This dissertation is comprised of three essays examining methods for surface water quality valuation. The first essay uses Zillow's ZTRAX property transaction database to investigate variation in hedonic price effects of water clarity on single-family houses throughout the United States. I consider five spatial scales and estimate models using different sample selection criteria and model specifications. The results indicate considerable spatial heterogeneity both within and across the four U.S. Census regions. However, I also find heterogeneity resulting from different types of investigator decisions, including sample selection and modelling choices. Thus, it is necessary to use practical knowledge to consider the limits of market areas and to investigate the robustness of estimation results to investigator choices.
In the second essay, I integrate a coastal recreation demand model for Southern New England with property sales in Massachusetts and Rhode Island to estimate the impacts of water quality improvements for freshwater and saltwater resources throughout the region. While traditional hedonic studies for water quality reveal the direct effects of local water quality on housing prices, the spatial extent of the models is limited to 2 km from the waterfront. Integrating recreation demand models with hedonic models allows identification of additional indirect effects of water quality at recreation sites that are capitalized in housing markets through a recreational index (i.e., the potential recreational benefits for a neighborhood). However, the spatial extent of these models is currently untested. I compare the spatial extent of indirect and direct effects of water quality for multiple water quality inputs isolating spatial and temporal sources of variation. The results indicate heterogeneity in the direct effects of freshwater and saltwater clarity depending on whether the source of variation is spatial or temporal. Conflating spatial and temporal water quality variation can lead to anomalous conclusions on the impacts of coastal recreation on housing markets.
In the third essay, I evaluate meta-regression models (MRMs) that are used by policy makers in calculating the potential benefits of improvements in environmental quality resulting from proposed regulatory actions. MRMs lay the foundation for benefit transfers applied by EPA to recent rulemakings under the Clean Water Act (CWA) in addition to other environmental contexts (e.g., health benefits under the Clean Air Act). While recent literature has emphasized the necessity that MRMs satisfy key theoretical conditions, including scope sensitivity and the adding up condition, existing MRMs that fulfil these properties require imposing structural model restrictions or removing relevant explanatory variables from the MRM at the expense of model fit and predictive performance. This study presents a method for defining MRMs that draws on characteristics of the given benefits transfer scenario and its relationship to the metadata while satisfying the adding up condition. This modelling framework outperforms the model used by EPA in model fit and predictive performance. Applying the results to a recent CWA rule, I find the model used by EPA substantially underestimates the potential benefits. / Doctor of Philosophy / This dissertation is comprised of three essays examining methods for surface water quality valuation. The first essay uses property sale models to evaluate spatial differences in the impacts of lake water quality on housing markets throughout the United States. I evaluate how investigator decisions related to spatial scale of the model, sample selection criteria, and model specification effects the observed results. I find variation in the impacts of water on property sale prices across the nation. However, the results in some regions are highly sensitive to investigator decisions, implying limitations to using a single model to represent the impacts. The second essay integrates a property sale model for water quality with a model that examines willingness to pay for coastal recreation in Southern New England. I evaluate the impacts of water quality at coastal recreation sites on property sales in Massachusetts and Rhode Island and compare the results to the impacts of local water quality. I find the effects of local water quality is largest on the coast but only capitalized into property sales up to 2 km from the waterfront. I do not find expected results for coastal recreation. The third essay evaluates the models used by policy makers to calculate the potential benefits of improvements in water quality resulting from regulatory action. Previous models prioritized theoretical properties of models, such as the adding up condition, at the expense of model fit and predictive performance. I develop a hybrid model approach that can be used model water quality benefits while satisfying the adding up condition with improved model performance. I apply the model to a recently proposed rulemaking and find the benefits potential benefits greatly exceed those presented in the rule making.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:VTETD/oai:vtechworks.lib.vt.edu:10919/119180 |
| Date | 29 May 2024 |
| Creators | Swedberg, Kristen M. |
| Contributors | Economics, Boyle, Kevin J., Nolte, Christoph, Benami, Elinor, Bosch, Darrell J., Cobourn, Kelly M. |
| Publisher | Virginia Tech |
| Source Sets | Virginia Tech Theses and Dissertation |
| Language | English |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Dissertation |
| Format | ETD, application/pdf, application/pdf |
| Rights | In Copyright, http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/ |
Page generated in 0.0022 seconds