{"id":{"repo_id":"soton","oai_identifier":"oai:eprints.soton.ac.uk:254167"},"canonical_url":"https://search.ndltd.org/etd/soton/oai:eprints.soton.ac.uk:254167","repository":{"repo_id":"soton","name":"University of Southampton","base_url":"https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2"},"display":{"title":"Mind as Machine: Can Computational Processes Be Regarded As Explanatory of Mental Processes?","abstract":"The aim of the thesis is to evaluate recent work in artificial intelligence (AI). It is argued that such evaluation can be philosophically interesting, and examples are given of areas of the philosophy of AI where insufficient concentration on the actual results of AI has led to missed opportunities for the two disciplines — philosophy and AI — to benefit from cross-fertilization. The particular topic of the thesis is the use of AI techniques in psychological explanation. The claim is that such techniques can be of value in psychology, and the strategy of proof is to exhibit an area where this is the case. The field of model-based knowledge-based system (KBS) development is outlined; a type of model called a conceptual model will be shown to be psychologically explanatory of the expertise that it models. A group of major philosophies of explanation are examined, and it is discovered that such philosophies are too restrictive and prescriptive to be of much value in evaluating many areas of science; they fail to apply to scientific explanation generally. The importance of having sympathetic yardsticks for the evaluation of explanatory practices in arbitrary fields is defended, and a series of such yardsticks is suggested. The practice of providing information processing models in psychology is discussed. A particular type of model, a psychological competence model, is defined, and its use in psychological explanation defended. It is then shown that conceptual models used in model-based KBS development are psychological competence models. It follows therefore that such models are explanatory of the expertise they model. Furthermore, since KBSs developed using conceptual models share many structural characteristics with their conceptual models, it follows that a limited class of those systems are also explanatory of expertise. This constitutes an existence proof that computational processes can be explanatory of mental processes.","abstract_html":"The aim of the thesis is to evaluate recent work in artificial intelligence (AI). It is argued that such evaluation can be philosophically interesting, and examples are given of areas of the philosophy of AI where insufficient concentration on the actual results of AI has led to missed opportunities for the two disciplines — philosophy and AI — to benefit from cross-fertilization. The particular topic of the thesis is the use of AI techniques in psychological explanation. The claim is that such techniques can be of value in psychology, and the strategy of proof is to exhibit an area where this is the case. The field of model-based knowledge-based system (KBS) development is outlined; a type of model called a conceptual model will be shown to be psychologically explanatory of the expertise that it models. A group of major philosophies of explanation are examined, and it is discovered that such philosophies are too restrictive and prescriptive to be of much value in evaluating many areas of science; they fail to apply to scientific explanation generally. The importance of having sympathetic yardsticks for the evaluation of explanatory practices in arbitrary fields is defended, and a series of such yardsticks is suggested. The practice of providing information processing models in psychology is discussed. A particular type of model, a psychological competence model, is defined, and its use in psychological explanation defended. It is then shown that conceptual models used in model-based KBS development are psychological competence models. It follows therefore that such models are explanatory of the expertise they model. Furthermore, since KBSs developed using conceptual models share many structural characteristics with their conceptual models, it follows that a limited class of those systems are also explanatory of expertise. This constitutes an existence proof that computational processes can be explanatory of mental processes.","abstract_has_math":false,"creators":["O'Hara, Kieron"],"institution":"University of Oxford","degree_name":"Ph.D.","degree_level":"doctoral","degree_discipline":null,"degree_department":null,"school":null,"contributors":[],"advisors":[],"committee_chairs":[],"committee_members":[],"year":1994,"date_issued":"1994","date_published":"1994","updated_at":"2026-11-19T09:30:34Z","subjects":[],"languages":["eng"],"rights":[],"rights_urls":[],"identifier_entries":[],"person_identifier_entries":[{"key":"person:identifier.orcid","label":"ORCID","values":["0000000290514456"],"render_values":[{"text":"0000-0002-9051-4456","href":"https://orcid.org/0000-0002-9051-4456","code":true}]}]},"links":{"outbound_url":null,"outbound_label":null,"outbound_source":null,"record_url":null,"record_label":null,"record_kind":null,"record_source":null,"download_url":"https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/254167/1/ohara-oxford-dphil-thesis-1994.pdf","download_label":"Download PDF","download_source":"dc:identifier.uri","access_status":null,"embargo_until":null,"access_note":null},"source_record":{"url":"https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2?verb=GetRecord&metadataPrefix=uketd_dc&identifier=oai%3Aeprints.soton.ac.uk%3A254167","prefix":"uketd_dc"},"metadata_groups":[{"id":"people","label":"People","entries":[{"key":"dc:creator","label":"Author","values":["O'Hara, Kieron"]},{"key":"person:identifier.orcid","label":"ORCID","values":["0000000290514456"]}]},{"id":"academic_context","label":"Academic Context","entries":[{"key":"dc:date","label":"Dc Date","values":["1994"]},{"key":"dc:date.issued","label":"Date","values":["1994"]},{"key":"dc:publisher.department","label":"Dc Publisher Department","values":["Web & Internet Science (pre 2018 reorg)","Faculty of Philosophy : Faculty of Literae Humaniores, University of Oxford, and Worcester College, Oxford"]},{"key":"dc:publisher.institution","label":"Dc Publisher Institution","values":["University of Oxford"]},{"key":"dc:relation.isreferencedby","label":"Dc Relation Isreferencedby","values":["https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/254167/"]},{"key":"dc:relation.references","label":"Dc Relation References","values":["Peter Achinstein (1981) 'Can There Be a Model of Explanation?' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.136-59 Peter Achinstein (1983) The Nature of Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford) Peter Achinstein (1984) 'The Pragmatic Character of Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.326-44 W.R. Adrion, M.A. Branstad and J.C. Cherniavsky (1982) 'Validation, Verification and Testing of Computer Software' in ACM Computing Surveys vol.14 pp.159-92 Neil Agnew, Ken Ford and Pat Hayes (1994) 'Expertise in Context: Personally Constructed, Socially Selected and Reality-Relevant?' in International Journal of Expert Systems vol.7 pp.65-88 Alan R. Anderson (ed.) (1964) Minds and Machines (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.) Anjo Anjewierden, Jan Wielemaker and Catherine Toussaint (1992) 'Shelley — Computer-Aided Knowledge Engineering' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.4 pp.109-25 S. Barthélemy, P. Frot and N. Simonin (1988) Analysis Document Experiment F4 (KADS deliverable D3) Izak Benbasat and Jasbir S. Dhaliwal (1989) 'A Framework for the Validation of Knowledge Acquisition' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.1 pp.215-33 Francesco Bergadano (1993) 'Machine Learning and the Foundations of Inductive Inference' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.31-51 G. Blaauw (1976) Digital System Implementation (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.) Margaret A. Boden (ed.) (1990a) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford) Margaret A. Boden (1990b) 'Introduction' in Margaret A. Boden (ed.) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford) pp.1-21 Fergus Bolger, George Wright, Gene Rowe, John Gammack and Bob Wood (1989) 'LUST For Life: Developing Expert Systems for Life Assurance Underwriting' in Nigel Shadbolt (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems VI (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.128-39 Joost Breuker, Bob Wielinga, Maarten van Someren, Robert de Hoog, Guus Schreiber, Paul de Greef, Bert Bredeweg, Jan Wielemaker, Jean-Paul Billeaut, Massoud Davoodi and Simon Hayward (1987) Model-Driven Knowledge Acquisition: Interpretation Models (KADS deliverable D1) Baruch A. Brody (1972) 'Towards an Aristotelian Theory of Scientific Explanation' in Philosophy of Science vol.39 pp.20-31 Rodney A. Brooks (1991) 'Intelligence Without Representation' in Artificial Intelligence vol.47 pp.139-59 S. Bromberger (1965) 'An Approach to Explanation' in R.J. Butler (ed.) Analytical Philosophy (Blackwells, Oxford), pp.72-105 S. Bromberger (1966) 'Why-Questions' in Robert Colodny (ed.) Mind and Cosmos: Essays in Contemporary Science and Philosophy (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh), pp.86-111 D.C. Brown and B. Chandrasekaran (1989) Design Problem Solving: Knowledge Structures and Control Strategies (Morgan Kaufman, San Mateo) B.G. Buchanan and E.A. Feigenbaum (1978) 'DENDRAL and Meta-DENDRAL: Their Applications Dimension' in Artificial Intelligence vol.11 pp.5-24 Alan Bundy (1987) 'How to Improve the Reliability of Expert Systems' in D.S. Moralee (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems IV (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.3-17 Tyler Burge (1986) 'Individualism and Psychology' in Philosophical Review vol.95 pp.3-45 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, A.D. Hedgecock and G. Rugg (1987) 'A Formal Evaluation of Knowledge Elicitation Techniques for Expert Systems: Domain 1' in D.S. Moralee (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems IV (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.136-45 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, G. Rugg and A.D. Hedgecock (1988) 'Knowledge Elicitation Techniques in Classification Domains' in Proceedings of the 8th European Conference on Artificial Intelligence (Pitman, London) pp.85-90 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, G. Rugg and A.D. Hedgecock (1990) 'The Efficacy of Knowledge Elicitation Techniques: A Comparison Across Domains and Levels of Expertise' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.2 pp.167-78 Tom Bylander and B. Chandrasekaran (1988) 'Generic Tasks for Knowledge-Based Reasoning: The \"Right\" Level of Abstraction for Knowledge Acquisition' in B.R. Gaines and J.H. Boose (eds.) Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems vol. i: Knowledge-Based Systems (Academic Press, San Diego) pp. 65-77 B. Chandrasekaran (1983) 'Towards a Taxonomy of Problem Solving Types' in AI Magazine vol.4(1) pp.9-17 B. Chandrasekaran (1990) 'Design Problem Solving: A Task Analysis' in AI Magazine vol.11(4) pp.59-71 B. Chandrasekaran and Todd R. Johnson (1993) 'Generic Tasks and Task Structures: History, Critique and New Directions' in J.-M. David, J.-P. Krivine and R. Simmons (eds.) Second Generation Expert Systems (Springer, Berlin) pp.232-72 B. Chandrasekaran, Michael C. Tanner and John R. Josephson (1989) 'Explaining Control Strategies in Problem solving' in IEEE Expert pp.9-24 Jean-Pierre Changeux (1985) Neuronal Man: The Biology of Mind (O.U.P., Oxford) Andrea Chierici, Maria Grazia Filippini and Marco Minati (1989) 'PORTAFOGLIO: A Portfolio Advisor Application' in Nigel Shadbolt (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems VI (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.140-52 William Child (1994) Causality, Interpretation and the Mind (O.U.P. Oxford) Patricia Smith Churchland (1986) Neurophilosophy: Toward a Unified Science of the Mind/Brain (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Paul M. Churchland (1970) 'The Logical Character of Action-Explanations' in Philosophical Review vol.79 pp.214-36 Paul M. Churchland (1979) Scientific Realism and the Plasticity of Mind (C.U.P., Cambridge) William J. Clancey (1983) 'The Epistemology of a Rule-Based Expert System — A Framework for Explanation' in Artificial Intelligence vol.20 pp.215-51 William J. Clancey (1985) 'Heuristic Classification' in Artificial Intelligence vol.27 pp.289-350 William J. Clancey (1991) 'The Frame of Reference Problem in the Design of Intelligent Machines' in K. VanLehn (ed.) Architectures for Intelligence (Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.) pp.357-423 William J. Clancey (1992) 'Model Construction Operators' in Artificial Intelligence vol.53 pp.1-115 Andy Clark (1989) Microcognition: Philosophy, Cognitive Science and Parallel Distributed Processing (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) L. Jonathan Cohen (1989) An Introduction to the Philosophy of Induction and Probability (Clarendon Press, Oxford) Neil Cooper (1994) 'Understanding' in Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society supp. vol.68 pp.1-26 Robert Cummins (1975) 'Functional Analysis' in Journal of Philosophy vol.72, pp.741-64. Page references to abridged version in Ned Block (ed.) Readings in the Philosophy of Psychology Volume 1 (Methuen, London, 1980) pp.185-90 Robert Cummins (1983) The Nature of Psychological Explanation (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Donald Davidson (1963) 'Actions, Reasons and Causes' in Essays on Actions and Events (O.U.P., Oxford 1980) pp.3-19 Randall Davis (1982) 'Teiresias: Applications of Meta-Level Knowledge' in R. Davis and D.B. Lenat (eds.) Knowledge-Based Systems in Artificial Intelligence (McGraw-Hill, New York) pp.227-490 Randall Davis (1987) 'Knowledge-Based Systems: The View in 1986' in W. Eric L. Grimson and Ramesh S. Patil (eds.) AI in the 1980s and Beyond: An M.I.T. Survey (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) pp.13-41 J.A. Deutsch (1962) The Structural Basis of Behaviour (C.U.P., Cambridge) Jasbir Singh Dhaliwal and Izak Benbasat (1990) 'A Framework for the Comparative Evaluation of Knowledge Acquisition Tools and Techniques' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.2 pp.145-66 John Domingue, Enrico Motta and Stuart Watt (1993) 'The Emerging VITAL Workbench' in N. Aussenac, G. Boy, B. Gaines, M. Linster, J.-G. Ganascia and Y. Kodratoff (eds.) Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems (Springer-Verlag, Berlin) pp.320-39 Hubert L. Dreyfus (1987) 'Misrepresenting Human Intelligence' in Rainer Born (ed.) Artificial Intelligence: The Case Against (Croon Helm, London) pp.41-54 Hubert L. Dreyfus and Stuart E. Dreyfus (1988) 'Making a Mind Versus Modeling the Brain: Artificial Intelligence Back at a Branchpoint' in Stephen R. Graubard (ed.) The Artificial Intelligence Debate: False Starts, Real Foundations (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) pp.15-43 Hubert L. Dreyfus, Stuart E. Dreyfus and Tom Athanasiou (1986) Mind Over Machine: The Power of Human Intuition and Expertise in the Era of the Computer (Blackwells, Oxford) Gerald M. Edelman (1992) Bright Air, Brilliant Fire: On the Matter of Mind (Penguin, Harmondsworth) Jerry A. Fodor (1987) Psychosemantics: The Problem of Meaning in the Philosophy of Mind (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Robert M. French (1990) 'Subcognition and the Limits of the Turing Test' in Mind vol.99 pp.53-65 Milton Friedman (1953) Essays in Positive Economics (University of Chicago Press, Chicago) B.R. Gaines (1988) 'Knowledge Acquisition and Technology' in Proceedings of the 3rd AAAI Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems Workshop (Banff, Canada) chapter 8 J. Gaschnig, P. Klahr, H. Pople, E. Shortliffe and A. Terry (1983) 'Evaluation of Expert Systems: Issues and Case Studies' in R. Hayes-Roth, D.A. Waterman and D.B. Lenat (eds.) Building Expert Systems (Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass.) pp.241-82 Michael R. Genesereth and Nils J. Nilsson (1987) Logical Foundations of Artificial Intelligence (Morgan Kaufman, Los Altos) Joseph Giarratano and Gary Riley (1989) Expert Systems: Principles and Programming (PWS-KENT, Boston) Nelson Goodman (1954) Fact, Fiction and Forecast (Athlone Press London) David Gries (1981) The Science of Programming (Springer Verlag, Berlin) Thomas R. Gruber (1992) Ontolingua: A Mechanism to Support Portable Ontologies Version 3.0 (Knowledge Systems Laboratory, Stanford) R.V. Guha and Douglas B. Lenat (1990) 'Cyc: A Midterm Report' in AI Magazine vol.11(3) pp.32-59 Stevan Harnad (1990) 'Lost in the Hermeneutic Hall of Mirrors' in The Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence vol.2 pp.321-7 Stevan Harnad (1991) 'Other Bodies, Other Minds: A Machine Incarnation of an Old Philosophical Problem' in Minds and Machines vol.1 pp.43-54 John Haugeland (ed.) (1981) Mind Design (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Larry Hauser (1993a) 'Why Isn't My Pocket Calculator a Thinking Thing?' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.3-10 Larry Hauser (1993b) 'The Sense of \"Thinking\"' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.21-9 Larry Hauser (1993c) 'Reaping the Whirlwind: Reply to Harnad's \"Other Bodies, Other Minds\"' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.219-37 S.A. Hayward, B.J. Wielinga and J.A. Breuker (1987) 'Structured Analysis of Knowledge' in International Journal of Man-Machine Studies vol.26 pp.487-98 Carl.G. Hempel (1945) 'Studies in the Logic of Confirmation' in Mind vol.54 pp.1-26, 97-121 Carl G. Hempel (1962a) 'Deductive-Nomological vs Statistical Explanation' in Herbert Feigl and Grover Maxwell (eds.) Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science III (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis) pp.98-169 Carl G. Hempel (1962b) 'Explanation in Science and in History' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.17-41 Carl G. Hempel (1965) Aspects of Scientific Explanation (Free Press, New York) Carl G. Hempel and Paul Oppenheim (1948) 'Studies in the Logic of Explanation' in Carl G. Hempel Aspects of Scientific Explanation (Free Press, New York 1965) pp.245-90 C.A.R. Hoare (1984) 'Programs are Predicates' in C.A.R. Hoare and J.C. Shepherdson (eds.) Mathematical Logic and Programming Languages (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1985) pp.141-54 Robert R. Hoffman (1980) 'Metaphor in Science' in R.P. Honeck and R.R. Hoffman (eds.) Cognition and Figurative Language (Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.) pp.393-423 Robert R. Hoffman (1985) 'Some Implications of Metaphor for Philosophy and Psychology of Science' in Wolf Paprotté and René Dirven (eds.) The Ubiquity of Metaphor: Metaphor in Language and Thought (John Benjamins, Amsterdam) pp.327-80 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1988) 'Functionalism and Broad Content' in Mind vol.97 pp.381-400 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1990) 'Program Explanation: A General Perspective' in Analysis vol.50 pp.107-17 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1992) 'Structural Explanation in Social Theory' in David Charles and Kathleen Lennon (eds.) Reduction, Explanation and Realism (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.97-131 Peter Jackson (1986) Introduction to Expert Systems (Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass.) P.N. Johnson-Laird (1988) The Computer and the Mind (Fontana, London) W. Karbach, Marc Linster and Angi Voß (1990) 'Model-Based Approaches: One Label — One Idea?' in Bob Wielinga, John Boose, Brian Gaines, Guus Schreiber and Maarten van Someren (eds) Current Trends in Knowledge Acquisition (IOS Press, Amsterdam) pp.173-189 G.A. Kelly (1955) The Psychology of Personal Constructs (Norton, New York) Philip Kitcher and Wesley C. Salmon (1987) 'Van Fraassen on Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.310-25 R.E. Korf (1985) 'Macro-Operators: A Weak Method for Learning' in Artificial Intelligence vol.26 pp.35-78 Henry E. Kyburg, Jr. (1965) 'Probability, Rationality and a Rule of Detachment' in Y. Bar-Hillel (ed.) Proceedings of the 1964 Congress for Logic, Methodology and the Philosophy of Science (North-Holland Amsterdam) pp.301-10 Henry E. Kyburg Jr. (1988) 'The Justification of Deduction in Science' in Adolf Grünbaum and Wesley C. Salmon (eds.) The Limitations of Deductivism (University of California Press, Berkeley) pp.61-94 R.C. Lacher (1993) 'Expert Networks: Paradigmatic Conflict, Technological Rapprochement' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.53-71 David Lewis (1986) 'Causal Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.182-206 Peter Lipton (1990) 'Contrastive Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.207-27 Nigel Major and Kieron O'Hara (1994) Using Generalised Directive Models to Represent Teaching Strategy Knowledge: A Description of COCA E.S.R.C. Centre for Research in Education, Development and Training Technical Report No.9 S. Marcus and J. McDermott (1989) 'SALT: A Knowledge Acquisition Tool for Propose-and-Revise Systems' in Artificial Intelligence vol.39 pp.1-37 David Marr (1982) Vision (Freeman, San Francisco) W.A. Martin and R.J. Fateman (1971) 'The MACSYMA System' in Proceedings of the Second Symposium on Symbolic and Algebraic Manipulation pp.59-75 J. McCarthy (1980) 'Circumscription — A Form of Non-Monotonic Reasoning' in Artificial Intelligence vol.13 pp.27-39 James L. McClelland, David E. Rumelhart and the PDP Research Group (1986) Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the Microstructure of Cognition Volume 2: Psychological and Biological Models (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Gregory McCulloch (1986) 'Scientism, Mind and Meaning' in Philip Pettit and John McDowell (eds.) Subject, Thought and Context (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.59-94 Warren S. McCulloch and Walter H. Pitts (1965) 'A Logical Calculus of the Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity' in Margaret A. Boden (ed.) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford 1990) pp.22-39 J. McDermott (1988) 'Preliminary Steps Toward a Taxonomy of Problem-Solving Methods' in S. Marcus (ed.) Automating Knowledge Acquisition for Expert Systems (Kluwer, Boston) pp.225-56 Colin McGinn (1982) 'The Structure of Content' in Andrew Woodfield (ed.) Thought and Object (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.207-58 Marvin Minsky (1975) 'A Framework for Representing Knowledge' in P.H. Winston (ed.) The Psychology of Computer Vision (McGraw-Hill, New York) pp.211-77 Katharina Morik (1989) 'Sloppy Modeling' in K Morik (ed.) Knowledge Representation and Organization in Machine Learning (Springer-Verlag, Berlin) pp.107-34 Adam Morton (1993) 'Mathematical Models: Questions of Trustworthiness' in British Journal for the Philosophy of Science vol.44 pp.659-74 Enrico Motta, Kieron O'Hara and Nigel Shadbolt (1994) 'Grounding GDMs: a Structured Case Study' in International Journal for Human-Computer Studies vol.40 pp.315-47 M.A. Musen (1989a) 'Conceptual Models of Interactive Knowledge-Acquisition Tools' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.1 pp.73-88 M.A. Musen (1989b) Automated Generation of Model-Based Knowledge-Acquisition Tools (Pitman, London) Nils J. Nilsson (1980) Principles of Artificial Intelligence (Tioga, Palo Alto) J.C. Nunnally (1967) Psychometric Theory (McGraw-Hill, New York) Kieron O'Hara (1993) 'A Representation of KADS-I Interpretation"]},{"key":"dc:type","label":"Dc Type","values":["Thesis"]},{"key":"dc:type.qualificationlevel","label":"Dc Type Qualificationlevel","values":["doctoral"]},{"key":"dc:type.qualificationname","label":"Dc Type Qualificationname","values":["Ph.D."]}]},{"id":"language_rights","label":"Language and Rights","entries":[{"key":"dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2","label":"Language (ISO 639-2)","values":["eng"]}]},{"id":"identifiers","label":"Identifiers","entries":[{"key":"dc:identifier.uri","label":"Identifier URI","values":["https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/254167/1/ohara-oxford-dphil-thesis-1994.pdf"]}]},{"id":"additional","label":"Additional Metadata","entries":[{"key":"dc:description.abstract","label":"Abstract","values":["The aim of the thesis is to evaluate recent work in artificial intelligence (AI). It is argued that such evaluation can be philosophically interesting, and examples are given of areas of the philosophy of AI where insufficient concentration on the actual results of AI has led to missed opportunities for the two disciplines — philosophy and AI — to benefit from cross-fertilization. The particular topic of the thesis is the use of AI techniques in psychological explanation. The claim is that such techniques can be of value in psychology, and the strategy of proof is to exhibit an area where this is the case. The field of model-based knowledge-based system (KBS) development is outlined; a type of model called a conceptual model will be shown to be psychologically explanatory of the expertise that it models. A group of major philosophies of explanation are examined, and it is discovered that such philosophies are too restrictive and prescriptive to be of much value in evaluating many areas of science; they fail to apply to scientific explanation generally. The importance of having sympathetic yardsticks for the evaluation of explanatory practices in arbitrary fields is defended, and a series of such yardsticks is suggested. The practice of providing information processing models in psychology is discussed. A particular type of model, a psychological competence model, is defined, and its use in psychological explanation defended. It is then shown that conceptual models used in model-based KBS development are psychological competence models. It follows therefore that such models are explanatory of the expertise they model. Furthermore, since KBSs developed using conceptual models share many structural characteristics with their conceptual models, it follows that a limited class of those systems are also explanatory of expertise. This constitutes an existence proof that computational processes can be explanatory of mental processes."]},{"key":"dc:format","label":"Dc Format","values":["text"]},{"key":"dcterms:accessrights","label":"Dcterms Accessrights","values":["public"]},{"key":"dc:title","label":"Title","values":["Mind as Machine: Can Computational Processes Be Regarded As Explanatory of Mental Processes?"]}]}],"canonical_facts":{"dc:creator":["O'Hara, Kieron"],"dc:date":["1994"],"dc:date.issued":["1994"],"dc:description.abstract":["The aim of the thesis is to evaluate recent work in artificial intelligence (AI). It is argued that such evaluation can be philosophically interesting, and examples are given of areas of the philosophy of AI where insufficient concentration on the actual results of AI has led to missed opportunities for the two disciplines — philosophy and AI — to benefit from cross-fertilization. The particular topic of the thesis is the use of AI techniques in psychological explanation. The claim is that such techniques can be of value in psychology, and the strategy of proof is to exhibit an area where this is the case. The field of model-based knowledge-based system (KBS) development is outlined; a type of model called a conceptual model will be shown to be psychologically explanatory of the expertise that it models. A group of major philosophies of explanation are examined, and it is discovered that such philosophies are too restrictive and prescriptive to be of much value in evaluating many areas of science; they fail to apply to scientific explanation generally. The importance of having sympathetic yardsticks for the evaluation of explanatory practices in arbitrary fields is defended, and a series of such yardsticks is suggested. The practice of providing information processing models in psychology is discussed. A particular type of model, a psychological competence model, is defined, and its use in psychological explanation defended. It is then shown that conceptual models used in model-based KBS development are psychological competence models. It follows therefore that such models are explanatory of the expertise they model. Furthermore, since KBSs developed using conceptual models share many structural characteristics with their conceptual models, it follows that a limited class of those systems are also explanatory of expertise. This constitutes an existence proof that computational processes can be explanatory of mental processes."],"dc:format":["text"],"dc:identifier.uri":["https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/254167/1/ohara-oxford-dphil-thesis-1994.pdf"],"dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2":["eng"],"dc:publisher.department":["Web & Internet Science (pre 2018 reorg)","Faculty of Philosophy : Faculty of Literae Humaniores, University of Oxford, and Worcester College, Oxford"],"dc:publisher.institution":["University of Oxford"],"dc:relation.isreferencedby":["https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/254167/"],"dc:relation.references":["Peter Achinstein (1981) 'Can There Be a Model of Explanation?' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.136-59 Peter Achinstein (1983) The Nature of Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford) Peter Achinstein (1984) 'The Pragmatic Character of Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.326-44 W.R. Adrion, M.A. Branstad and J.C. Cherniavsky (1982) 'Validation, Verification and Testing of Computer Software' in ACM Computing Surveys vol.14 pp.159-92 Neil Agnew, Ken Ford and Pat Hayes (1994) 'Expertise in Context: Personally Constructed, Socially Selected and Reality-Relevant?' in International Journal of Expert Systems vol.7 pp.65-88 Alan R. Anderson (ed.) (1964) Minds and Machines (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.) Anjo Anjewierden, Jan Wielemaker and Catherine Toussaint (1992) 'Shelley — Computer-Aided Knowledge Engineering' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.4 pp.109-25 S. Barthélemy, P. Frot and N. Simonin (1988) Analysis Document Experiment F4 (KADS deliverable D3) Izak Benbasat and Jasbir S. Dhaliwal (1989) 'A Framework for the Validation of Knowledge Acquisition' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.1 pp.215-33 Francesco Bergadano (1993) 'Machine Learning and the Foundations of Inductive Inference' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.31-51 G. Blaauw (1976) Digital System Implementation (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J.) Margaret A. Boden (ed.) (1990a) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford) Margaret A. Boden (1990b) 'Introduction' in Margaret A. Boden (ed.) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford) pp.1-21 Fergus Bolger, George Wright, Gene Rowe, John Gammack and Bob Wood (1989) 'LUST For Life: Developing Expert Systems for Life Assurance Underwriting' in Nigel Shadbolt (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems VI (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.128-39 Joost Breuker, Bob Wielinga, Maarten van Someren, Robert de Hoog, Guus Schreiber, Paul de Greef, Bert Bredeweg, Jan Wielemaker, Jean-Paul Billeaut, Massoud Davoodi and Simon Hayward (1987) Model-Driven Knowledge Acquisition: Interpretation Models (KADS deliverable D1) Baruch A. Brody (1972) 'Towards an Aristotelian Theory of Scientific Explanation' in Philosophy of Science vol.39 pp.20-31 Rodney A. Brooks (1991) 'Intelligence Without Representation' in Artificial Intelligence vol.47 pp.139-59 S. Bromberger (1965) 'An Approach to Explanation' in R.J. Butler (ed.) Analytical Philosophy (Blackwells, Oxford), pp.72-105 S. Bromberger (1966) 'Why-Questions' in Robert Colodny (ed.) Mind and Cosmos: Essays in Contemporary Science and Philosophy (University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh), pp.86-111 D.C. Brown and B. Chandrasekaran (1989) Design Problem Solving: Knowledge Structures and Control Strategies (Morgan Kaufman, San Mateo) B.G. Buchanan and E.A. Feigenbaum (1978) 'DENDRAL and Meta-DENDRAL: Their Applications Dimension' in Artificial Intelligence vol.11 pp.5-24 Alan Bundy (1987) 'How to Improve the Reliability of Expert Systems' in D.S. Moralee (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems IV (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.3-17 Tyler Burge (1986) 'Individualism and Psychology' in Philosophical Review vol.95 pp.3-45 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, A.D. Hedgecock and G. Rugg (1987) 'A Formal Evaluation of Knowledge Elicitation Techniques for Expert Systems: Domain 1' in D.S. Moralee (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems IV (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.136-45 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, G. Rugg and A.D. Hedgecock (1988) 'Knowledge Elicitation Techniques in Classification Domains' in Proceedings of the 8th European Conference on Artificial Intelligence (Pitman, London) pp.85-90 A.M. Burton, N.R. Shadbolt, G. Rugg and A.D. Hedgecock (1990) 'The Efficacy of Knowledge Elicitation Techniques: A Comparison Across Domains and Levels of Expertise' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.2 pp.167-78 Tom Bylander and B. Chandrasekaran (1988) 'Generic Tasks for Knowledge-Based Reasoning: The \"Right\" Level of Abstraction for Knowledge Acquisition' in B.R. Gaines and J.H. Boose (eds.) Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems vol. i: Knowledge-Based Systems (Academic Press, San Diego) pp. 65-77 B. Chandrasekaran (1983) 'Towards a Taxonomy of Problem Solving Types' in AI Magazine vol.4(1) pp.9-17 B. Chandrasekaran (1990) 'Design Problem Solving: A Task Analysis' in AI Magazine vol.11(4) pp.59-71 B. Chandrasekaran and Todd R. Johnson (1993) 'Generic Tasks and Task Structures: History, Critique and New Directions' in J.-M. David, J.-P. Krivine and R. Simmons (eds.) Second Generation Expert Systems (Springer, Berlin) pp.232-72 B. Chandrasekaran, Michael C. Tanner and John R. Josephson (1989) 'Explaining Control Strategies in Problem solving' in IEEE Expert pp.9-24 Jean-Pierre Changeux (1985) Neuronal Man: The Biology of Mind (O.U.P., Oxford) Andrea Chierici, Maria Grazia Filippini and Marco Minati (1989) 'PORTAFOGLIO: A Portfolio Advisor Application' in Nigel Shadbolt (ed.) Research and Development in Expert Systems VI (C.U.P., Cambridge) pp.140-52 William Child (1994) Causality, Interpretation and the Mind (O.U.P. Oxford) Patricia Smith Churchland (1986) Neurophilosophy: Toward a Unified Science of the Mind/Brain (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Paul M. Churchland (1970) 'The Logical Character of Action-Explanations' in Philosophical Review vol.79 pp.214-36 Paul M. Churchland (1979) Scientific Realism and the Plasticity of Mind (C.U.P., Cambridge) William J. Clancey (1983) 'The Epistemology of a Rule-Based Expert System — A Framework for Explanation' in Artificial Intelligence vol.20 pp.215-51 William J. Clancey (1985) 'Heuristic Classification' in Artificial Intelligence vol.27 pp.289-350 William J. Clancey (1991) 'The Frame of Reference Problem in the Design of Intelligent Machines' in K. VanLehn (ed.) Architectures for Intelligence (Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.) pp.357-423 William J. Clancey (1992) 'Model Construction Operators' in Artificial Intelligence vol.53 pp.1-115 Andy Clark (1989) Microcognition: Philosophy, Cognitive Science and Parallel Distributed Processing (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) L. Jonathan Cohen (1989) An Introduction to the Philosophy of Induction and Probability (Clarendon Press, Oxford) Neil Cooper (1994) 'Understanding' in Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society supp. vol.68 pp.1-26 Robert Cummins (1975) 'Functional Analysis' in Journal of Philosophy vol.72, pp.741-64. Page references to abridged version in Ned Block (ed.) Readings in the Philosophy of Psychology Volume 1 (Methuen, London, 1980) pp.185-90 Robert Cummins (1983) The Nature of Psychological Explanation (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Donald Davidson (1963) 'Actions, Reasons and Causes' in Essays on Actions and Events (O.U.P., Oxford 1980) pp.3-19 Randall Davis (1982) 'Teiresias: Applications of Meta-Level Knowledge' in R. Davis and D.B. Lenat (eds.) Knowledge-Based Systems in Artificial Intelligence (McGraw-Hill, New York) pp.227-490 Randall Davis (1987) 'Knowledge-Based Systems: The View in 1986' in W. Eric L. Grimson and Ramesh S. Patil (eds.) AI in the 1980s and Beyond: An M.I.T. Survey (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) pp.13-41 J.A. Deutsch (1962) The Structural Basis of Behaviour (C.U.P., Cambridge) Jasbir Singh Dhaliwal and Izak Benbasat (1990) 'A Framework for the Comparative Evaluation of Knowledge Acquisition Tools and Techniques' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.2 pp.145-66 John Domingue, Enrico Motta and Stuart Watt (1993) 'The Emerging VITAL Workbench' in N. Aussenac, G. Boy, B. Gaines, M. Linster, J.-G. Ganascia and Y. Kodratoff (eds.) Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems (Springer-Verlag, Berlin) pp.320-39 Hubert L. Dreyfus (1987) 'Misrepresenting Human Intelligence' in Rainer Born (ed.) Artificial Intelligence: The Case Against (Croon Helm, London) pp.41-54 Hubert L. Dreyfus and Stuart E. Dreyfus (1988) 'Making a Mind Versus Modeling the Brain: Artificial Intelligence Back at a Branchpoint' in Stephen R. Graubard (ed.) The Artificial Intelligence Debate: False Starts, Real Foundations (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) pp.15-43 Hubert L. Dreyfus, Stuart E. Dreyfus and Tom Athanasiou (1986) Mind Over Machine: The Power of Human Intuition and Expertise in the Era of the Computer (Blackwells, Oxford) Gerald M. Edelman (1992) Bright Air, Brilliant Fire: On the Matter of Mind (Penguin, Harmondsworth) Jerry A. Fodor (1987) Psychosemantics: The Problem of Meaning in the Philosophy of Mind (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Robert M. French (1990) 'Subcognition and the Limits of the Turing Test' in Mind vol.99 pp.53-65 Milton Friedman (1953) Essays in Positive Economics (University of Chicago Press, Chicago) B.R. Gaines (1988) 'Knowledge Acquisition and Technology' in Proceedings of the 3rd AAAI Knowledge Acquisition for Knowledge-Based Systems Workshop (Banff, Canada) chapter 8 J. Gaschnig, P. Klahr, H. Pople, E. Shortliffe and A. Terry (1983) 'Evaluation of Expert Systems: Issues and Case Studies' in R. Hayes-Roth, D.A. Waterman and D.B. Lenat (eds.) Building Expert Systems (Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass.) pp.241-82 Michael R. Genesereth and Nils J. Nilsson (1987) Logical Foundations of Artificial Intelligence (Morgan Kaufman, Los Altos) Joseph Giarratano and Gary Riley (1989) Expert Systems: Principles and Programming (PWS-KENT, Boston) Nelson Goodman (1954) Fact, Fiction and Forecast (Athlone Press London) David Gries (1981) The Science of Programming (Springer Verlag, Berlin) Thomas R. Gruber (1992) Ontolingua: A Mechanism to Support Portable Ontologies Version 3.0 (Knowledge Systems Laboratory, Stanford) R.V. Guha and Douglas B. Lenat (1990) 'Cyc: A Midterm Report' in AI Magazine vol.11(3) pp.32-59 Stevan Harnad (1990) 'Lost in the Hermeneutic Hall of Mirrors' in The Journal of Experimental and Theoretical Artificial Intelligence vol.2 pp.321-7 Stevan Harnad (1991) 'Other Bodies, Other Minds: A Machine Incarnation of an Old Philosophical Problem' in Minds and Machines vol.1 pp.43-54 John Haugeland (ed.) (1981) Mind Design (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Larry Hauser (1993a) 'Why Isn't My Pocket Calculator a Thinking Thing?' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.3-10 Larry Hauser (1993b) 'The Sense of \"Thinking\"' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.21-9 Larry Hauser (1993c) 'Reaping the Whirlwind: Reply to Harnad's \"Other Bodies, Other Minds\"' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.219-37 S.A. Hayward, B.J. Wielinga and J.A. Breuker (1987) 'Structured Analysis of Knowledge' in International Journal of Man-Machine Studies vol.26 pp.487-98 Carl.G. Hempel (1945) 'Studies in the Logic of Confirmation' in Mind vol.54 pp.1-26, 97-121 Carl G. Hempel (1962a) 'Deductive-Nomological vs Statistical Explanation' in Herbert Feigl and Grover Maxwell (eds.) Minnesota Studies in the Philosophy of Science III (University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis) pp.98-169 Carl G. Hempel (1962b) 'Explanation in Science and in History' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.17-41 Carl G. Hempel (1965) Aspects of Scientific Explanation (Free Press, New York) Carl G. Hempel and Paul Oppenheim (1948) 'Studies in the Logic of Explanation' in Carl G. Hempel Aspects of Scientific Explanation (Free Press, New York 1965) pp.245-90 C.A.R. Hoare (1984) 'Programs are Predicates' in C.A.R. Hoare and J.C. Shepherdson (eds.) Mathematical Logic and Programming Languages (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, N.J. 1985) pp.141-54 Robert R. Hoffman (1980) 'Metaphor in Science' in R.P. Honeck and R.R. Hoffman (eds.) Cognition and Figurative Language (Lawrence Erlbaum, Hillsdale, N.J.) pp.393-423 Robert R. Hoffman (1985) 'Some Implications of Metaphor for Philosophy and Psychology of Science' in Wolf Paprotté and René Dirven (eds.) The Ubiquity of Metaphor: Metaphor in Language and Thought (John Benjamins, Amsterdam) pp.327-80 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1988) 'Functionalism and Broad Content' in Mind vol.97 pp.381-400 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1990) 'Program Explanation: A General Perspective' in Analysis vol.50 pp.107-17 Frank Jackson and Philip Pettit (1992) 'Structural Explanation in Social Theory' in David Charles and Kathleen Lennon (eds.) Reduction, Explanation and Realism (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.97-131 Peter Jackson (1986) Introduction to Expert Systems (Addison Wesley, Reading, Mass.) P.N. Johnson-Laird (1988) The Computer and the Mind (Fontana, London) W. Karbach, Marc Linster and Angi Voß (1990) 'Model-Based Approaches: One Label — One Idea?' in Bob Wielinga, John Boose, Brian Gaines, Guus Schreiber and Maarten van Someren (eds) Current Trends in Knowledge Acquisition (IOS Press, Amsterdam) pp.173-189 G.A. Kelly (1955) The Psychology of Personal Constructs (Norton, New York) Philip Kitcher and Wesley C. Salmon (1987) 'Van Fraassen on Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.310-25 R.E. Korf (1985) 'Macro-Operators: A Weak Method for Learning' in Artificial Intelligence vol.26 pp.35-78 Henry E. Kyburg, Jr. (1965) 'Probability, Rationality and a Rule of Detachment' in Y. Bar-Hillel (ed.) Proceedings of the 1964 Congress for Logic, Methodology and the Philosophy of Science (North-Holland Amsterdam) pp.301-10 Henry E. Kyburg Jr. (1988) 'The Justification of Deduction in Science' in Adolf Grünbaum and Wesley C. Salmon (eds.) The Limitations of Deductivism (University of California Press, Berkeley) pp.61-94 R.C. Lacher (1993) 'Expert Networks: Paradigmatic Conflict, Technological Rapprochement' in Minds and Machines vol.3 pp.53-71 David Lewis (1986) 'Causal Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.182-206 Peter Lipton (1990) 'Contrastive Explanation' in David-Hillel Ruben (ed.) Explanation (O.U.P., Oxford 1993) pp.207-27 Nigel Major and Kieron O'Hara (1994) Using Generalised Directive Models to Represent Teaching Strategy Knowledge: A Description of COCA E.S.R.C. Centre for Research in Education, Development and Training Technical Report No.9 S. Marcus and J. McDermott (1989) 'SALT: A Knowledge Acquisition Tool for Propose-and-Revise Systems' in Artificial Intelligence vol.39 pp.1-37 David Marr (1982) Vision (Freeman, San Francisco) W.A. Martin and R.J. Fateman (1971) 'The MACSYMA System' in Proceedings of the Second Symposium on Symbolic and Algebraic Manipulation pp.59-75 J. McCarthy (1980) 'Circumscription — A Form of Non-Monotonic Reasoning' in Artificial Intelligence vol.13 pp.27-39 James L. McClelland, David E. Rumelhart and the PDP Research Group (1986) Parallel Distributed Processing: Explorations in the Microstructure of Cognition Volume 2: Psychological and Biological Models (M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, Mass.) Gregory McCulloch (1986) 'Scientism, Mind and Meaning' in Philip Pettit and John McDowell (eds.) Subject, Thought and Context (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.59-94 Warren S. McCulloch and Walter H. Pitts (1965) 'A Logical Calculus of the Ideas Immanent in Nervous Activity' in Margaret A. Boden (ed.) The Philosophy of Artificial Intelligence (O.U.P., Oxford 1990) pp.22-39 J. McDermott (1988) 'Preliminary Steps Toward a Taxonomy of Problem-Solving Methods' in S. Marcus (ed.) Automating Knowledge Acquisition for Expert Systems (Kluwer, Boston) pp.225-56 Colin McGinn (1982) 'The Structure of Content' in Andrew Woodfield (ed.) Thought and Object (Clarendon Press, Oxford) pp.207-58 Marvin Minsky (1975) 'A Framework for Representing Knowledge' in P.H. Winston (ed.) The Psychology of Computer Vision (McGraw-Hill, New York) pp.211-77 Katharina Morik (1989) 'Sloppy Modeling' in K Morik (ed.) Knowledge Representation and Organization in Machine Learning (Springer-Verlag, Berlin) pp.107-34 Adam Morton (1993) 'Mathematical Models: Questions of Trustworthiness' in British Journal for the Philosophy of Science vol.44 pp.659-74 Enrico Motta, Kieron O'Hara and Nigel Shadbolt (1994) 'Grounding GDMs: a Structured Case Study' in International Journal for Human-Computer Studies vol.40 pp.315-47 M.A. Musen (1989a) 'Conceptual Models of Interactive Knowledge-Acquisition Tools' in Knowledge Acquisition vol.1 pp.73-88 M.A. Musen (1989b) Automated Generation of Model-Based Knowledge-Acquisition Tools (Pitman, London) Nils J. Nilsson (1980) Principles of Artificial Intelligence (Tioga, Palo Alto) J.C. Nunnally (1967) Psychometric Theory (McGraw-Hill, New York) Kieron O'Hara (1993) 'A Representation of KADS-I Interpretation"],"dcterms:accessrights":["public"],"dc:title":["Mind as Machine: Can Computational Processes Be Regarded As Explanatory of Mental Processes?"],"dc:type":["Thesis"],"dc:type.qualificationlevel":["doctoral"],"dc:type.qualificationname":["Ph.D."],"person:identifier.orcid":["0000000290514456"]},"updated_at":"2026-11-19T09:30:34Z"}