Return to search

Constructing Human Rights:Historical Contexts,Diverse Meanings,Competing Powers

Abstract
This essay elaborates in a historical perspective on some controversies concerning the human rights conception. The reason why I take a historical perspective as my analytic standpoint lies in the essence of the human rights conception which is recognized as a human-made thing, rather than a natural phenomenon. In other words, the human rights conception is a kind of interpretation, knowledge and narrative. In this essay, I will firstly examine the main changes of philosophical and social conditions influencing the development and evolution of human rights conceptions. After a brief introduction of human rights conception, the following work of this essay is premised on the questions of what might be broadly termed ¡§universalism vs. relativism¡¨, ¡§individual rights vs. collective rights¡¨ and ¡§sovereignty vs. human rights¡¨. Accordingly, it is concerned with focusing scholarly attention on the place of diverse values and cultures in contemporary international society. Besides, I will take ¡§Asian value¡¨ as an object to embody those controversies mentioned above. Briefly speaking, there are four premises on which the ¡§Asian value¡¨ is founded, namely ¡§priority of the socio-economic rights over the politico-civil rights¡¨, ¡§priority of the cultural particularity over the universality of human rights¡¨, ¡§priority of individual rights over collective rights¡¨, and ¡§priority of sovereignty over human rights¡¨. Finally, I will examine the philosophical hermeneutics of Hans-Georg Gadamer. It is argued that the notion of the ¡§fusion of horizons¡¨, which Gadamer derives from the linguistic and nature and historicity of human existence, provides fruitful responses to those competing opinions outlined above. I suggest that an application of Gadamer¡¦s inspiring ideas opens the way to a more convergent and inclusive human rights conception.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:NSYSU/oai:NSYSU:etd-1225102-164341
Date25 December 2002
CreatorsYen, Ming-Hong
ContributorsKuo-Hsiang Tseng, Ching-Chuan Huang, Chih-Yu Shih
PublisherNSYSU
Source SetsNSYSU Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Archive
LanguageCholon
Detected LanguageEnglish
Typetext
Formatapplication/pdf
Sourcehttp://etd.lib.nsysu.edu.tw/ETD-db/ETD-search/view_etd?URN=etd-1225102-164341
Rightsunrestricted, Copyright information available at source archive

Page generated in 0.0023 seconds