Evolution of adaptation requires both generation of novel phenotypic variation and retention of a locally beneficial subset of this variation. Such retention can be facilitated by genetic assimilation, the accumulation of genetic and molecular mechanisms that stabilize induced phenotypes and assume progressively greater control over their reliable production. A particularly strong inference into genetic assimilation as an evolutionary process requires a system where it is possible to directly evaluate the extent to which an induced phenotype is progressively incorporated into preexisting developmental pathways. Evolution of diet-dependent pigmentation in birds-where external carotenoids are coopted into internal metabolism to a variable degree before being integrated with a feather's developmental processes-provides such an opportunity. Here we combine a metabolic network view of carotenoid evolution with detailed empirical study of feather modifications to show that the effect of physical properties of carotenoids on feather structure depends on their metabolic modification, their environmental recurrence, and biochemical redundancy, as predicted by the genetic assimilation hypothesis. Metabolized carotenoids caused less stochastic variation in feather structure and were more closely integrated with feather growth than were dietary carotenoids of the same molecular weight. These patterns were driven by the recurrence of organism-carotenoid associations: commonly used dietary carotenoids and biochemically redundant derived carotenoids caused less stochastic variation in feather structure than did rarely used or biochemically unique compounds. We discuss implications of genetic assimilation processes for the evolutionary diversification of diet-dependent animal coloration.

Many organisms can acclimate to new environments through phenotypic plasticity, a complex trait that can be heritable, be subject to selection, and evolve. However, the rate and genetic basis of plasticity evolution remain largely unknown. Experimentally evolved populations of the nematode Caenorhabditis remanei were created by selecting for stress resistance under different environmental conditions. This resource was used to address key questions about how phenotypic plasticity evolves and what the genetic basis of plasticity is. Here, I highlight ways in which a fuller understanding of the environmental context influences our interpretation of the evolution of phenotypic plasticity. In a population selected to withstand heat stress, an apparent case of genetic assimilation did not show correlated changes in global gene regulation. However, further investigation revealed that the induced plasticity was not fixed across environments, but rather the threshold for the response was shifted over evolutionary time. Similarly, the past environment experienced by populations can play a role in directing the multivariate response to selection. Correlated responses to selection between traits and across environments were examined. The pattern of covariation in the evolutionary response among traits differed depending on the environment in which selection occurred, indicating that there exists variation in pleiotropy across the stress response network that is highly sensitive to the external environment. To understand how the patterns of pleiotropy are altered by environment and evolution, there is a pressing need to determine the structure of the molecular networks underlying plastic phenotypes. Using RNA-sequencing, the structure of the gene regulatory network is examined for a subset of evolved populations from one environment. Key modules within this network were identified that are strong candidates for the evolution of phenotypic plasticity in this system. Together, the data presented in this dissertation provide a comprehensive view of the myriad ways in which the environment shapes the genetic architecture of stress response phenotypes and directs the evolution of phenotypic plasticity. Additionally, the structure of transcriptional network provides valuable insight into the genetic basis of adaptation to environmental change and the evolution of phenotypic plasticity. This dissertation includes both previously published and co-authored material.

The Extended Evolutionary Synthesis (EES) is currently emerging as a theoretical alternative to the Modern Synthesis (MS) in which to frame evolutionary observations and interpretations. These alternative frameworks differ fundamentally in their understanding of the relative roles of the genotype, phenotype, development and environment in evolutionary processes and patterns. While the MS represents a gene-centred view of evolution, the EES instead emphasizes the interactions between organism, development and environment. This novel theoretical framework has generated a number of evolutionary predictions that are mutually incompatible with the equivalent of the MS. While research and empirical testing has begun on a number of these in a neontological context, the field of palaeontology has yet to contribute meaningfully to this endeavour. One of the reasons for this is a lack of methodological approaches capable of investigating relevant evolutionary patterns in the fossil record. In this thesis morphometric methods capable of providing relevant data are developed and employed in the analysis of Cambrian fossils. Results of these analyses provide empirical support for the process of evolution through phenotypic plasticity and genetic assimilation hypothesized by the EES. Furthermore, theoretical revision to the species concept in a palaeontological context is suggested. Finally, predictions of the EES specific to the fossil record are made explicit and promising directions of future research are outlined.