As climate change exacerbates water scarcity and alters available water and fertilizer resources, it is vital that take appropriate measures to ensure sustainable treatment of water, wastewater, and other waste streams that are protective of public health and support recovery and reuse of water and nutrients. The overarching theme of this dissertation is the advancement of next-generation DNA sequencing (NGS) and computational tools for achieving these goals. A suite of relevant fecal and environmental opportunistic pathogens are examined using both culture-based and NGS-based methods. Of particular concern to this research was not only the attenuation and inactivation of pathogens, but also ensuring that optimal treatment approaches reduce antibiotic resistant bacteria (ARB) and antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). Key systems that were the focus of this effort included nutrient reuse (wastewater-derived biosolids and cattle-derived manure), water reuse, and drinking water systems disrupted by a major hurricane.
A field study was carried out to survey a suite of pathogens from source-to tap in six small drinking water systems in Puerto Rico six months after Hurricane Maria. The study revealed that pathogenic Leptospira DNA was detected in all systems that were reliant on surface water. On the other hand, Salmonella spp. was detected in surface and groundwater sources and some distribution system waters both by culture and PCR. The study provided comparison of molecular-, microscopic-, and culture-based analysis for pathogen detection and highlighted the need for disaster preparedness for small water systems, including back-up power supply and access to chlorination as soon as possible after a natural disaster.
A second field-study examined wastewater derived solids across an international transect of wastewater treatment plants in order to gain insight into the range of ARG concentrations encountered. It was found that, while total ARGs did not vary between treatment or continent of origin, clinically-relevant ARGs (i.e., ARGs encoding resistance to important classes of antibiotics used in humans) were significantly higher in solids derived from Asian wastewater treatment plants. Estimated loading rates of ARGs to soil under a scenario of land application were determined, highlighting in all cases that they are orders of magnitude higher than in the aqueous effluent. Livestock manure, derived from control cattle and cattle undergoing typical antibiotic treatment, and corresponding composts were also evaluated as common soil amendments in a separate study. In this study, the amendments were applied to two soil types in a greenhouse setting, in order to compare the resulting carriage of ARGs on a root (radish) versus leafy (lettuce) vegetable. Remarkably, radishes were found to harbor the highest relative abundance of total ARGs enumerated by metagenomics, even higher than corresponding soils or manures. Although the total microbial load will be lower on a harvested vegetable, the results suggest that the vegetable surface environment can differentially favor the survival of ARBs.
The role of wastewater and water reuse treatment processes in reducing ARB and ARGs was also investigated at field-scale. Two independent wastewater treatment plants both substantially reduced total ARG relative and absolute abundance through biological treatment and settling according to metagenomic analysis. The subsequent water reuse treatment train of one system produced water for non- potable purposes and found further reduction in ARGs after chlorination, but a five hundred percent increase in the relative abundance of ARGs in the subsequent distribution system. In the second plant, which employed a membrane-free ozone-biologically-activated carbon-granular activated carbon treatment train for indirect potable reuse, there were notable increases in total ARG relative abundance following ozonation and chlorination. However, these numbers attenuated below background aquifer levels before recharge. Culture-based analysis of these systems targeting resistant ESKAPE pathogens (Escherichia coil, Staphylococcus aureus, Klebsiella spp., Acinetobacter baumannii, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Enterococcus spp.) indicated similar trends as the metagenomic ARG analysis for both systems, but was challenged by sub-optimal media for wastewater samples and low confirmation rates, limiting statistical analysis.
In order to advance the application of NGS, molecular, and associated bioinformatic tools for monitoring pathogens and antibiotic resistance in environmental systems, newly emerging methods and field standards for antibiotic resistance assessment were also evaluated. Hybrid assembly, the assembly for both short and long metagenomic sequencing reads, were assessed with an in silico framework in order to determine which available assemblers produced the most accurate and long contigs. Hybrid assembly was found to produce longer and more accurate assemblies at all coverages by reducing error as compared to short read assembly, though the outputs differed in composition from long read assembly. Where it is possible, it is beneficial to sequence using both long- and short-read NGS technologies and employ hybrid assembly, but further validation is recommended. Genome resolved metagenomics has also emerged as a strategy to recover individual bacterial genomes from the mixed metagenomic samples though this is often not well validated. In order to address this, genomes were assembled from reclaimed water systems and were compared against whole-genome sequences of antibiotic resistant E.coli isolates. Metagenome-derived genomes were found to produce similar profiles in wastewater treatment plant influents.
A final theme to this dissertation addresses the need to standardize targets, methodologies, and reporting of antibiotic resistance in the environment. A systematic literature review was conducted on assays for the enumeration of key ARGs across aquatic environments and recommendations are summarized for the production of comparable data. In sum, this dissertation advances knowledge about the occurrence of pathogens, ARB, and ARGs across aquatic and agricultural systems and across several countries. Advances are made in the application of NGS tools for environmental monitoring of antibiotic resistance and other targets and a path forward is recommended for continued improvement as both DNA sequencing technologies and computational methodologies continue to rapidly advance. / Doctor of Philosophy / Understanding bacteria in our engineered systems is critical to ensuring drinking water, recycled water, and manure-derived soil amendments are safe for downstream applications. As novel approaches for assessing bacteria are developed, standardized methods and evaluations much be developed to ensure that sound conclusions are made that can appropriately inform policy and practice for the protection of public health. This dissertation focuses on combining bacterial culture and DNA sequencing methods for the study of pathogens (i.e., disease-causing organisms) and antibiotic resistance (i.e., ability of some bacteria to survive antibiotic treatments) in agricultural manure management, water reuse, and drinking water systems. Additionally, this work sought to advance emergent metagenomic analysis tools, which provides a new and potentially powerful pathogen and antibiotic resistance monitoring approach through direct extraction and sequencing of DNA from environmental samples.
Antibiotic resistance is a global health challenge and it has been widely recognized that wastewater and agriculture are key control points. When antibiotics are ingested by people or livestock, they select for resistant bacteria in the gut. Mitigation efforts are needed, particularly at wastewater treatment plants and on farms, to ensure that excreted antibiotics and resistant bacteria do not further propagate and pose a risk. However, additional challenges such as climate change have spurred the need for more efficient use of our water and nutrient resources. In this work I examined how nutrient and water reuse treatment methods affect antibiotic resistant bacteria and antibiotic resistance genes using DNA sequencing as well as culture-based methods. In order to assess agricultural practices, a systems approach was conducted at the greenhouse scale to identify key control points to stem the spread of antibiotic resistance when vegetables are grown in soils amended with cattle-derived manure fertilizers. Along the food production chain, vegetables (i.e., radish and lettuce) were found to harbor higher proportions of bacteria carrying antibiotic resistance genes, although the estimated numbers of these bacteria were lower. Solids from an international transect of wastewater treatment plants (Sweden, Switzerland, USA, India, Hong Kong, Phillippenes) were examined because they are also foten used as soil amendments. DNA sequencing of these solids revealed that total measured antibiotic resistance genes did not vary between treatment or continent of origin. Calculations were made to determine the range of total hypothetical outputs of ARGs if the biosolids are land applied.
Wastewater reuse systems were also examined using culture and metagenomic DNA analysis so that living pathogens could be compared alongside the total (dead and alive) antibiotic resistance genes. While standard wastewater and subsequent water reuse treatments were found to reduce the absolute numbers of antibiotic resistance genes and bacteria in a treatment plant producing water for non-potable reuse (i.e., irrigation), increases in culturable resistant pathogens and antibiotic resistance genes were apparent in the distribution system (i.e., in the pipes conveying treated water to the point of use). Similar reductions in antibiotic resistant bacteria and resistance genes were also seen in a plant using more advanced treatment (ozonation paired with biofiltration) to produce water suitable for indirect potable reuse via aquifer recharge, but there were indications that ozone and chlorine can increase the proportion of antibiotic resistant bacteria. Finally, genomes were recovered from the metagenomic sequencing analysis and were compared to sequenced culture isolates to validate the capabilities of metagenomic analysis to re-assemble genomes at the strain level, which is often required for pathogen confirmation.
Pathogens were also assessed in disrupted drinking water systems in Puerto Rico after Hurricane Maria. Small scale systems that were disrupted by the storm were sampled to identify if pathogens were measurable six months after the hurricane. This work revealed that genes attributed to pathogenic Leptospira were detected in all surface water reliant systems while Salmonella spp. were detected by culture and DNA methods, but only in the source surface and groundwaters, not in the distribution systems delivering water to from the treatment site to the tap.
This research also contributed to the advancement of big data analysis pipelines as well as to the standardization of methods to ensure that data produced across studies are comparable. Hybrid assembly, an emergent method that combines both short and long metagenomic DNA sequences generated by different technologies to more accurately recover genomes, was found to improve reliability and accuracy of algorithms aimed at reassembling DNA fragments. Antibiotic resistance is a global challenge, but without standardized methodologies for environmental monitoring, it will be difficult to compare measurements across countries and treatment processes in order to identify effective mitigation strategies. A critical literature review was conducted on assays for the enumeration of key antibiotic resistance genes across aquatic environments so that comparable data can be generated. This will be critical to tap into the tremendous volumes of antibiotic resistance monitoring data being generated around the globe to help identify trends and inform solutions.
Collectively, this dissertation advances knowledge about the occurrence of pathogens, antibiotic resistant bacteria and antibiotic resistance genes across aquatic and agricultural systems while also critically evaluating emerging methods for the detection of antibiotic resistance in the environment.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:VTETD/oai:vtechworks.lib.vt.edu:10919/114036 |
| Date | 09 September 2021 |
| Creators | Keenum, Ishi M. |
| Contributors | Civil and Environmental Engineering, Pruden, Amy, Krometis, Leigh-Anne H., Edwards, Marc A., Garner, Emily, Vikesland, Peter J. |
| Publisher | Virginia Tech |
| Source Sets | Virginia Tech Theses and Dissertation |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Dissertation |
| Format | ETD, application/pdf, application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.wordprocessingml.document |
| Rights | Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International, http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ |
Page generated in 0.006 seconds