Everyday speech is littered with disfluencies such as filled pauses, silent pauses, repetitions and repairs which reflect a speaker’s language production difficulties. But what are the effects on language comprehension? This thesis took a novel approach to the study of disfluencies by combining an investigation of the immediate effects on language processing with an investigation of the longer-term effects for the representation of language in memory. A series of experiments is reported which reflects the first attempt at a systematic investigation of the effects of different types of disfluencies on language comprehension. The experiments focused on the effects of three types of disfluencies—ers, silent pauses, and repetitions—on the comprehension of subsequent words. Critical words were either straightforward continuations of the pre-interrupted speech or a repair word which corrected the pre-interrupted speech. In addition, the effects that occur when er, repetition, and repair disfluencies themselves are processed, were assessed. ERPs showed that the N400 effect elicited in response to contextually unpredictable compared to predictable words was attenuated by the presence of a pre-target er reflecting a reduction in the standard difference where unpredictable words are more difficult to integrate into their contexts. This finding suggests that ers may reduce the extent to which listeners make predictions about upcoming words. In addition, words preceded by an er were more likely to be correctly recognised in a subsequent memory test. These findings demonstrate a longer-term consequence for representation which may reflect heightened attention during processing. Silent pauses did not affect the N400 but there was some indication of an effect on recognition memory. Repetition disfluencies did not affect the N400 or recognition memory. These findings demonstrate the importance of the nature of the disruption to speech. For all types of disfluent utterances, unpredictable words elicited a Late Positive Complex (LPC), possibly reflecting processes associated with memory retrieval and control as listeners attempted to resume structural fluency after any interruption. Ers themselves elicited standard attention-related ERP effects: the Mismatch Negativity (MMN) and P300 effects, supporting the possibility that ers heighten attention. Repetition disfluencies elicited a right posterior positivity, reflecting detection of the disfluency and possibly syntactic reanalysis. Repair disfluencies elicited an early frontal negativity, possibly related to the detection of a word category violation, and a P600 effect, reflecting syntactic reanalysis. The presence of an er preceding the repair eliminated the early negativity, but had no effect on the P600 suggesting that ers may prepare listeners for the possibility of an upcoming repair, but that they do not reduce the difficulty associated with reanalysis. Taken together, the results from the studies reported in the thesis support an account of disfluency processing which incorporates both prediction and attention.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:bl.uk/oai:ethos.bl.uk:562285 |
| Date | January 2008 |
| Creators | MacGregor, Lucy J. |
| Contributors | Corley, Martin |
| Publisher | University of Edinburgh |
| Source Sets | Ethos UK |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
| Source | http://hdl.handle.net/1842/3311 |
Page generated in 0.0022 seconds