Darwin first proposed sexual selection as a process to explain the evolution of extravagant morphological traits in males. Despite being potentially detrimental to individual survival, such traits evolve because they increase a male's reproductive success, and provide a net benefit to their fitness. Mate competition is the source of sexual selection, and healthier, more vigorous males are likely to be superior competitors. Because most genes are likely to impact an individual’s health/vigour, sexual selection should act across much of the genome to favour the same alleles as natural selection, thereby promoting adaptation. On the other side of the coin, adaptation to an environment should enhance male sexual fitness, since it is likely to increase the overall health/vigour of individuals within a population, though tests of this prediction are rare and results are mixed. Taking advantage of a long-term evolution experiment involving replicate populations of Drosophila melanogaster, I performed a reciprocal transplant in which the sexual fitness of males was compared when raised in an environment to which they are well adapted and in one to which they are not. I improved on past tests via a comprehensive measure of male sexual fitness that included pre- and post-copulatory reproductive success in a competitive assay under conditions that closely mirrored those to which the populations have been evolving. I found that sexual fitness was higher in locally-adapted males from these experimental populations, a result that was consistent across environments that also manipulated the context in which mate competition occurred.

Social dominance can influence the allocation of resources in animal groups and has important consequences for individual fitness. In my thesis, I examined the structure, formation, maintenance and consequences of dominance, in the cooperatively breeding pukeko (Porphyrio melanotus melantous: Aves). I first describe a quantitative analysis of pukeko dominance networks (Chapter 2), which included one of the first applications of exponential random graph models in behavioural ecology. This study demonstrated that pukeko form highly ordered dominance hierarchies, and that dominance relationships were influenced by both the attributes of individual birds, as well as self-organizational processes such as winner and loser effects. Additionally, I demonstrated that hatching order has an important influence on the formation of dominance relationships, with earlier hatched chicks achieving higher dominance ranks as adults (Chapter 3). To maintain dominance relationships, pukeko use their red frontal shield as a ‘status signal’, with larger frontal shields indicating more dominant individuals. I showed that sexual dimorphism in frontal shield size is dramatically different in two pukeko populations, probably due to differences in the intensity of intrasexual competition (Chapter 4). Furthermore, by manipulating apparent frontal shield size, I demonstrated that shield phenotype both influences, and is influenced by, social interactions (Chapter 5). This bi-directional relationship between signals and social interactions challenges conventional signalling theory, and has important implications for how honesty is maintained in this signalling system. Finally, I expanded my findings on pukeko colour traits by exploring interspecific patterns of bill colouration in over 1600 bird species (Chapter 6). This study revealed that colourful bills likely evolved as a signal used in competitive interactions, rather than as a sexual signal. Taken together, my research provides a significant advancement in our understanding of the complex nature of dominance in a wild bird, and provides both a methodological and theoretical basis for future studies on animal social behaviour. / Thesis / Doctor of Science (PhD)

No description available.

Elaborate sexual ornaments evolve because mate choice exerts strong sexual selection favouring individuals with high levels of ornament expression. Consequently, even at evolutionary equilibrium, life history theory predicts that ornamental traits should be under directional sexual selection that opposes contrasting selection to reduce the costs associated with their maintenance. Otherwise, the resources used to maintain ornaments should be used to improve other life history functions. Elaborate female ornaments have only evolved in a few species, despite females commonly experiencing strong sexual selection. One explanation for this rarity is that male preferences for female ornaments may be self-limiting: females with higher mating success become less attractive because of the lower paternity share they provide to mates with every additional sperm competitor. The unusual species in which female ornaments do occur can provide rare insight into how selection can favour the expression of expensive characters in females despite their costs. The main goal of my thesis was to determine how sexual selection acts on exaggerated sexual ornaments, and give new insight into how these ornaments may have evolved, in spite of the self-limiting nature of selection on male preferences. To determine the strength of sexual selection acting on female ornamentation in dance flies, we developed new microsatellite markers to assess polyandry rates by genotyping stored sperm in wild female dance flies. We first used polyandry rates to determine whether ornament expression was associated with higher mating success in female Rhamphomyia longicauda, a species that has evolved two distinct and exaggerated female ornaments. Contrary to our predictions, we found no evidence that females with larger ornaments enjoy higher mating success. We then compared polyandry rates in R. longicauda to those of two other species of dance fly, one (Empis aestiva) that has i independently evolved female ornaments on its legs, and another (E. tessellata) that does not possess any discernable female ornaments. We also estimated the opportunity for sexual selection, which we found to be similar and relatively low in all three species. Moreover, the standardized sexual selection gradients for ornaments were weak and non-significant in all three species. Females with more elaborate ornaments, in both within- and cross-species comparisons, therefore did not enjoy higher mating success. Overall, these results suggested that sexual selection operates rather differently in females compared to males, potentially explaining the general rarity of female ornaments. Our amplifications of stored sperm were able to reveal more than just mate numbers. We developed new methods to study patterns of sperm storage in wild female dance flies. We investigated how the skew in sperm genotypes from mixed sperm stores changed with varying levels of polyandry. Our data suggested that sperm stores were dominated by a single male in R. longicauda, and that the proportion of sperm contributed by this dominant male was largely independent of the number of rival males’ sperm present in the spermatheca. These results were consistent with the expectation of males using sperm ‘offence strategies’ in sperm competition and that the most successful male is likely to be the female’s last partner before oviposition. As a whole, my thesis contributed new molecular resources for an understudied and fascinating group of organisms. It exploited these new resources to provide the first estimates of lifetime mating success in several related species, and suggested that the general prediction that ornament expression should covary with sexual selection intensity does not seem to hold in this group. Instead, both the unusual prevalence of ii ornaments and the inconsistent evidence for sexual selection that sustains them in dance flies may owe their existence to the confluence of two important factors. First, the conditions under which sperm competition occurs: as last male precedence is likely, males are selected to prefer the most gravid females to secure a high fraction of her offspring’s paternity as they are unlikely to mate again before oviposition. Second, potent sexually antagonistic coevolution between hungry females and discerning males: females have evolved ornaments to disguise their stage of egg maturity to receive the benefits of nuptial gifts, while males face the challenge of distinguishing between gravidity and ornamentation in females.

No description available.

Sexual selection acts on traits that increase the reproductive success of an individual in competition with other individuals of the same sex over reproductive opportunities, through intra-sexual competition and inter-sexual mate choice. Because males benefit more from remating than females, they are subject to more intense sexual selection. Modern genetic tools have shown that females often mate promiscuously, thus prolonging sexual selection after insemination through intra-sexual (sperm competition) and inter-sexual (cryptic female choice) episodes. Despite increasing interest in post-copulatory sexual selection, the implications of sperm competition, cryptic female choice and underpinning mechanisms remain little understood. This thesis adopts an integrated approach to quantify the relative importance of post-copulatory episodes in the operation of sexual selection, elucidate their proximate mechanisms in the red junglefowl Gallus gallus. By combining behavioural observations of replicate groups with paternity data, I show that female promiscuity decreased the total opportunity for sexual selection in a group, but accounts for an unexpectedly large proportion of the variance in male reproductive success. By comparing the operation of sexual selection on multiple male traits, I show that post-copulatory sexual selection reinforced pre-copulatory sexual selection for male social dominance and that female preferred to mate with compatible males. I used experiments to study the mechanisms of post-copulatory sexual selection by studying the effect of seminal fluid in sperm competition and cryptic female choice in relation to male status and relatedness. Following previous work indicating that seminal fluid products influence sperm quality in this species, I tested in vivo whether the seminal fluid of an ejaculate acts differentially towards sperm from the same ejaculate and rival sperm, and found no evidence for this idea. Finally, I show that cryptic female choice can drastically bias the outcome of sperm competition, and that female fowl might bias paternity toward unrelated males.

The evolutionary processes of sexual selection are investigated in this study by developing a new model for the evolution of epigamic traits and examining the effects of male-male competition, female choice and filial cannibalism in a field population of the Cortez damselfish (Stegastes rectifraenum). Two general processes have been proposed to explain the evolution of epigamic traits: the good genes process and the Fisherian process. A third process leading to the evolution of epigamic traits is presented here: the good parent process. Epigamic traits arise through this process by clarifying the differences in non-heritable parental quality among potential mates. A population genetic model is developed, which further suggests that increases in the frequency of good fathers in the population and phenotypic plasticity enhance the evolution of a good parent trait. The relative strengths of female choice and male-male competition were studied in S. rectifraenum by direct observation of reproductive behavior, and through field experiments. Male body size was found to be the single most important correlate of male reproductive success. Males were removed from their territories to determine the extent to which the vacant territories were valued by other local males. All of the territories were quickly recolonized by new males and sites that initially showed the highest reproductive success continued to be the most successful when new residents were present. A second experiment involved standardizing nests in 30 territories. Under these conditions male body size was no longer correlated with reproductive success, indicating that females are strongly influenced by variance in natural nest sites. Consequently, male-male competition over territories containing high quality nest sites, in combination with female choice of those sites, generates the observed correlation between male body size and reproductive success. Partial clutch filial cannibalism by male S. rectifraenum was studied in the same population. A group of custodial males were fed eggs, while controls remained unfed. Both groups were dissected on the next day to determine the number of eggs in their stomachs. Fed males had significantly fewer eggs in their guts, indicating that they indeed feed on the eggs they guard, rather than take them incidently during nest maintenance activities. A second egg feeding experiment showed that male behaviour and reproductive success are little affected by filial cannibalism; thus it is hypothesized that the energy gained by this behaviour is channelled primarily into growth and survival.

Over the last century, sexual selection has grown from a controversial theory into a vast field of theoretical and empirical research. Although Darwin outlined two major mechanisms within his theory, male-male competition and female mate choice, the latter has promoted a wealth of research by virtue of its complexity. Despite decades of research into how female preferences and sexually selected traits have evolved, there is still little consensus as to why females prefer the males they do. Preferences are thought to evolve from either direct selection on the preference, as females themselves benefit directly from mating with a preferred male, or through indirect selection on the preference via offspring fitness. In all cases however, female preferences should compensate for the costs of discriminating between potential mates, if they are to remain overall beneficial. The fitness benefits of mating with preferred males were investigated here using the fruitfly Drosophila simulans, employing a range of behavioural, phenotypic and quantitative genetic approaches. The findings presented here indicate that female Drosophila simulans do not gain directly from mating with a preferred male. Multiple mating can increase fecundity, although costs from male harassment can reduce the net benefit. They also indicate that females may benefit indirectly from mating with attractive males as attractiveness is heritable and sons of preferred males are themselves preferred. There is also evidence that attractive males are successful in both the pre- and post-copulatory sense, as preferred males are better sperm competitors than less-preferred males. However, although there appear to be benefits from preferred males via their sons, there appear to be no benefits from males via their daughters’ fitness. These findings collectively indicate that female preferences in Drosophila simulans are driven by indirectly selected benefits (via Fisherian sons), and that females benefit directly from mating multiply.

Ageing is the progressive decline in physiological performance with age, which is almost universal amongst multicellular organisms. While understanding ageing is an important aim in biological research, our current understanding of how and why we age is incomplete. In this thesis, I examine how sexual selection affects the evolution and mechanistic basis of ageing. I then explore how diet affects lifespan and reproduction in either sex. Finally, I test the hypotheses that oxidative stress, which occurs when cellular levels of Reactive Oxygen Species exceed circulating antioxidant defences causes ageing (i.e. the free radical theory of ageing) and/or constrains life-history strategies. To ask these questions, I employ quantitative genetics in decorated crickets Gryllodes sigillatus to examine the genetic co(variance) of ageing, lifespan, reproductive effort, oxidative damage and antioxidant protection. In the Australian field cricket, Teleogryllus commodus, I apply the geometric framework of nutrition to examine how lifespan, reproductive effort, oxidative damage and antioxidant capacity respond to dietary manipulation. In G. sigillatus, I found that sexual selection caused divergent strategies of age-dependent reproductive effort across the sexes and that this, in turn, promoted different rates of ageing in males and females. I found a trade-off between early reproductive effort and ageing rate in both sexes, although this trade-off was more pronounced in females (Chapter 3). I then explored the mechanistic basis of these sex-specific life-history strategies and, in support of the free radical theory of ageing, I found that oxidative damage was greatest in the shortest lived sex (females) and was negatively genetically correlated with lifespan. Additionally, oxidative damage was a cost of female reproductive effort that accelerated ageing, showing that oxidative stress may mediate sex-specific life-history strategies in decorated crickets (Chapter 4). If sexual selection affects reproduction and lifespan it should promote sex-specific life-history responses to dietary manipulation. In Australian black field crickets Teleogryllus commodus, I found that males and females have distinct dietary optima for lifespan and reproductive effort and that diet mediated a trade-off between these traits. I found that mating affected responses to dietary manipulation and caused sexual dimorphism in dietary intake under choice (Chapter 5). However, oxidative stress did not explain these life-history responses to dietary manipulation across the sexes (Chapter 6): although oxidative damage was greatest in the shortest lived sex (i.e. females), diets that extended lifespan did not reduce oxidative damage. My thesis illustrates the importance of considering sexual selection when considering the evolution and mechanistic basis of ageing. It offers equivocal support for the free radical theory of ageing but shows that oxidative stress may help underpin sex-specific life-history strategies. However, my results highlight that unravelling the relationship between oxidative stress and life-history strategies across the sexes will be a very difficult task.

Barriers to interbreeding limit gene flow between sister taxa, leading to reproductive isolation and the maintenance of distinct species. These barriers come in many forms, and can act at different stages in the reproductive process. Pre-copulatory barriers may be due to individuals discriminating against heterospecifics in mate choice decisions. These decisions may be informed through a range of sensory modalities. If a female is mated and inseminated, then there may be multiple postmating-prezygotic barriers that affect the success of heterospecific sperm in attaining fertilisations. Post-zygotic barriers can be very early acting, resulting in embryonic fatality, or may be later acting, affecting the fitness of hybrid offspring. In this thesis I investigate potential reproductive barriers between the interbreeding field crickets Gryllus bimaculatus and G. campestris. I find that females of both species show only weak preference for conspecific calling song, and may even respond phonotactically to songs typical of heterospecific males. Female G. bimaculatus are repeatable in their preferences and strength of response. G. bimaculatus females presented with synthetic songs prefer those with longer inter-pulse intervals, whereas G. campestris show no discrimination between these songs. Upon meeting, G. campestris females strongly discriminate against heterospecific males, behaving aggressively towards them. This is likely driven by females responding to close range species recognition cues, including chemoreception. The species differ in their cuticular hydrocarbon profiles, and females that are no longer able to use their antennae to receive chemosensory information reduced their aggressive behaviour towards heterospecific males. G. bimaculatus females will mate with heterospecific males, though less readily than to conspecifics. When sequentially mated to both conspecific and heterospecific males, these females will preferentially take up and store sperm from the conspecific male, and sperm from conspecific males is more likely to sire offspring than would be predicted from the proportion of sperm in storage. Eggs from inter-species mating pairs are less likely to begin embryogenesis, and are more likely to suffer developmental arrest during the early stages of embryogenesis. However hybrid embryos that survive to later stages of development have hatching success similar to that of pure-bred embryos. After mating, phonotaxis of G. bimaculatus females towards male songs follows a pattern of suppression and subsequent recovery, likely triggered through detection of seminal proteins transferred in the male ejaculate, or detection of mechanical filling of the spermatheca. This pattern of suppression and recovery of phonotaxis does not differ between females mated to conspecific or heterospecific males. Females that lay few or no eggs do not experience a refractory period.