Human-swarm interaction studies how human beings can interact with a robotswarm---a large number of robots cooperating with each other without any form of centralizedcontrol. In today's human-swarm interaction literature, the large majority of the works investigatehow human beings can issue commands to and receive feedback from a robot swarm. However, only a few ofthese works study the effect of the interaction with a robot swarm on human psychology (e.g. on thehuman stress or on the human workload). Understanding human psychology in human-swarm interaction isimportant because the human psychological state can have significant impact on the way humansinteract with robot swarms (e.g. a high level of stress can cause a human operator to freeze in themiddle of a critical task, such as a search-and-rescue task). Most existing works that study human psychology in human-swarm interaction conduct their experimentsusing robot swarms simulated on a computer screen. The use of simulation is convenient becauseexperimental conditions can be repeated perfectly in different experimental runs and becauseexperimentation using real robots is expensive both in money and time. However, simulation suffersfrom the so-called reality gap: the inherent discrepancy between simulation and reality. Itis therefore important to study whether this inherent discrepancy can affect humanpsychology---human operators interacting with a simulated robot swarm can react differently thanwhen interacting with a real robot swarm.A large literature in human-robot interaction has studied the psychological impact of theinteraction between human beings and single robots. This literature could in principle be highlyrelevant to human-swarm interaction. However, an inherent difference between human-robot interactionand human-swarm interaction is that in the latter, human operators interact with a large number ofrobots. This large number of robots can affect human psychology---human operators interacting with alarge number of robots can react differently than when interacting with a single robot or with asmall number of robots. It is therefore important to understand whether the large number of robotsthat composes a robot swarm affects human psychology. In fact, if this is the case, it would not bepossible to directly apply the results of human-robot interaction research to human-swarminteraction.We conducted several experiments in order to understand the effect of the reality gap and the effectof the group size (i.e. the number of robots that composes a robot swarm) on the humanpsychological state. In these experiments our participants are exposed to swarms of robots and arepurely passive---they do not issue commands nor receive feedback from the robots. Making theinteraction passive allowed us to study the effects of the reality gap and of the group size on thehuman psychological state without the risk that an interaction interface (such as a joystick)influences the psychological responses of the participants (and thus limiting the visibility of both thereality gap and group size effects). In the reality gap experiments, participants are exposed tosimulated robot swarms displayed either on a computer screen or in a virtual reality environment, and toreal robot swarms. In the group size experiments, participants are exposed to an increasing numberof real robots.In this thesis, we show that the reality gap and the group size affect the human psychological stateby collecting psychophysiological measures (heart rate and skin conductance), self-reported (viaquestionnaires) affective state measures (arousal and valence), self-reported workload (the amountof mental resource needed to carry out a task) and reaction time (the time needed to respond to astimulus). Firstly, we show with our results that our participants' psychophysiological measures,affective state measures, workload and reaction time are significantly higher when they interactwith a real robot swarm compared to when they interact with a robot swarm simulated on a computerscreen, confirming that the reality gap significantly affects the human psychological state.Moreover, we show that it is possible to mitigate the effect of the reality gap using virtualreality---our participants' arousal, workload and reaction time are significantly higher when theyinteract with a simulated robot swarm displayed in a virtual reality environment as opposed to whenit is displayed on a computer screen. Secondly, we show that our participants' psychophysiologicalmeasures and affective state measures increase when the number of robots they are exposed toincreases. Our results have important implications for research in human-swarm interaction. Firstly, for thefirst time, we show that experiments in simulation change the human psychological state compared toexperiments with real robots. Secondly, we show that a characteristic that is inherent to thedefinition of swarm robotics---the large number of robots that composes a robotswarm---significantly affects the human psychological state. Finally, our results show thatpsychophysiological measures, such as heart rate and skin conductance, provide researchers with moreinformation on human psychology than the information provided by using traditional self-reportedmeasures (collected via psychological questionnaires). / Doctorat en Sciences de l'ingénieur et technologie / info:eu-repo/semantics/nonPublished
Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:ulb.ac.be/oai:dipot.ulb.ac.be:2013/245391 |
Date | 27 January 2017 |
Creators | Podevijn, Gaetan |
Contributors | Dorigo, Marco, Bersini, Hugues, O'Grady, Rehan, Fantini-Hauwel, Carole, Birattari, Mauro, Vanderborght, Bram, Pinciroli, Carlo |
Publisher | Universite Libre de Bruxelles, Université libre de Bruxelles, Ecole polytechnique de Bruxelles – Informatique, Bruxelles |
Source Sets | Université libre de Bruxelles |
Language | English |
Detected Language | English |
Type | info:eu-repo/semantics/doctoralThesis, info:ulb-repo/semantics/doctoralThesis, info:ulb-repo/semantics/openurl/vlink-dissertation |
Format | 3 full-text file(s): application/pdf | application/pdf | application/pdf |
Rights | 3 full-text file(s): info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess | info:eu-repo/semantics/closedAccess | info:eu-repo/semantics/restrictedAccess |
Page generated in 0.109 seconds