Global ETD Search
Search theses and dissertations gathered from participating repositories worldwide. Every result links back to the library that holds it. No account is needed.
Results
Showing 1 to 15 of 15 for “"Incompatibilism"”.
-
In Defense of the Direct Argument for Incompatibilism
… If it is successful, we have an argument for incompatibilism about responsibility and determinism that does not make use of two controversial claims typically invoked by incompatibilists: (i) a person is morally responsible for what she has done only if she could have done otherwise, and (ii) …
-
Incompatibilist arguments and compatibilist rebuttals
… of one philosophical position on this debate --- incompatibilism. Incompatibilism is the doctrine that claims free will and moral responsibility are incompatible with determinism. A major part of this thesis is a critical survey of three of the most influential (types of) arguments for …
-
Responsibility, Identity And Luck
… would, if accurate, provide reason to reject incompatibilism about moral responsibility and determinism. In the second chapter I argue that Quality of Will accounts of moral responsibility, while likely correct, do not provide reason to rejection incompatibilism. In the third chapter I provide …
-
Hard Incompatibilist Challenges To Morality And Autonomy
… and libertarian positions on free will. Hard incompatibilism is the view that the free will required for moral responsibility is incompatible with both the truth of causal determinism and its falsity. My position differs from those of some philosophers who hold similar views (such as Derk …
-
A rationalist argument for libertarian free will
… chapter, in which I give a new argument for incompatibilism between free will and determinism, which I call the situatedness argument for incompatibilism. If the presuppositions of the thesis are granted and the situatedness argument works, then we may be justified in thinking that to the …
-
Content Externalism and Self-Knowledge
… the so-called “discrimination argument” for incompatibilism. This argument appeals to the fact that, if content externalism is true, then we will not always be able to discriminate one thought-type from another. This generates problems for privileged access if we think that knowledge requires …
-
"Ought" Claims And Blame In A Deterministic World
… Instead, this dissertation rebuts arguments for incompatibilism and attempts to explain why determinism, if true, should not undermine these two aspects of morality. Chapter One focuses on the intuitive, but controversial, proposition that moral "ought" claims imply "can" claims. This principle …
-
Das Problem der moralischen Verantwortlichkeit
… sein können. The traditional argument for incompatibilism (the view that determinism and moral responsibility are incompatible) is based on two premises: (1) Free will (the ability to act otherwise) and determinism are incompatible. (2) Free will is a necessary condition of moral …
-
Freedom, God, and Empiricism in Locke
… concepts of "determinism," "compatibilism," and "incompatibilism," are defined in the third section of the first part of chapter 1...
-
Freedom, coherence, and the self.
… knowledge. I defend the consequence argument for incompatibilism and argue that the compatibilist understanding of freedom is unsatisfactory. Hence, drawing on the coherence account of autonomy, I develop a coherentist libertarian theory of freedom. I respond to challenges to that account and …
-
Reimagining free will and moral responsibility: Nietzsche’s practical approach
… offers a method to move beyond the compatibilism/incompatibilism dualism by analysing the development of conscience in response to moral expectations and punishment. In this account, conscience and guilt are corresponding attitudes to moral expectations and to be a free agent is a matter of …
-
A Tectonic Theory of Moral Responsibility: How a Concern for Patiency can Make Moral Responsibility Practices More Fair
… moral responsibility such as compatibilism and incompatibilism. To develop the tectonic theory, I draw from work in philosophy, psychology, and cognitive neuroscience.
-
Varieties of Compatibilism: An Evaluation of Compatibilist Approaches to the Free Will Problem
… of this, concluding<br/>that although diagnostic incompatibilism may be true, we nevertheless<br/>can and should be prescriptive compatibilists. This is to say, despite the<br/>fact that our concepts and practices associated with responsible agency<br/>are inconsistent with determinism as they …
-
After Compatibilism: Essays on Freedom and Responsibility
… may actually support a powerful form of incompatibilism about free will and determinism. This casts the entire contemporary project that draws on his work in a suspect light. Drawing lessons from these two failures, in Chapter 4, I offer a practice-based argument for realism about freedom …
-
TRANSCENDENTAL IDEALISM AS A FRAMEWORK FOR AGENT-CAUSAL LIBERTARIANISM
… free will is incompatible with determinism (i.e. incompatibilism), and free will exists. Libertarianism is a competitor to compatibilist views that claim that free will is compatible with determinism, i.e. the view that there is a unique outcome given a past and laws of nature characterizing the …