{"id":{"repo_id":"mcmaster","oai_identifier":"oai:macsphere.mcmaster.ca:11375/33487"},"canonical_url":"https://search.ndltd.org/etd/mcmaster/oai:macsphere.mcmaster.ca:11375/33487","repository":{"repo_id":"mcmaster","name":"McMaster University","base_url":"https://macsphere.mcmaster.ca/server/oai/request"},"display":{"title":"Maternal and Neonatal Outcomes Following Trial of Labour After Cesarean Birth and the Role of Operative Vaginal Birth","abstract":"Background: Over the past three decades, rates of cesarean birth (CB) have been rising steadily in high-resource settings, and one critical reason for this trend is the growing number of individuals with repeat CB. People with a previous CB thus represent an important target for studying alternatives to CB such as through the increased uptake of trial of labour after cesarean birth (TOLAC). TOLAC is undertaken to avoid the risks associated with multiple CBs in subsequent pregnancies. Presently, TOLAC outcomes are usually conceptualized as resulting in either a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) or an elective repeat cesarean birth (ERCB). However, this oversimplification masks important heterogeneity within the VBAC group. As such, the comparative relative safety of different modes of birth – notably operative vaginal birth (OVB; forceps or vacuum) – among individuals with a TOLAC remains uncertain. Objectives: The objectives of this dissertation were: 1) To map and evaluate the literature examining operative vaginal birth compared with second-stage CB among individuals with a TOLAC; 2) To describe the distribution of operative birth modes and quantify the association between operative delivery mode and maternal morbidity among individuals with a previous CB in Canada; 3) To compare severe maternal morbidity associated with attempted forceps birth and vacuum birth among individuals with a TOLAC in Canada and to evaluate whether this association varies by pelvic station; and 4) To compare the rate of severe neonatal morbidity and neonatal mortality associated with forceps versus vacuum birth among individuals with previous cesarean birth in the United States. Methods: To address objective 1, a scoping review was conducted. For objectives 2-3, data from over 230,590 individuals with a previous CB from the mother-centric linked file carried out by Statistics Canada was leveraged. For objective 4, data from over 722,032 births with VBAC from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Center for Health Statistics was used. These studies are unique as they reflect nationally representative cohorts possessing rich demographic, labour and delivery, and maternal or infant health information. For objectives 2-4, population-based analyses were conducted. Multivariable logistic and modified Poisson regression models with overlap weights were used to quantify associations. To address objective 3 and 4, novel epidemiologic methods were applied, including an intention-to-treat framework, multivariable regression and propensity score overlap weighting, regression risk analyses and recycled predictions, effect modification analyses, and quantitative bias analysis. Results: In chapter 2, the review emphasized that the existing evidence base around maternal morbidity is insufficient to support confident clinical decision-making between OVB compared with CB in the second stage of labour. Chapter 3 demonstrated that a considerable proportion of births required an OVB and that maternal morbidity differed substantially across operative delivery pathways. Compared with ERCB, rates of severe maternal morbidity were higher among individuals with TOLAC and varied by mode of vaginal birth, notably demonstrating higher rates of maternal morbidity with forceps and combined instrument births. To extend these investigations further, chapter 4 uncovered substantially higher rates of severe maternal morbidity with forceps birth than vacuum birth, and severe hemorrhage and surgical complications were the leading contributors to maternal morbidity in this population. Lastly, chapter 5 did not uncover meaningful differences in severe neonatal morbidity or severe neonatal morbidity and mortality between forceps and vacuum births apart from a higher likelihood of prolonged assisted ventilation among infants delivered by forceps. Collectively, the population-based studies suggest that differences between forceps and vacuum may be more pronounced for maternal outcomes than for severe neonatal outcomes. Conclusions: Across a series of complementary studies, the findings demonstrate that VBAC is a heterogeneous outcome and that maternal and neonatal risks vary according to the specific pathway through which vaginal birth is achieved. Ultimately, this dissertation contributes contemporary evidence to inform clinical management during TOLAC and provides a more nuanced understanding of the maternal and neonatal outcomes associated with forceps birth, vacuum birth, and repeat cesarean birth. These findings highlight the importance of considering VBAC as a heterogeneous outcome, which may improve counseling, support informed decision-making, and enhance care for individuals with a prior cesarean birth.","abstract_html":"Background: Over the past three decades, rates of cesarean birth (CB) have been rising steadily in high-resource settings, and one critical reason for this trend is the growing number of individuals with repeat CB. People with a previous CB thus represent an important target for studying alternatives to CB such as through the increased uptake of trial of labour after cesarean birth (TOLAC). TOLAC is undertaken to avoid the risks associated with multiple CBs in subsequent pregnancies. Presently, TOLAC outcomes are usually conceptualized as resulting in either a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) or an elective repeat cesarean birth (ERCB). However, this oversimplification masks important heterogeneity within the VBAC group. As such, the comparative relative safety of different modes of birth – notably operative vaginal birth (OVB; forceps or vacuum) – among individuals with a TOLAC remains uncertain. Objectives: The objectives of this dissertation were: 1) To map and evaluate the literature examining operative vaginal birth compared with second-stage CB among individuals with a TOLAC; 2) To describe the distribution of operative birth modes and quantify the association between operative delivery mode and maternal morbidity among individuals with a previous CB in Canada; 3) To compare severe maternal morbidity associated with attempted forceps birth and vacuum birth among individuals with a TOLAC in Canada and to evaluate whether this association varies by pelvic station; and 4) To compare the rate of severe neonatal morbidity and neonatal mortality associated with forceps versus vacuum birth among individuals with previous cesarean birth in the United States. Methods: To address objective 1, a scoping review was conducted. For objectives 2-3, data from over 230,590 individuals with a previous CB from the mother-centric linked file carried out by Statistics Canada was leveraged. For objective 4, data from over 722,032 births with VBAC from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Center for Health Statistics was used. These studies are unique as they reflect nationally representative cohorts possessing rich demographic, labour and delivery, and maternal or infant health information. For objectives 2-4, population-based analyses were conducted. Multivariable logistic and modified Poisson regression models with overlap weights were used to quantify associations. To address objective 3 and 4, novel epidemiologic methods were applied, including an intention-to-treat framework, multivariable regression and propensity score overlap weighting, regression risk analyses and recycled predictions, effect modification analyses, and quantitative bias analysis. Results: In chapter 2, the review emphasized that the existing evidence base around maternal morbidity is insufficient to support confident clinical decision-making between OVB compared with CB in the second stage of labour. Chapter 3 demonstrated that a considerable proportion of births required an OVB and that maternal morbidity differed substantially across operative delivery pathways. Compared with ERCB, rates of severe maternal morbidity were higher among individuals with TOLAC and varied by mode of vaginal birth, notably demonstrating higher rates of maternal morbidity with forceps and combined instrument births. To extend these investigations further, chapter 4 uncovered substantially higher rates of severe maternal morbidity with forceps birth than vacuum birth, and severe hemorrhage and surgical complications were the leading contributors to maternal morbidity in this population. Lastly, chapter 5 did not uncover meaningful differences in severe neonatal morbidity or severe neonatal morbidity and mortality between forceps and vacuum births apart from a higher likelihood of prolonged assisted ventilation among infants delivered by forceps. Collectively, the population-based studies suggest that differences between forceps and vacuum may be more pronounced for maternal outcomes than for severe neonatal outcomes. Conclusions: Across a series of complementary studies, the findings demonstrate that VBAC is a heterogeneous outcome and that maternal and neonatal risks vary according to the specific pathway through which vaginal birth is achieved. Ultimately, this dissertation contributes contemporary evidence to inform clinical management during TOLAC and provides a more nuanced understanding of the maternal and neonatal outcomes associated with forceps birth, vacuum birth, and repeat cesarean birth. These findings highlight the importance of considering VBAC as a heterogeneous outcome, which may improve counseling, support informed decision-making, and enhance care for individuals with a prior cesarean birth.","abstract_has_math":false,"creators":["Oltean, Irina Ioana."],"institution":"Not Applicable","degree_name":null,"degree_level":null,"degree_discipline":null,"degree_department":"Health Research Methodology","school":null,"contributors":[],"advisors":["Muraca, Giulia"],"committee_chairs":[],"committee_members":[],"year":2026,"date_issued":"2026","date_published":"2026","updated_at":"2026-11-18T19:38:13Z","subjects":["pregnancy","trial of labor","labor stage (second)","Cesarean section","elective repeat cesarean birth","emergency cesarean birth","spontaneous vaginal birth","operative vaginal birth","vacuum","forceps","combined instruments","severe maternal morbidity","obstetric anal sphincter injury","severe neonatal morbidity and mortality","severe neonatal morbidity"],"languages":["en"],"rights":["Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Canada"],"rights_urls":["http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.5/ca/"],"identifier_entries":[{"key":"dc:identifier.issn","label":"ISSN","values":["Not Applicable"],"render_values":[{"text":"Not Applicable","href":null,"code":true}]},{"key":"dc:identifier.uri","label":"Identifier URI","values":["https://doi.org/10.71548/2271"],"render_values":[{"text":"https://doi.org/10.71548/2271","href":"https://doi.org/10.71548/2271","code":true}]},{"key":"dc:identifier.citation","label":"Dc Identifier Citation","values":["Not Applicable"],"render_values":[{"text":"Not Applicable","href":null,"code":true}]}],"person_identifier_entries":[]},"links":{"outbound_url":"https://hdl.handle.net/11375/33487","outbound_label":"Handle","outbound_source":"dc:identifier.uri","record_url":"https://hdl.handle.net/11375/33487","record_label":"Repository record","record_kind":"handle","record_source":"dc:identifier.uri","download_url":null,"download_label":null,"download_source":null,"access_status":null,"embargo_until":null,"access_note":null},"source_record":{"url":"https://macsphere.mcmaster.ca/server/oai/request?verb=GetRecord&metadataPrefix=dim&identifier=oai%3Amacsphere.mcmaster.ca%3A11375%2F33487","prefix":"dim"},"metadata_groups":[{"id":"people","label":"People","entries":[{"key":"dc:contributor.advisor","label":"Advisor","values":["Muraca, Giulia"]},{"key":"dc:contributor.department","label":"Department","values":["Health Research Methodology"]},{"key":"dc:creator","label":"Author","values":["Oltean, Irina Ioana."]}]},{"id":"academic_context","label":"Academic Context","entries":[{"key":"dc:date.accessioned","label":"Dc Date Accessioned","values":["2026-08-24T18:20:15Z"]},{"key":"dc:date.issued","label":"Date","values":["2026"]},{"key":"dc:publisher","label":"Institution","values":["Not Applicable"]},{"key":"dc:relation.ispartofseries","label":"Dc Relation Ispartofseries","values":["Not Applicable; Not Applicable"]},{"key":"dc:type","label":"Dc Type","values":["Dissertation","Thesis"]}]},{"id":"subjects_keywords","label":"Subjects and Keywords","entries":[{"key":"dc:subject","label":"Dc Subject","values":["pregnancy","trial of labor","labor stage (second)","Cesarean section","elective repeat cesarean birth","emergency cesarean birth","spontaneous vaginal birth","operative vaginal birth","vacuum","forceps","combined instruments","severe maternal morbidity","obstetric anal sphincter injury","severe neonatal morbidity and mortality","severe neonatal morbidity"]}]},{"id":"language_rights","label":"Language and Rights","entries":[{"key":"dc:language.iso","label":"Language (ISO)","values":["en"]},{"key":"dc:rights","label":"Dc Rights","values":["Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Canada"]},{"key":"dc:rights.uri","label":"Rights URI","values":["http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.5/ca/"]}]},{"id":"identifiers","label":"Identifiers","entries":[{"key":"dc:identifier.citation","label":"Dc Identifier Citation","values":["Not Applicable"]},{"key":"dc:identifier.issn","label":"ISSN","values":["Not Applicable"]},{"key":"dc:identifier.uri","label":"Identifier URI","values":["https://hdl.handle.net/11375/33487","https://doi.org/10.71548/2271"]}]},{"id":"additional","label":"Additional Metadata","entries":[{"key":"dc:description","label":"Description","values":["Not Applicable"]},{"key":"dc:description.abstract","label":"Abstract","values":["Background: Over the past three decades, rates of cesarean birth (CB) have been rising steadily in high-resource settings, and one critical reason for this trend is the growing number of individuals with repeat CB. People with a previous CB thus represent an important target for studying alternatives to CB such as through the increased uptake of trial of labour after cesarean birth (TOLAC). TOLAC is undertaken to avoid the risks associated with multiple CBs in subsequent pregnancies. Presently, TOLAC outcomes are usually conceptualized as resulting in either a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) or an elective repeat cesarean birth (ERCB). However, this oversimplification masks important heterogeneity within the VBAC group. As such, the comparative relative safety of different modes of birth – notably operative vaginal birth (OVB; forceps or vacuum) – among individuals with a TOLAC remains uncertain. Objectives: The objectives of this dissertation were: 1) To map and evaluate the literature examining operative vaginal birth compared with second-stage CB among individuals with a TOLAC; 2) To describe the distribution of operative birth modes and quantify the association between operative delivery mode and maternal morbidity among individuals with a previous CB in Canada; 3) To compare severe maternal morbidity associated with attempted forceps birth and vacuum birth among individuals with a TOLAC in Canada and to evaluate whether this association varies by pelvic station; and 4) To compare the rate of severe neonatal morbidity and neonatal mortality associated with forceps versus vacuum birth among individuals with previous cesarean birth in the United States. Methods: To address objective 1, a scoping review was conducted. For objectives 2-3, data from over 230,590 individuals with a previous CB from the mother-centric linked file carried out by Statistics Canada was leveraged. For objective 4, data from over 722,032 births with VBAC from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Center for Health Statistics was used. These studies are unique as they reflect nationally representative cohorts possessing rich demographic, labour and delivery, and maternal or infant health information. For objectives 2-4, population-based analyses were conducted. Multivariable logistic and modified Poisson regression models with overlap weights were used to quantify associations. To address objective 3 and 4, novel epidemiologic methods were applied, including an intention-to-treat framework, multivariable regression and propensity score overlap weighting, regression risk analyses and recycled predictions, effect modification analyses, and quantitative bias analysis. Results: In chapter 2, the review emphasized that the existing evidence base around maternal morbidity is insufficient to support confident clinical decision-making between OVB compared with CB in the second stage of labour. Chapter 3 demonstrated that a considerable proportion of births required an OVB and that maternal morbidity differed substantially across operative delivery pathways. Compared with ERCB, rates of severe maternal morbidity were higher among individuals with TOLAC and varied by mode of vaginal birth, notably demonstrating higher rates of maternal morbidity with forceps and combined instrument births. To extend these investigations further, chapter 4 uncovered substantially higher rates of severe maternal morbidity with forceps birth than vacuum birth, and severe hemorrhage and surgical complications were the leading contributors to maternal morbidity in this population. Lastly, chapter 5 did not uncover meaningful differences in severe neonatal morbidity or severe neonatal morbidity and mortality between forceps and vacuum births apart from a higher likelihood of prolonged assisted ventilation among infants delivered by forceps. Collectively, the population-based studies suggest that differences between forceps and vacuum may be more pronounced for maternal outcomes than for severe neonatal outcomes. Conclusions: Across a series of complementary studies, the findings demonstrate that VBAC is a heterogeneous outcome and that maternal and neonatal risks vary according to the specific pathway through which vaginal birth is achieved. Ultimately, this dissertation contributes contemporary evidence to inform clinical management during TOLAC and provides a more nuanced understanding of the maternal and neonatal outcomes associated with forceps birth, vacuum birth, and repeat cesarean birth. These findings highlight the importance of considering VBAC as a heterogeneous outcome, which may improve counseling, support informed decision-making, and enhance care for individuals with a prior cesarean birth."]},{"key":"dc:description.degree","label":"Dc Description Degree","values":["Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)"]},{"key":"dc:description.sponsorship","label":"Dc Description Sponsorship","values":["I received the 2022 Canadian Institutes of Health Research Doctoral Research Award: Canada Graduate Scholarship, who had no part in the conception or development of manuscripts related to these projects. The analyses presented in chapters 3 to 5 in this dissertation were funded by the Marta and Owen Boris Foundation and/or the Alternative Funding Plan for the Academic Health Sciences Centres of Ontario. The remaining chapters were otherwise unfunded."]},{"key":"dc:title","label":"Title","values":["Maternal and Neonatal Outcomes Following Trial of Labour After Cesarean Birth and the Role of Operative Vaginal Birth"]},{"key":"dc:title.alternative","label":"Alternative Title","values":["Operative Birth in Trials of Labour After Cesarean Birth"]},{"key":"others:access_status","label":"Others Access Status","values":["open.access"]}]}],"canonical_facts":{"dc:contributor.advisor":["Muraca, Giulia"],"dc:contributor.department":["Health Research Methodology"],"dc:creator":["Oltean, Irina Ioana."],"dc:date.accessioned":["2026-08-24T18:20:15Z"],"dc:date.issued":["2026"],"dc:description":["Not Applicable"],"dc:description.abstract":["Background: Over the past three decades, rates of cesarean birth (CB) have been rising steadily in high-resource settings, and one critical reason for this trend is the growing number of individuals with repeat CB. People with a previous CB thus represent an important target for studying alternatives to CB such as through the increased uptake of trial of labour after cesarean birth (TOLAC). TOLAC is undertaken to avoid the risks associated with multiple CBs in subsequent pregnancies. Presently, TOLAC outcomes are usually conceptualized as resulting in either a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) or an elective repeat cesarean birth (ERCB). However, this oversimplification masks important heterogeneity within the VBAC group. As such, the comparative relative safety of different modes of birth – notably operative vaginal birth (OVB; forceps or vacuum) – among individuals with a TOLAC remains uncertain. Objectives: The objectives of this dissertation were: 1) To map and evaluate the literature examining operative vaginal birth compared with second-stage CB among individuals with a TOLAC; 2) To describe the distribution of operative birth modes and quantify the association between operative delivery mode and maternal morbidity among individuals with a previous CB in Canada; 3) To compare severe maternal morbidity associated with attempted forceps birth and vacuum birth among individuals with a TOLAC in Canada and to evaluate whether this association varies by pelvic station; and 4) To compare the rate of severe neonatal morbidity and neonatal mortality associated with forceps versus vacuum birth among individuals with previous cesarean birth in the United States. Methods: To address objective 1, a scoping review was conducted. For objectives 2-3, data from over 230,590 individuals with a previous CB from the mother-centric linked file carried out by Statistics Canada was leveraged. For objective 4, data from over 722,032 births with VBAC from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Center for Health Statistics was used. These studies are unique as they reflect nationally representative cohorts possessing rich demographic, labour and delivery, and maternal or infant health information. For objectives 2-4, population-based analyses were conducted. Multivariable logistic and modified Poisson regression models with overlap weights were used to quantify associations. To address objective 3 and 4, novel epidemiologic methods were applied, including an intention-to-treat framework, multivariable regression and propensity score overlap weighting, regression risk analyses and recycled predictions, effect modification analyses, and quantitative bias analysis. Results: In chapter 2, the review emphasized that the existing evidence base around maternal morbidity is insufficient to support confident clinical decision-making between OVB compared with CB in the second stage of labour. Chapter 3 demonstrated that a considerable proportion of births required an OVB and that maternal morbidity differed substantially across operative delivery pathways. Compared with ERCB, rates of severe maternal morbidity were higher among individuals with TOLAC and varied by mode of vaginal birth, notably demonstrating higher rates of maternal morbidity with forceps and combined instrument births. To extend these investigations further, chapter 4 uncovered substantially higher rates of severe maternal morbidity with forceps birth than vacuum birth, and severe hemorrhage and surgical complications were the leading contributors to maternal morbidity in this population. Lastly, chapter 5 did not uncover meaningful differences in severe neonatal morbidity or severe neonatal morbidity and mortality between forceps and vacuum births apart from a higher likelihood of prolonged assisted ventilation among infants delivered by forceps. Collectively, the population-based studies suggest that differences between forceps and vacuum may be more pronounced for maternal outcomes than for severe neonatal outcomes. Conclusions: Across a series of complementary studies, the findings demonstrate that VBAC is a heterogeneous outcome and that maternal and neonatal risks vary according to the specific pathway through which vaginal birth is achieved. Ultimately, this dissertation contributes contemporary evidence to inform clinical management during TOLAC and provides a more nuanced understanding of the maternal and neonatal outcomes associated with forceps birth, vacuum birth, and repeat cesarean birth. These findings highlight the importance of considering VBAC as a heterogeneous outcome, which may improve counseling, support informed decision-making, and enhance care for individuals with a prior cesarean birth."],"dc:description.degree":["Doctor of Philosophy (PhD)"],"dc:description.sponsorship":["I received the 2022 Canadian Institutes of Health Research Doctoral Research Award: Canada Graduate Scholarship, who had no part in the conception or development of manuscripts related to these projects. The analyses presented in chapters 3 to 5 in this dissertation were funded by the Marta and Owen Boris Foundation and/or the Alternative Funding Plan for the Academic Health Sciences Centres of Ontario. The remaining chapters were otherwise unfunded."],"dc:identifier.citation":["Not Applicable"],"dc:identifier.issn":["Not Applicable"],"dc:identifier.uri":["https://hdl.handle.net/11375/33487","https://doi.org/10.71548/2271"],"dc:language.iso":["en"],"dc:publisher":["Not Applicable"],"dc:relation.ispartofseries":["Not Applicable; Not Applicable"],"dc:rights":["Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 2.5 Canada"],"dc:rights.uri":["http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-nd/2.5/ca/"],"dc:subject":["pregnancy","trial of labor","labor stage (second)","Cesarean section","elective repeat cesarean birth","emergency cesarean birth","spontaneous vaginal birth","operative vaginal birth","vacuum","forceps","combined instruments","severe maternal morbidity","obstetric anal sphincter injury","severe neonatal morbidity and mortality","severe neonatal morbidity"],"dc:title":["Maternal and Neonatal Outcomes Following Trial of Labour After Cesarean Birth and the Role of Operative Vaginal Birth"],"dc:title.alternative":["Operative Birth in Trials of Labour After Cesarean Birth"],"dc:type":["Dissertation","Thesis"],"others:access_status":["open.access"]},"updated_at":"2026-11-18T19:38:13Z"}