Spelling suggestions: "subject:"assessment reactivity"" "subject:"essessment reactivity""
1 |
Assessment Reactivity within the Context of a Web-Based Brief Intervention for Alcohol UseFazzino, Tera Leigh 01 January 2014 (has links)
Introduction: Unhealthy alcohol use is a substantial problem among college students and can lead to a variety of negative consequences. Commercially available web-based brief alcohol intervention (WBI) programs have demonstrated efficacy in a range of student groups and have been widely disseminated to colleges to address this issue. However, the majority of published WBI studies required participants to complete baseline research assessments (RA) about their alcohol use before the WBI and reactivity to the RA may have inflated WBI efficacy estimates in these studies. The present study tested whether there was an additive effect of RA administered online plus a WBI on alcohol consumption, alcohol consequences, and protective behaviors related to alcohol used in the past month compared to the effects of only a WBI. It was hypothesized that participants randomized to the RA+WBI condition would have significantly lower alcohol consumption in the past month, fewer alcohol-related problems, and use more protective behaviors related to alcohol consumption in the past month than participants randomized to the WBI only condition.
Methods: Undergraduate students (n= 856) from universities in the United States and Canada were recruited for this online study. Seventy percent of the sample was female and 82% were Caucasian. The sample had a mean age was 20.0. Sixty four percent (n= 547) of participants who were randomized completed the WBI. Sixty-eight percent completed the one month follow up questionnaire.
Results: Multiple regression analyses using 20 multiply imputed datasets revealed that there were no significant differences in groups at follow up on alcohol use measures, alcohol related problems, or protective behaviors used when controlling for variables with theoretical and statistical relevance to the models. A repeated measures analysis of covariance indicated that there was a significant decrease in peak estimated blood alcohol concentration from baseline to follow up, but no differential effect by randomization group. The results suggested there was a moderate effect of the WBI consistent with studies of WBI efficacy in the literature and that there were no substantial assessment reactivity effects.
Discussion: The current study contributes to the literature by identifying an experimental condition under which assessment reactivity may not be present and does not appear to cloud the detection of WBI efficacy when measured within subjects. The results indicate that WBI researchers may be justified in conducting brief pretreatment research assessments online to collect information about participant alcohol use without biasing within subjects estimates of WBI efficacy. Universities using these programs may likely observe similar effect sizes to those reported in the literature, however effectiveness studies are warranted.
|
2 |
Change over time in alcohol consumption in control groups in brief intervention studies: Systematic review and meta-regression study.Jenkins, R.J., McAlaney, John, McCambridge, J. January 2009 (has links)
No / Reactivity to assessment has attracted recent attention in the brief alcohol intervention literature. This
systematic review sought to examine the nature of change in alcohol consumption over time in control
groups in brief intervention studies. Primary studies were identified from existing reviews published in
English language, peer-reviewed journals between 1995 and 2005. Change in alcohol consumption and
selected study-level characteristics for each primary study were extracted. Consumption change data
were pooled in random effects models and meta-regression was used to explore predictors of change.
Eleven review papers reported the results of 44 individual studies. Twenty-six of these studies provided
data suitable for quantitative study. Extreme heterogeneity was identified and the extent of observed
reduction in consumption over time was greater in studies undertaken in Anglophone countries, with
single gender study participants, and without special targeting by age. Heterogeneity was reduced but
was still substantial in a sub-set of 15 general population studies undertaken in English language countries.
The actual content of the control group procedure itself was not predictive of reduction in drinking, nor
were a range of other candidate variables including setting, the exclusion of dependent drinkers, the
collection of a biological sample at follow-up, and duration of study. Further investigations may yield
novel insights into the nature of behaviour change with potential to inform brief interventions design.
|
Page generated in 0.0977 seconds