Foreign object ingestion (FOI) into jet engines is a recurring scenario during the operation life of aircraft. Objects can range from as small as a pebble on the tarmac to the size of a large bird. Among the potential ingestion scenarios, damage caused by smaller objects may be considered to be negligible. Alternatively, larger objects can initiate progressive damage, potentially leading to catastrophic failure, compromising the integrity of the structure, and endangering the safety of passengers. Considering the dramatic increase in air traffic, FOI represents a crucial safety hazard, and must be better understood to minimize possible damage and structural failure. The main purpose of this study is to develop a unique methodology to assess the response and dynamic damage progression of an advanced, high-bypass propulsion system in the event of an FOI during operation. Using a finite element framework, a unique modeling methodology has been proposed in order to characterize the FOI response of the system. In order to demonstrate versatility of the computational analysis, the impact characteristics of two most common foreign object materials, bird and ice, were investigated. These materials were then defined in finite element domain, verified computationally, and then validated against the existing physical experiments. In addition to the mechanics of the two FOI materials, other material definitions, used to characterize the structures of the high-bypass propulsion system, were also explored. Both composite materials and rate dependent definitions for metal alloys were investigated to represent the damage mechanics in the event of an FOI. Subsequently, damage sequence of high-bypass propulsion systems subject to FOI was developed and assessed, using a uniquely devised Fluid-Structure Interaction (FSI) technique. Using advanced finite element formulation, this approach enabled the accurate simulation of the comprehensive damage progression of the propulsion systems by including aerodynamic interaction. Through this strategy, fluid mechanics was combined with structural mechanics in order to simulate the mutual interaction between both continua, allowing the interpretation of both the additional damage caused by the fluid flow and disrupted aerodynamics induced by the dynamic deformation of the fan blade. Subsequently, this multidisciplinary-multiphysics computational approach, in the framework of the comprehensive analysis methodology introduced, enabled the effective determination of details on the overall progressive impact damage, not traditionally available to propulsion designers. / PHD

This dissertation investigates the development of a methodology suitable for the evaluation of advanced propulsion concepts. At early stages of development, both the future performance of these concepts and their requirements are highly uncertain, making it difficult to forecast their future value. A systematic methodology to identify potential advanced propulsion concepts and assess their robustness is necessary to reduce the risk of developing advanced propulsion concepts. Existing advanced design methodologies have evaluated the robustness of technologies or concepts to variations in requirements, but they are not suitable to evaluate a large number of dissimilar concepts. Variations in requirements have been shown to impact the development of advanced propulsion concepts, and any method designed to evaluate these concepts must incorporate the possible variations of the requirements into the assessment. In order to do so, a methodology had to do two things. First, it had to systemically identify a probabilistic distribution for the future requirements. Such a distribution would allow decision-makers to quantify the uncertainty introduced by variations in requirements. Second, the methodology must assess the robustness of the propulsion concepts as a function of that distribution. These enabling elements have been synthesized into new methodology, the Evolving Requirements Technology Assessment (ERTA) method. The ERTA method was used to evaluate and compare advanced propulsion systems as possible power systems for a hurricane tracking, High Altitude, Long Endurance (HALE) unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV). The problem served as a good demonstration of the ERTA methodology because conventional propulsion systems will not be sufficient to power the UAV, but the requirements for such a vehicle are still uncertain.

The present thesis is the result of a research period at the Institute of Space and Astronautical Science of the Japanese Aerospace Exploration Agency, ISAS/JAXA within Funaki Laboratory of the Department of Space Flight Systems that followed the path of plume plasma diagnostics for space electric propulsion drives. During the experimental studies two high-current hollow cathodes and an innovative prototype of a low-voltage fully external discharge plasma thruster (XPT) had their plasma plumes diagnosed using electrostatic probes and retarding potential analyser (RPA). A Hall thruster and hollow cathode plume is defined as an unmagnetised quasi-neutral plasma which is mainly formed of neutral particles, electrons, singly and doubly charged ions. Plasma diagnostic techniques provide information through practical observations in order to fully understand the dynamics of the aforementioned plume components, the physical processes taking place within the plume and their effects on the spacecraft, for instance. Mastering these aspects of the plasma plume of space electric propulsion drives bolster the design processes, leading to highly efficient devices. Firstly, the introduction provides insights on the fundamental principles of hollow cathodes and Hall thrusters and a brief presentation of the plasma diagnostic techniques used during the research: single and double Langmuir probes, emissive probes and retarding potential analyser. Then, the fundamental plume diagnostics principles are depicted in an exhaustive way, departing from classical plasma kinetic theory, energy distribution functions and ending with an overview on the theory of charge collection by cylindrical probes. Subsequently, peculiarities of various analysis techniques are exposed for the Langmuir probes, emissive probes and RPA, with an emphasis on their strengths and demerits. The experimental setups for the cathodes and XPT plume diagnostic procedures are then outlined. The experimental logic, setup and electrical diagrams as well as a presentation of each probe design and manufacturing details are extensively discussed. The hollow cathodes experimental results are exposed with a discourse that aims of overviewing the difference between the various data analysis methods applied for the raw data. A discussion ensued based on the results in order to effectively identify mechanisms that produced the observed plasma parameters distributions. For the first time, the plume of a fully external discharge plasma thruster was diagnosed utilising double Langmuir probes.  The thesis highlights the main results obtained for the XPT far-field plume plasma diagnostics. The experimental findings for both thruster centreline positions and 2D plume maps for several axial distances away from the anode plate offer a ground basis for future measurements, a comparison term and a database to support ongoing computational codes. The results are discussed and related to the thruster performances data obtained during previous experiments. The thesis includes consistency analyses between the experimental data and the numerical simulation results and the uncertainties in measured plasma parameters associated with each data analysis procedure are evaluated for each data set. Last, the conclusions underline the main aspects of the research and further work on the previously mentioned plasma diagnostic techniques for hollow cathodes and XPT is suggested. / La présente thèse est le résultat d'une période de recherche à l'Institut des Sciences Spatiales et Astronautiques de l'Agence Spatiale Japonaise, ISAS / JAXA qui a suivi la voie des diagnostics du plasma de la plume de propulseurs électriques spatiaux. Au cours des études expérimentales, deux cathodes creuses à fort courant et un prototype innovant d'un propulseur basse tension à décharge externe de plasma (XPT) avaient leurs faisceaux de plasma diagnostiqués en utilisant des sondes électrostatiques et un analyseur à potentiel retardé. La plume d’un propulseur à effet Hall et d’une cathode creuse est définie comme un plasma quasi-neutre non-magnétisé qui est principalement formé de particules neutres, d’électrons, d’ions monovalents et bivalents. Les techniques de diagnostic du plasma fournissent des informations, via des observations pratiques, afin de bien comprendre la dynamique des composants de la plume mentionnés ci-dessus, les processus physiques qui se déroulent dans la plume et leurs effets sur une sonde spatiale, par exemple. La maîtrise de ces aspects du plasma de la plume généré par les propulseurs électriques spatiaux renforce les processus de conception de ce type de propulsion, ce qui conduit à des dispositifs hautement efficaces. Tout d'abord, l'introduction donne un aperçu sur les principes fondamentaux de cathodes creuses et de propulseurs à effet Hall, et une brève présentation des techniques de diagnostic du plasma utilisées lors de la recherche : sondes de Langmuir simples et doubles, des sondes émissives et d’analyseur à potentiel retardé. Ensuite, les principes fondamentaux de diagnostic de la plume sont représentés de manière exhaustive, d’abord la théorie cinétique classique du plasma, les fonctions de distribution en énergie et pour terminer une vue d'ensemble de la théorie de la collecte de charge par des sondes cylindriques. Par la suite, les particularités des diverses techniques d'analyse sont exposées pour les sondes de Langmuir, les sondes émissives et RPA, en mettant l'accent sur leurs avantages et leurs inconvénients. Les montages expérimentaux pour les procédures de diagnostic de la plume-plasma de cathodes et du XPT sont ensuite décrits. La logique expérimentale, les schémas électriques ainsi qu'une présentation de la conception et de la fabrication de chaque sonde sont largement discutés. Les résultats expérimentaux pour les cathodes creuses sont exposés de façon à présenter la différence entre plusieurs méthodes d'analyse de données appliquées aux données brutes. Une discussion s’ensuit, basée sur les résultats afin d'identifier efficacement les mécanismes qui ont produits les propriétés électroniques observées. Pour la première fois, la plume d'un propulseur à décharge externe de plasma a été diagnostiquée en utilisant des sondes de Langmuir doubles. La thèse met en évidence les principaux résultats obtenus pour le diagnostic en champ lointain de la plume-plasma du XPT. Les résultats expérimentaux pour les positions sur l'axe du propulseur et le cartes 2D de la plume pour plusieurs distances axiales loin de l’anode offrent une base pour de futures mesures, un terme de comparaison et une base de données pour appuyer les codes numériques. Les résultats sont discutés et sont rapportés aux données de performances du propulseur obtenus lors des essais précédents. La thèse comprend des analyses de la cohérence entre les données expérimentales et les résultats de simulation numérique, et les incertitudes des paramètres mesurés du plasma associées à chaque procédure d'analyse des données sont évaluées pour chaque ensemble de données. Enfin, les conclusions soulignent les principaux aspects de la recherche et une poursuite des travaux sur les techniques de diagnostic de plasma pour les cathodes creuses et le XPT est suggérée.