This study answers the critical question: How do women leaders experience gender
equality in the South African Democratic Teachers’ Union (SADTU)? It focuses on
five women leaders in the union, illuminating their experiences and evolving gender
consciousness. This qualitative study addresses a gap in research on gender in
teacher unions, to understand and reveal how women who have accessed previously
male-dominated spaces experience gender equality. The women leaders’ experiences
are a prism through which to understand the “depth” of the substantive experience of
gender equality in the union. It examines how the union through its organisational
bureaucracy, culture and politics shapes their experiences.
Through a historical analysis of the gender and liberation struggle, I demonstrate the
trajectory of achievements, challenges and visions for gender equity in South Africa
within the trade union movement, noting the achievements and highlighting lost
opportunities to advance gender struggles of its members.
The study theorises different conceptions of feminisms and imagings of organisations
to understand the women’s experiences in relation to the union and to broader
society, within the culture, politics and bureaucracy of the organisation. I extended
this lens by exploring differing conceptions of feminisms to understand the gendered
experiences of the women leaders as they traverse life from childhood to adulthood.
Conceived with the broader realm of feminist methodology, I use elements of life
history research, notably in-depth interviews to produce narratives in the form of
“harmonised poems” to illuminate the public and private experiences of the research
participants, providing deep insights into their evolving gender consciousness.
The analysis is multi-dimensional, traversing the influence of the family, school, and
the historical and political contexts that shaped the women’s gender consciousness.
The findings indicate that teachers’ contradictory class location, history of patriarchy
and acceptance of sexual division of labour contribute to the women leaders’
experiences of gender inequality in the union. These experiences of inequality were
magnified by apartheid’s1 structural and ideological roots, which shaped gender roles
while simultaneously catalysing the development of gender consciousness and
advancing political activism. In this regard, the family served as a crucial site of
gender socialisation, while the school formally reproduced a hierarchical gendered
society.
At the organisational level, hierarchically bureaucratic structures maintained and
reinforced particular patterns of control and power through the formal system of
trade union governance in which gender oppression is institutionalised and
legitimised under its banner of emancipatory politics. However, women in the
organisation are by no means innocent victims of hostile patriarchal forces, but are
active participants in their own oppression as they strategically comply with
institutional norms. Significantly, the findings indicate that equality of opportunity
for women leaders in the union does not translate into equality of outcome. This thesis contributes to the theoretical debates on evolving gendered consciousness
by advancing an extended conceptual lens to interrogate women’s gendered
experiences in predominantly patriarchal spaces. It identifies four domains of
evolving consciousness. Starting with the divided self in the domain of home, girl
children imbibe the dominant hierarchical social structures, and fixed gender roles
are inscribed here. However, the family domain provides the catalyst for a
developing consciousness among the women as children.
The socialised self emerging in the domain of the school emphasises the gender
socialisation, both overt and covert, that occurs in schools. It illuminates their
evolving gender consciousness by resisting such subjugation initially as students and
later as radical teachers.
Progressing to the domain of the union, the women embody a strategic self in
response to gender inequality in SADTU, which often takes an organisational form
that contradicts its espoused policy and public pronouncements. Armed with the
maturity to transcend their individualised gender consciousness, the women leaders
emerge with a collective consciousness determined to break down the barriers to
equality at the structural level.
Finally, in the emerging collective self, the women simultaneously embody elements
that constrain their individual emancipatory impulses while trajecting them to
potentially higher levels of consciousness as change agents. Their willingness to
embrace a shared consciousness and their call for activism indicate a shift towards
heightened collective consciousness. As they move from their individual subjugated
selves to their heightened collective, transformed consciousness, they express a
compelling desire for collective agency to challenge structural drivers of inequality
and enact change at the systemic level. / Thesis (Ph.D.) - University of KwaZulu-Natal, Durban, 2008.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:netd.ac.za/oai:union.ndltd.org:ukzn/oai:http://researchspace.ukzn.ac.za:10413/469 |
| Date | January 2008 |
| Creators | Mannah, Shermain. |
| Contributors | Samuel, Michael Anthony., Govinden, Devarakshanam Betty. |
| Source Sets | South African National ETD Portal |
| Language | English |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Thesis |
Page generated in 0.0019 seconds