Global ETD Search
Search theses and dissertations gathered from participating repositories worldwide. Every result links back to the library that holds it. No account is needed.
Results
Showing 1 to 20 of 24 for “"Moral Luck"”.
-
Moral dilemmas and moral luck
A moral dilemma is a situation in which a person cannot avoid acting wrongly. In the first part of the dissertation, I examine the two most important arguments for the possibility of moral dilemmas: the incommensurability argument and the argument from guilt. I argue that neither of these arguments …
-
Bounded Rationality and Moral Luck
… “unbounded” approaches to rationality and morality, human behavior can look alarmingly irrational and rather indifferent to the rules of morality. My aim is to present Gerd Gigerenzer’s “bounded” theories of rationality and morality as plausible alternatives to these traditional approaches. …
-
Moral Luck in Medical Ethics and Practical Politics
… between these polarities creates the paradox of moral luck. In practice we regard actions as right or wrong, and character as good or bad, partly according to what happens as a result of the agent's decision. Yet we also think that people should not be held responsible for matters beyond their …
-
Embracing Moral Luck: Accidents, Apologies, and the Foundations of Social Cooperation
… what they can tell us about the nature of moral responsibility. Drawing on Adam Smith's brief, but important discussion of moral luck, I argue that our responses to accidents reveal the extent to which the obligations we incur and the moral appraisals we make of one another are often …
-
Responsibility and Ambivalence
… five contemporary debates in the philosophy of moral responsibility: (1) psychopathy, (2) free will, (3) the emotion of guilt, (4) regret and indirect moral luck, and (5) moral demandingness. Rather than arguing for one theory or another, acknowledging ambivalence paves the way for resolving …
-
What Moral Responsibility Requires
… a robust commonsense libertarian theory of moral responsibility; that moral agents are the causes, and owners, of their actions, and in virtue of this it is appropriate to hold them praiseworthy or blameworthy for what they do. Here, I critique and defend two commonsense principles …
-
Unlinking moral responsibility and appraisability: defending an asymmetric relation
In ordinary moral judgment, we often ask whether an action is related to an agent in the morally relevant sense: is the action really the agent’s, and is the agent praiseworthy or blameworthy for doing it? These questions come together and make it natural to assume that the statuses of being …
-
Impossible and Necessary: The Problem of Luck and the Promise of Kindness
… of kindness as a response to the problem of luck which confronts both ancient and modern visions of the moral life. A rich articulation of kindness in the light of historical moral theory reveals that, far from being a trifling, merely and purely sentimental phenomenon, kindness involves many …
-
Why unavoidable moral wrongdoing is impossible
… act in accordance with the all-things-considered morally right course of action, and yet nevertheless experience an emotion of self-directed distress at the fact that we have so acted. Moreover, we have the intuition that this emotion is rational or appropriate. Literature is scattered with such …
-
The Politics of Luck.
This dissertation considers the place of luck in political life through examination of the political thought of Thucydides, Aristotle, and Machiavelli. I turn to these thinkers because, in my view, they approach the idea of luck from a strongly skeptical, deflationary, and psychological vantage …
-
Liability and culpability
… liable to defensive harms. Yet the nature of moral liability, its limits and justifications, are the subject of considerable debate. This thesis is a contribution to those debates. Its starting point is the idea that we can better understand both liability and culpability by examining the …
-
Aristotle on luck : the role of coincidence in happiness and virtue
… view on the place and significance of luck (τύχη) in happiness and virtue. According to the prevalent interpretation, Aristotle maintains that happiness and virtue are largely dependent on luck, for he believes that they are susceptible to the influence of factors beyond our control. I …
-
The role of luck in entrepreneurial success
Luck is a nuanced concept subject to numerous debates in philosophy and beyond. Philosophers not only acknowledge the existence of luck simpliciter, but also its various types, such as moral and epistemic luck. Moral luck is associated with factors beyond one's control that affect moral judgments …
-
Social worker experience of fatal child abuse : An interpretive phenomenological analysis.
… grief, Nagel's (1979) concept of "moral luck" and also Hawkins and Shohet's (1989) model of effective supervision. The study introduces a new concept developed by the author. Termed the "personification of systemic failure", this concept highlights how such factors as media …
-
Does implicit bias threaten the semicompatibilist position on free will and responsibility?
… from one of its major threats, the problem of moral luck. I show that semicompatibilism successfully accommodates the phenomenon of implicit bias; agent responsibility for issuing behaviour is confirmed, in harmony with the presented models of implicit bias. A particular understanding of …
-
Shame as virtue and pride as vice: emotions of self-assessment in the works of Abu Hamid al-Ghazālī and Thomas Aquinas
This dissertation explores the moral and spiritual role of the self-assessing emotions of shame and pride in the works of Abu Hamid al-Ghazālī (c. 1058-1111) and Thomas Aquinas (1225-1274). In my analysis of their ethical and religious views on these topics, I demonstrate their great debt to …
-
Essays on Overdetermination
… counterfactual structure, and properties of moral responsibility. I investigate causal overdetermination in three related papers.In "Overdetermination Underdetermined," I show that overdetermination has been underspecified in the literature, leading to a conflation of several important …
-
The Puzzle of Victim-Anger
In this paper I raise a puzzle that I call 'the puzzle of victim-anger' that is parallel to Bernard William's puzzle of agent-regret. Suppose a truck driver is driving down the street when a child happens to walk in front of them. Through no fault of their own, the driver hits and kills the child. …
-
Emergent grace: Paul Tillich, existential ontology, and the ethics of acceptance
… doctrine of grace in conversation with secular moral philosophy, highlighting its relevance to virtue cultivation within and beyond religious contexts. This is an unusual connection, admittedly, but properly understood, grace addresses key ethical issues such as moral development, moral …
-
The orphaned subject and moral debilitation: accounting for postcolonial pessimism
This dissertation investigates the concept of “moral debilitation” as it pertains to the “orphaned subject” in Korean society, a notion that denotes the diminished moral agency consequential to colonial and neocolonial legacies. The term “orphaned subject” describes certain characteristics …
Page 1 of 2