Return to search

Kierkegaard and the Funny

<p> This dissertation begins by addressing a puzzle that arises in academic analytic interpretations of Kierkegaard&rsquo;s Concluding Unscientific Postscript. The puzzle arises when commentators try to paraphrase the book&rsquo;s philosophical thesis &ldquo;truth is subjectivity.&rdquo; I resolve this puzzle by arguing that the motto &ldquo;truth is subjectivity&rdquo; is like a joke, and resists and invites paraphrase just as a joke does. </p><p> The connection between joking and Kierkegaard&rsquo;s philosophical practice is then deepened by giving a philosophical reconstruction of Kierkegaard's definition of joking as a way of responding to contradiction that is painless precisely because it sees the way out in mind. Kierkegaard&rsquo;s account of joking and his account of his own philosophical project are used to mutually illuminate each other. The dissertation develops a phenomenology of retroactive temporality that explains how joking and subjective thinking work. I put forward an argument for why &ldquo;existential humorism&rdquo; is a valuable approach to life for Kierkegaard, but why it ultimately fails, and explain the relationship between comedy as a way of life and faith as a way of life, particularly as they both relate to risk. </p><p> In the final chapter three peculiar features of Kierkegaard&rsquo;s writing practice are addressed: his use of indirect communication, pseudonyms, and revocation. I explain the function of these methods to his philosophical project as I have described it in the previous chapters and conclude with a close reading of the graveyard scene in the Postscript and an analysis of how it serves to implicate the reader in existential thinking. Finally, I offer some reflections about the implications of Kierkegaard&rsquo;s account of humor and subjective thinking for human self-understanding. I argue that an implication of Kierkegaard&rsquo;s account is that philosophy is a risky, vulnerable, interpersonal activity, just as joking is.</p><p>

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:PROQUEST/oai:pqdtoai.proquest.com:10283782
Date22 May 2018
CreatorsKaplan, Eric Linus
PublisherUniversity of California, Berkeley
Source SetsProQuest.com
LanguageEnglish
Detected LanguageEnglish
Typethesis

Page generated in 0.0019 seconds