變異數的檢驗發現,閱聽眾對於3D動畫的既有態度不會影響新聞可信度評估,最後,人口學變項也不會影響新聞可信度評估。
即便本研究初步證實社會新聞使用3D動畫有無,在新聞可信度上並無差異,但相較於沒有使用3D動畫的,有使用的反而獲得較高的平均數。 / At the end of 2009, Taiwan Next Media introduced Animated News, which induced considerable public criticism due to its use of 3D animation to portray social news containing acts of sexual assault and violence. Furthermore, the National Communications Commission (NCC) has clearly pointed out that the 3D animation used in TV news is not a real representation. In other words, both the public and government believe to a large degree that 3D animation used in TV news may harm journalistic professionalism. In view of the fact that the most important value of news media is "news credibility," the study employs experimental methods to determine the difference in the credibility of news in the eyes of research subjects consisting of ordinary viewers that results when social news adopts 3D animation.
The total of 52 respondents were divided into four groups viewing news in the two subcategories of breaking news and crime news either with or without 3D animation. Inspection employing the t-test revealed that the presence of 3D animation does not affect the credibility of news, and no effect was observed in the case of either breaking news or crime news. Two-way ANOVA further discovered that the credibility of news does not vary due to "social news subcategory," "presence of 3D animation," or their interaction. In addition, two-way ANOVA also revealed that viewers' existing attitude toward 3D animation does not influence their assessment of the credibility of news.
This study not only found that the use of 3D animation and social news does not affect the credibility of the news, but also discovered that compared with news not employing 3D animation, news using animation in fact received relatively high average credibility scores.
Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:CHENGCHI/G0099941007 |
Creators | 周欣怡, Chou, Hsin I |
Publisher | 國立政治大學 |
Source Sets | National Chengchi University Libraries |
Language | 中文 |
Detected Language | English |
Type | text |
Rights | Copyright © nccu library on behalf of the copyright holders |
Page generated in 0.0018 seconds