Global ETD Search
Search theses and dissertations gathered from participating repositories worldwide. Every result links back to the library that holds it. No account is needed.
Results
Showing 1 to 20 of 134 for “"Incommensurability"”.
-
Incommensurability revisited.
… an eye to clarifying his controversial notion of incommensurability. Although the notion of incommensurability, one of the most significant results of Kuhn's The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, has been much criticized in recent Anglo-American philosophy, I argue that it incorporates insights …
-
A defence of Kuhn's incommensurability thesis
Kuhn's incommensurability thesis is the claim that successive scientific theories often conflict not only logically but also normatively: i.e. they differ both about nature and also about the use of common apparatus, concepts and experimental results, and what are proper scientific goals and …
-
Rhetorical Perspectivism: an Epistemologically Meaningful Response to Incommensurability
… an epistemologically meaningful response to incommensurability. Rhetorical perspectivism is reviewed as a theory of rhetorical epistemology, and applied to the McLean v. Arkansas evolution/creation trial. The study found that the theory provides significant insight into the creation/evolution …
-
Kuhnian incommensurability between two paradigms of contemporary linguistics.
… of linguistics, can account for the existence of incommensurability across two paradigms of linguistics. The relationship between transformational generative grammar and socio- linguistics is vexed. Both claim the same object of study, but with radi- cally different methods and aims. This …
-
The Language of Science as Creole: A Case Against Incommensurability
The incommensurability thesis (IT) is the claim that historically related theories cannot be fully translated into each other. IT shows how a scientific theory can be different from its predecessor in a way deemed revolutionary. This dissertation, in contrast, argues that IT reflects the …
-
Policy, values & incommensurability: the Northern Rocky Mountain Wolf Recovery Project
In this thesis I explore the following question: When a government agency is charged with implementing policies formulated in the light of scientific principles, why do the justifications for implementation differ from justifications for the legislation? The predator reintroduction being carried …
-
The Politics of Incommensurability: A Value Pluralist Approach to Liberalism and Democracy
… from the central value pluralist concept of incommensurability. In my approach, I maintain the distinction between the moral-practical and societal groupings theories, focusing on the moral-practical version as a more original and less well-understood contribution of Berlin's thought. I also …
-
Public Administration Reform and Building of the 'Vertical of Power' in Russia: Exploring Incommensurability
The dissertation explores the reform of Russian public administration that began in 2003. Although, it was considered by the ruling elite as one of the most important political projects that should establish a necessary fundament for further socio-economic modernization of the country, the reform …
-
Incommensurability and scientific progress : an essay concerning the nature of the relation between successive scientific theories
… put forward in terms of which it is shown that incommensurability between theories is something other than the change of meaning of their individual terms, and that, in any case, such a change of meaning does not entail relativism. Furthermore this alternative conception, in seeing the relation …
-
Adjusting the Narrative Lens: Overcoming the Incommensurability of Representations of Rape and Sexual Violence in the Field of Transitional Justice
… lens to consider the possibility of overcoming incommensurability.
-
Value Pluralism: What It Is and Why Its Main Arguments Fail
… pluralism fail. I argue both that the purported incommensurability of value does not entail pluralism, and that the indirect argument for pluralism from rational regret is unsuccessful. The debate on the incommensurability of value applies to both pluralist and monistic theories of the good. …
-
Nothing to disagree about: Aristotle, Newton, and the existence of void as seen through a Kuhnian lens
… this work, I argue that a doctrine of theoretic incommensurability, something like that offered by Thomas Kuhn, can be used to to explain the disagreement between Aristotle and Isaac Newton regarding the existence of void. A significant portion of the work is directed at identifying Kuhn’s mature …
-
Judging without scales
<p>This thesis is about the nature of value incommensurability and its significance for judicial reasoning. It argues that there can be incommensurable values and that this incommensurability can have significant implications for judicial reasoning. I argue that incommensurability gives rise to a …
-
Objectivity, reasoning and interdisciplinary: making the links
… to require relativism, scepticism, and Kuhnian incommensurability, as well as casting serious doubt on the potential of our cognitive traditions to provide us with objective knowledge about an objective world. This thesis exposes and critiques the presuppositions about the nature of reasoning …
-
Scientific progress and its metaphysical foundations
… begins with a discussion of the so-called ‘incommensurability of theories’. The notion is defended against some influential sets of objections; nonetheless it is shown that there are ways of making comparisons among potentially incommensurable theories. Incommensurability is a matter of …
-
Transcending the Impasses: Towards an Indigenous Vision of Legality in Palestine
… Mills' theoretical framework to argue for an incommensurability between Palestine's indigenous conception of legality and the dominant conception of legality underlying international law. Further, the thesis offers a reading of Ghassan Kanafani's novel The Other Thing to explore the …
-
Skepticism, rhetoric, and Nietzsche: an examination of the skeptical underpinnings of postmodern rhetoric
… of postmodern rhetoric by tracing uncertainty, incommensurability, and judgment through the history of skepticism. The examination starts with a look at the Hellenistic Skeptics and how their form of skepticism allowed for an epistemology without the assumption of universal truth. The next …
-
Scientific virtues :
… certain anti-realist positions (those based on 'incommensurability arguments') involve an insufficient treatment of 'meaning' and 'reference' for theoretical terms. I review much of the current work on theories of reference and show that these incommensurability positions are bankrupt given …
Page 1 of 7