Heterochromatin in the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae is composed of polymers of the SIR (Silent Information Regulator) complex bound to nucleosomal DNA. Assembly of heterochromatin requires all three proteins of the Sir complex: the histone deacetylase Sir2, and histone binding proteins Sir3 and Sir4. Heterochromatin establishment requires passage through at least one cell cycle, but is not dependent on replication. Inhibition of chromatin modifying enzymes may be a mechanism for how cells limit assembly. Dot1 dependent methylation of H3K79 is suggested to inhibit de novo assembly. Halving the levels of Sir4 in cells causes a loss of silencing, suggesting that Sir4 protein abundance regulates the assembly of heterochromatin. We examine de novo assembly using a single cell assay. Half the level of Sir4 affects establishment, but not the maintenance, of silencing at HM loci. Additional Sir4 accelerates the rate of assembly. Epistasis analysis suggests that Dot1 dependent chromatin modification may act upstream of Sir4 abundance. We hypothesize that dot1Δ mutants speed assembly by disrupting telomeric heterochromatin, which liberates Sir4 to act at the HM loci. Deletion of YKU70, which specifically disrupts telomeric silencing, also speeds de novo assembly, without altering the methylation of histone H3. Consistent with our model, we have shown that Sir4 abundance falls during pheromone and stationary phase arrests after which several cell cycles are required before silencing can be reestablished.