Submitted by Nadir Basilio (nadirsb@uninove.br) on 2018-01-24T20:35:47Z No. of bitstreams: 1 Luigi Tavolaro Santini.pdf: 2357766 bytes, checksum: b70528f7db6bf88f1285744982eb4234 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2018-01-24T20:35:47Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 Luigi Tavolaro Santini.pdf: 2357766 bytes, checksum: b70528f7db6bf88f1285744982eb4234 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2017-02-23 / The present work deals with the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem with Three-Dimensional Loading Constraints. This problem is difficult to solve exactly, still relatively little studied, but important in the logistics activities of movement, warehousing and transportation. This problem consists in minimizing the total traveled distance by a homogeneous fleet of vehicles that address the issue of deliveries of customer demands, in which these demands are composed of items that have three relevant spatial dimensions. The objective of the present work is to develop heuristic and metaheuristic algorithms to solve the problem in question. The algorithms are based on the Clarke & Wright and George & Robinson heuristics, and on the Iterated Local Search and Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search metaheuristics. In the proposed algorithm, the routing problem is firstly addressed by adapting the Clarke & Wright heuristic, creating routes that are used to verify the loading pattern, thus obtaining an initial solution. In the following, an extensive search in the solution neighborhood is applied with the Iterated Local Search metaheuristic. For the best results of this search, it is checked if the loading pattern is feasible using an adapted George & Robinson algorithm. If it is not feasible, the Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search metaheuristic is executed in an attempt to find a feasible solution to the loading problem. Instances from the literature are used to evaluate the efficiency of the developed methods. The results obtained for the routing problem individually were of paramount importance to ensure the effectiveness of the Iterated Local Search metaheuristic. For the loading problem individually, the tests were also satisfactory, allowing for several feasible loading patterns using the adapted George & Robinson algorithm and the Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search metaheuristic. The results obtained with the proposed algorithm for the integrated problem were also good, being very close to those in the literature and with computational time relatively lower. As perspectives for future research, it is intended to investigate more efficient ways of exploring the solution space of the integrated problem, as well as the use of other metaheuristics. / O presente trabalho trata do Problema de Roteamento de Veículos Capacitado com Restrições de Carregamento Tridimensional. Este é um problema de difícil solução exata, ainda relativamente pouco estudado, porém importante nas atividades logísticas de movimentação, armazenagem e transporte de produtos. Este problema consiste em minimizar a distância total percorrida por uma frota homogênea de veículos que supram a questão das entregas das demandas de clientes, em que tais demandas são compostas por itens que possuem três dimensões espaciais relevantes. O objetivo do presente trabalho consiste em desenvolver algoritmos heurísticos e meta-heurísticos para resolver o problema em questão. Os algoritmos são baseados nas heurísticas de Clarke & Wright e de George & Robinson, e nas meta-heurísticas Iterated Local Search e Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search. No algoritmo proposto, primeiro trata-se o problema de roteamento adaptando-se a heurística de Clarke & Wright, criando roteiros que são utilizados para a verificação do padrão de carregamento, tendo-se assim uma solução inicial. Em seguida, é aplicada uma busca extensiva na vizinhança com a meta-heurística Iterated Local Search. Para os melhores resultados desta busca, verifica-se se o padrão de carregamento é viável utilizando o algoritmo de George & Robinson adaptado. Nos casos em que não é viável, a meta-heurística Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search é executada na tentativa de se encontrar soluções viáveis para o problema de carregamento. Instâncias da literatura são utilizadas para avaliar a eficiência dos métodos desenvolvidos. Os resultados obtidos para o problema de roteamento separadamente foram de suma importância para assegurar a eficiência do meta-heurística Iterated Local Search. Para o problema de carregamento separadamente, os testes utilizando o algoritmo de George & Robinson adaptado e a meta-heurística Adaptive Large Neighborhood Search também foram satisfatórios, permitindo a obtenção de vários padrões de carregamento factíveis. Os resultados obtidos com o algoritmo proposto para o problema integrado também foram bons, sendo bastante próximos aos da literatura e com tempo computacional relativamente menor. Como perspectivas de pesquisas futuras, pretende-se estudar formas mais eficientes de se explorar o espaço de busca do problema integrado, bem como a utilização de outras meta-heurísticas.

Submitted by Liliane Ferreira (ljuvencia30@gmail.com) on 2018-03-08T14:57:43Z No. of bitstreams: 2 Dissertação - Kamyla Maria Ferreira - 2018.pdf: 2406020 bytes, checksum: 87a4f31f5a394055dd9a84a1c7c73512 (MD5) license_rdf: 0 bytes, checksum: d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Luciana Ferreira (lucgeral@gmail.com) on 2018-03-12T11:16:50Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 2 Dissertação - Kamyla Maria Ferreira - 2018.pdf: 2406020 bytes, checksum: 87a4f31f5a394055dd9a84a1c7c73512 (MD5) license_rdf: 0 bytes, checksum: d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2018-03-12T11:16:50Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 2 Dissertação - Kamyla Maria Ferreira - 2018.pdf: 2406020 bytes, checksum: 87a4f31f5a394055dd9a84a1c7c73512 (MD5) license_rdf: 0 bytes, checksum: d41d8cd98f00b204e9800998ecf8427e (MD5) Previous issue date: 2018-02-16 / Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior - CAPES / This research deals with the resolution of problems that involve the location, routing, and packing decisions with focus on the location routing problem, capacitated vehicle routing problem with two-dimensional loading constraints, and location routing problem with two-dimensional loading constraints. For that, it is proposed a framework that reuses part of the algorithms, which are of a common domain, such that the development of the project is systematized. The objective of the framework is allowing the resolution of different variants of problems that integrate location, routing, and packing decisions without the need to replicate algorithms. As a proposal for an algorithm, it is developed a hybrid heuristic, which involves the cooperation between the simulated annealing and the artificial algae algorithm. The simulated annealing has four neighborhood operators, local search, and three procedures to diversify the solution. The artificial algae algorithm is combined with the skyline method in order to verify the feasibility of the two-dimensional packing constraints. Once the framework and heuristics have been codified, computational experiments are performed to test its performance, as well as comparisons are made with the most recent results published in the literature. The results show that the heuristic is competitive with other methods from the literature since it could obtain 36.25% solutions equal to the best ones reported in the literature of the location routing problem, besides the average GAP being 0.57%. For the vehicle routing problem with two-dimensional loading constraints, the heuristic could obtain 43.05% solutions equal to the best known in the literature, besides the average GAP being 3.33%. The results obtained for the location routing problem with twodimensional loading constraints were satisfactory. / Este trabalho trata da resolução de problemas que envolvem decisões de localização, roteamento e empacotamento com foco nos problemas de localização e roteamento, roteamento de veículos capacitado com restrições de empacotamento bidimensional, e localização e roteamento com restrições de empacotamento bidimensional. Para tanto, propõe-se um framework capaz de reutilizar parte dos algoritmos, que são de domínio comum, para que o desenvolvimento do projeto seja sistematizado. O objetivo é que o framework possibilite a resolução de diferentes variantes do problema que integram as decisões de localização, roteamento e empacotamento sem ter que replicar algoritmos. Como proposta de algoritmo, desenvolve-se uma heurística híbrida, a qual envolve a cooperação entre dois métodos, o recozimento simulado e o algoritmo artificial de algas. O recozimento simulado possui quatro operadores de vizinhança, procedimentos de busca local e três procedimentos para diversificar a solução. O algoritmo artificial de algas é combinado com a técnica Skyline para verificar as restrições de empacotamento bidimensional. A partir da codificação do framework e da heurística, experimentos computacionais foram realizados para testar o seu desempenho e comparar os resultados com os mais recentes da literatura. Os resultados indicam que a heurística é competitiva com os demais métodos da literatura, sendo possível obter 36,25% de soluções iguais às melhores reportadas na literatura do problema de localização e roteamento, além do GAP médio ter sido de 0,57%. No problema de roteamento de veículos com restrições de empacotamento bidimensional, a heurística obteve 43,05% soluções iguais às melhores conhecidas na literatura, além do GAP médio ter sido de 3,33%. Os resultados obtidos para o problema de localização e roteamento com restrições de empacotamento bidimensional foram satisfatórios.

Cette thèse s’intéresse aux problèmes de tournées de véhicules où l’on retrouve des contraintes de chargement ayant un impact sur les séquences de livraisons permises. Plus particulièrement, les items placés dans l’espace de chargement d’un véhicule doivent être directement accessibles lors de leur livraison sans qu’il soit nécessaire de déplacer d’autres items. Ces problèmes sont rencontrés dans plusieurs entreprises de transport qui livrent de gros objets (meubles, électroménagers). Le premier article de cette thèse porte sur une méthode exacte pour un problème de confection d’une seule tournée où un véhicule, dont l’aire de chargement est divisée en un certain nombre de piles, doit effectuer des cueillettes et des livraisons respectant une contrainte de type dernier entré, premier sorti. Lors d’une collecte, les items recueillis doivent nécessairement être déposés sur le dessus de l’une des piles. Par ailleurs, lors d’une livraison, les items doivent nécessairement se trouver sur le dessus de l’une des piles. Une méthode de séparation et évaluation avec plans sécants est proposée pour résoudre ce problème. Le second article présente une méthode de résolution exacte, également de type séparation et évaluation avec plans sécants, pour un problème de tournées de véhicules avec chargement d’items rectangulaires en deux dimensions. L’aire de chargement des véhicules correspond aussi à un espace rectangulaire avec une orientation, puisque les items doivent être chargés et déchargés par l’un des côtés. Une contrainte impose que les items d’un client soient directement accessibles au moment de leur livraison. Le dernier article aborde une problème de tournées de véhicules avec chargement d’items rectangulaires, mais où les dimensions de certains items ne sont pas connus avec certitude lors de la planification des tournées. Il est toutefois possible d’associer une distribution de probabilités discrète sur les dimensions possibles de ces items. Le problème est résolu de manière exacte avec la méthode L-Shape en nombres entiers. / In this thesis, we study mixed vehicle routing and loading problems where a constraint is imposed on delivery sequences. More precisely, the items in the loading area of a vehicle must be directly accessible, without moving any other item, at delivery time. These problems are often found in the transportation of large objects (furniture, appliances). The first paper proposes a branch-and-cut algorithm for a variant of the single vehicle pickup and delivery problem, where the loading area of the vehicle is divided into several stacks. When an item is picked up, it must be placed on the top of one of these stacks. Conversely, an item must be on the top of one of these stacks to be delivered. This requirement is called “Last In First Out” or LIFO constraint. The second paper presents another branch-and-cut algorithm for a vehicle routing and loading problem with two-dimensional rectangular items. The loading area of the vehicles is also a rectangular area where the items are taken out from one side. A constraint states that the items of a given customer must be directly accessible at delivery time. The last paper considers a stochastic vehicle routing and loading problem with two- dimensional rectangular items where the dimensions of some items are unknown when the routes are planned. However, it is possible to associate a discrete probability distribution on the dimensions of these items. The problem is solved with the Integer L-Shaped method.

Cette thèse s’intéresse aux problèmes de tournées de véhicules où l’on retrouve des contraintes de chargement ayant un impact sur les séquences de livraisons permises. Plus particulièrement, les items placés dans l’espace de chargement d’un véhicule doivent être directement accessibles lors de leur livraison sans qu’il soit nécessaire de déplacer d’autres items. Ces problèmes sont rencontrés dans plusieurs entreprises de transport qui livrent de gros objets (meubles, électroménagers). Le premier article de cette thèse porte sur une méthode exacte pour un problème de confection d’une seule tournée où un véhicule, dont l’aire de chargement est divisée en un certain nombre de piles, doit effectuer des cueillettes et des livraisons respectant une contrainte de type dernier entré, premier sorti. Lors d’une collecte, les items recueillis doivent nécessairement être déposés sur le dessus de l’une des piles. Par ailleurs, lors d’une livraison, les items doivent nécessairement se trouver sur le dessus de l’une des piles. Une méthode de séparation et évaluation avec plans sécants est proposée pour résoudre ce problème. Le second article présente une méthode de résolution exacte, également de type séparation et évaluation avec plans sécants, pour un problème de tournées de véhicules avec chargement d’items rectangulaires en deux dimensions. L’aire de chargement des véhicules correspond aussi à un espace rectangulaire avec une orientation, puisque les items doivent être chargés et déchargés par l’un des côtés. Une contrainte impose que les items d’un client soient directement accessibles au moment de leur livraison. Le dernier article aborde une problème de tournées de véhicules avec chargement d’items rectangulaires, mais où les dimensions de certains items ne sont pas connus avec certitude lors de la planification des tournées. Il est toutefois possible d’associer une distribution de probabilités discrète sur les dimensions possibles de ces items. Le problème est résolu de manière exacte avec la méthode L-Shape en nombres entiers. / In this thesis, we study mixed vehicle routing and loading problems where a constraint is imposed on delivery sequences. More precisely, the items in the loading area of a vehicle must be directly accessible, without moving any other item, at delivery time. These problems are often found in the transportation of large objects (furniture, appliances). The first paper proposes a branch-and-cut algorithm for a variant of the single vehicle pickup and delivery problem, where the loading area of the vehicle is divided into several stacks. When an item is picked up, it must be placed on the top of one of these stacks. Conversely, an item must be on the top of one of these stacks to be delivered. This requirement is called “Last In First Out” or LIFO constraint. The second paper presents another branch-and-cut algorithm for a vehicle routing and loading problem with two-dimensional rectangular items. The loading area of the vehicles is also a rectangular area where the items are taken out from one side. A constraint states that the items of a given customer must be directly accessible at delivery time. The last paper considers a stochastic vehicle routing and loading problem with two- dimensional rectangular items where the dimensions of some items are unknown when the routes are planned. However, it is possible to associate a discrete probability distribution on the dimensions of these items. The problem is solved with the Integer L-Shaped method.