Inclusion of local knowledge in decision-making is recognized as important for land-use
planning. However, this is prevented by communication constraints. Increasingly local
communities throughout the world are using community mapping and simple Geographic
Information Technologies (GIT) to communicate information about traditional lands to decisionmakers.
This corresponds to the trend, primarily in North America, for practitioners to apply
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) technologies in public participation settings. Claims have
been made that use of Public Participation Geographic Information Systems (PPGIS) by
disadvantaged groups can be empowering. However, others claim that PPGIS is disempowering
due to the cost and complexity of the technologies, inaccessibility of data, restrictive
representation of local geographic information, and the low level of community participation.
The research described in this thesis sets out to contribute to the debate regarding PPGIS
and empowerment. Participatory Geographic Information and Multimedia Systems (PGIMS)
technologies were developed for this project in an attempt to overcome the weaknesses of PPGIS
described above. A PGIMS project was introduced into two communities in West Kutai,
Indonesia. The PGIMS technologies enabled local communities to gather information using a
digital camera and video camera, and store, manage and access it. A participatory process
ensured that communities made all decisions related to the project and were trained in the
necessary technical skills. Functional PGIMS were created in both participating villages. These
PGIMS were relevant to the communities’ needs to record information for future generations and
communicate information about boundaries and land use to outsiders.
The research question addressed in this thesis was: How does the PGIMS project
empower or disempower local communities? The author developed a working definition of
empowerment to enable evaluation: empowerment is an increase in social influence or political
power. Furthermore the author determined that empowerment is achieved through a combination
of internal changes in an individual or community as well as external factors. These are defined
as changes in ‘empowerment capacity’.
This thesis presents a framework to structure an analysis of empowerment. It enabled the
author to examine how four catalysts related to the PGIMS project empowered and
disempowered, as well as increased and decreased empowerment capacity of the individual and
community. Catalysts included the information contained within the PGIMS, the participatory
process used, the technological skills acquired and the tools applied to develop the PGIMS.
Qualitative data were gathered in the field using participant observation, semi-structured
interviews and questionnaires. Data were categorised into indicators of increased or decreased
empowerment and empowerment capacity. These indicators were sorted into the relevant cells of
the framework.
The empowerment framework offered a logical structure to categorize the data and enable an analysis of how different components of the PGIMS project impacted individuals and
communities. It was also useful for differentiating between empowerment and empowerment
capacity impacts. There were weaknesses with the methods and framework. These included the
inability to determine the extent to which the PGIMS project contributed to the observed
indicators relative to other influences; the difficulty of interpreting the data to create indicators,
and the difficulty of measuring some indicators or defining their relative importance in the
framework.
This research concluded that the PGIMS project empowered participating individuals and
communities, and also increased their empowerment capacity, but it is difficult to determine how
lasting or significant this is. It also disempowered individuals and communities. Individuals were
more empowered by skills and processes, while communities more empowered by information
and tools. The benefits of individual empowerment can conflict with community empowerment.
Empowerment in the PGIMS project was highly influenced by pre-existing conditions in individuals and communities. / Graduate
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:uvic.ca/oai:dspace.library.uvic.ca:1828/8063 |
| Date | 04 May 2017 |
| Creators | Corbett, Jonathan Michael Swan |
| Contributors | Keller, C. Peter |
| Source Sets | University of Victoria |
| Language | English, English |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Thesis |
| Rights | Available to the World Wide Web |
Page generated in 0.0116 seconds