Islands in the Maritime Boundary Delimitation─A Case Study on the Disputes over the Diaoyutai Islands and the Maritime Delimitation in the East China Sea / 論島嶼在海域劃界中之地位─兼論釣魚台及其東海劃界問題

碩士 / 國立臺灣大學 / 政治學研究所 / 95 / The capacity of islands to generate maritime zones and to influence the location of international maritime boundaries was a long-term dispute long before a single provision in the 1982 UN Convention on the Law of the Sea. Particularly, the problem of the effect of the islands'' delimitation in the sea had attracted the attention of international law. Regime of Islands in the UNCLOS has confirmed the legal definition of an island and its entitlement. However, the rules of the provision are too simple to be applied. In addition, the UNCLOS leaves open the function of the islands in the maritime delimitation. Therefore, the effect of the islands’ delimitation can only be found in the customary law. According to the numerous international judicial legal precedents and state practices, it is full effect, partial effect and zero effect that the islands could possibly obtain in delimitation, and it is the nature and position of the islands and other factors including economic and political consideration, trade-off value, disputed islands and so on that influence the effect of the islands’ delimitation in the sea. At last, this essay attempts to analysis the possible effect of Diaoyutai Islands in the maritime delimitation of the East China Sea in terms of the regime of islands in the UNCLOS and international judicial legal precedents and bilateral agreements concerning maritime boundaries involved. Both case law and state practices seem to suggest that the most appropriate and most likely effect of Diaoyutai Islands on the delimitation of the East China Sea may be no effect or at most be limited to circa 12 nautical miles. This value, if accepted, could certainly help to bring some solution to the complicated deadlock of the maritime delimitation in the East China Sea.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:TW/095NTU05227039
Date January 2007
CreatorsHsiang-Yin Lin, 林香吟
Contributors楊永明
Source SetsNational Digital Library of Theses and Dissertations in Taiwan
Languagezh-TW
Detected LanguageEnglish
Type學位論文 ; thesis
Format233

Page generated in 0.011 seconds