Global ETD Search
Search theses and dissertations gathered from participating repositories worldwide. Every result links back to the library that holds it. No account is needed.
Results
Showing 1 to 20 of 31 for “"Stare decisis"”.
-
Legal Doctrine and Self Imposed Norms: Examining the Politics of Stare Decisis
The "law versus politics" debate is central in the study of the Supreme Court's institutional role in US democracy and law making. Research has sought to determine if the Supreme Court is an unconstrained political actor or if it is constrained by precedent. This dissertation contributes to this …
-
Pressupostos normativos para o stare decisis constitucional e modelo decisório escrito do Supremo Tribunal Federal: uma abordagem normativo-institucional
… define theoretical assumptions for dealing with stare decisis at constitutional environment and, based on these collected assumptions, draft an ideal writing decision model for the Brazilian Supreme Court’s decisions. The need of Redesigning stare decisis doctrine at constitutional domains …
-
Winning Conditions for Charter Reconsideration: Assisted Suicide and the Supreme Court of Canada
… and depart from, an earlier Charter precedent. Stare decisis, or precedent, is a fundamental doctrine of the legal system that judges are reluctant to ignore. However, in Bedford, the Supreme Court outlined new criteria for revisiting a precedential decision, and these same criteria allowed for …
-
Judicial Interpretation of Social Rights: The Rights to Education, Health, and Housing in Brazil and South Africa
… theoretical consistency with a limited role for stare decisis will tend to develop an individualized social rights jurisprudence that focuses on remedying specific harms suffered by individuals. In contrast, countries with a more centralized system of judicial review, characterized by a small …
-
Jurisdição constitucional e código de processo civil : sincronia, racionalidade, interpretação e segurança jurídica
… e da interpretação constitucionais sem o stare decisis e a viabilidade e a necessidade de correção deste erro com o CPC/15. Analisa-se o anacronismo do CPC/73, completamente inadequado ao Estado Social Contemporâneo. Buzaid baseou-se em teorias vinculadas a uma visão do direito anterior a …
-
Precedentes vinculantes no Brasil e na Louisiana : desafios de um transplante jurídico
… brasileiro, da mentalidade da técnica do stare decisis e da doutrina do precedente vinculante. Visto sob o viés das resistências culturais e institucionais à tendência de interpenetração e hibridização entre as tradições romano-germânicas e de Common Law, o caso peculiar do direito da …
-
A Concise Guide to Legal Research and Writing
… a discussion on the nature of legal precedents (stare decisis) to a chapter on legal research tools and techniques which enable one to discover these precedents. It continues with an explanation of what a "legal issue" is and how one discovers it among various facts relevant to a case, but not …
-
In Originalism's Stead: Old Constitutions and Originalism's Normative Foundations
… interpretation-construction distinction and 2) stare decisis and democratic legitimacy. Taken together, these avenues point to originalism’s fading normative justification and legitimacy in light of the challenges that old constitutions and their characteristics pose for the judicial philosophy.
-
Towards the Ideal: Coherence Theories of Judicial Adjudication and the Ideal Law in Hard Cases
… of Angelo-American legal theory, hard cases, and stare decisis, coherence theories of judicial adjudication will be presented and shown to suffer from conservatism. This will be argued to create problems both in unjust and just societies. The ideal law methodology, which is adapted from arguments …
-
Precedentes no direito brasileiro : a tradição jurídica ocidental entre instrumentos, métodos e história
… pretende apurar a viabilidade da introdução do stare decisis em sistema predominantemente de direito legislado. A análise parte de uma comparação histórica entre a tradição romano-canônica e o common law, a fim de identificar as origens, momentos de divergências e o atual estágio de aproximação, …
-
A relação e a compatibilidade entre o constitucionalismo contemporâneo, a democratização da função jurisdicional e os precedentes vinculantes no ordenamento brasileiro
Celebrated by some and criticized by others, the stare decisis system adopted by the Brazilian procedural law is, undoubtedly, one of the most important innovations of this procedural statute. Even if it is possible to affirm that the judges were already forced to follow precedents, it is …
-
O mito da prestação jurisdicional pelos tribunais superiores brasileiros
… pode ser fruto de mera repetição (common law stare decisis). Pode ser o resultado do raciocínio fático/jurídico real, fictício, mitificado, com negação de prestação jurisdicional, ainda que em um processo judicial resolvido silogisticamente. Pode ser fruto de mitificação invertendo o …
-
The formulation of a coherent South African approach to the classification of income and the taxation of international cross-border partnerships
… case. Bearing in mind the principle of stare decisis and the constitutional obligation to develop South African common law in line with international law, it is necessary that a body of work be developed to begin the process of reconciling South African sources of law into one coherent …
-
The Impact of Supreme Court Precedent in a Judicial Hierarchy
… analysis offer new insights on the influence of stare decisis and decision-making behavior within the U.S. Supreme Court and the U.S. Courts of Appeals.
-
The Act of Judging in Nigeria: A Matter of Interpretation and Judicial Discretion
… using the common law system with the doctrine of stare decisis (i.e., judicial precedents). This doctrine has shaped the context of judging in Nigeria, especially as strict adherence to precedent somewhat impacts the use of judicial discretion in the interpretation of statutes. Judging is not …
-
The state of international arbitration: the possibility of establishing an appeal mechanism
… This is possible because binding precedent and stare decisis do not operate in international investment arbitration. The conflicting decisions that are being made are causing a crisis of consistency and uniformity in international investment arbitration. In order to address this crisis and …
-
The impact of dissenting opinions upon thedevelopment of Australian constitutional law
… when a minority Justice yields to the demands of stare decisis. The impact of dissent upon the development of the Court’s constitutional interpretation is evaluated. Although the study finds that direct reversals in the law in favour of an earlier dissent occur very rarely, it argues that dissents …
-
A constitucionalização do processo : a virada do paradigma racional e político no processo civil brasileiro do estado democrático constitucional
… em razão da recepção tardia e mitigada do stare decisis no direito brasileiro (súmulas vinculantes, decisões vinculantes em controle de constitucionalidade e jurisprudência dominante dos tribunais), bem como, da importância dos modelos judiciais na densificação dos conteúdos das …
-
IL VALORE DEL 'PRECEDENTE' NELLA GIURISPRUDENZA DEL GIUDICE DELL'UNIONE EUROPEA
… pivotal conditions allowing the development of a stare decisis system. The second part of the present thesis is focused on the peculiar features of the judicial precedent in the case law of the Court of Justice. In particular, we could notice, firstly, the absence of a clear definition and …
-
The Brazilian Model of Precedents: a New Hybrid between Civil and Common Law?
… on some of the advantages of the doctrine of stare decisis – stability, certainty of law, equality, time-saving –, as positive criteria of functionality, in order to analyse improvements in the deliverance of justice in Brazil since the adoption of a more comprehensive approach to binding …
Page 1 of 2