Submitted by Caroline Xavier (caroline.xavier@pucrs.br) on 2017-06-30T17:20:02Z No. of bitstreams: 1 DIS_THIAGO_MULLER_KURBAN_COMPLETO.pdf: 836404 bytes, checksum: ad618b257be45a043c611a1ad3235c6c (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-06-30T17:20:02Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 DIS_THIAGO_MULLER_KURBAN_COMPLETO.pdf: 836404 bytes, checksum: ad618b257be45a043c611a1ad3235c6c (MD5) Previous issue date: 2017-03-31 / The present paper comparatively analyzes the reports prepared by international nongovernmental human rights organizations Amnesty International and HUMAN RIGTHS WATCH on the Israeli Operation Cast Lead. The Operation Cast Lead was a military offensive of great worldwide repercussion due to the significant number of Palestinian civilian deaths, the use of prohibited weapons and the controversy involving the Commission established by the United Nations Human Rights Council. The organizations selected for the work act in a large number of countries, have special consultative status with the UN Economic and Social Council, and have already received the Nobel Peace Prize. HRW's 2006 action in Lebanon allows to raise the hypothesis that such organizations can act influenced by external pressures and change their positions. The comparative analysis proposed here aims to verify the organizations' notes in order to test the hypothesis mentioned. / O presente trabalho analisa comparativamente os relat?rios elaborados pelas organiza??es n?o-governamentais internacionais de Direitos Humanos Amnesty International e Human Rigths Watch sobre a Opera??o Israelense Chumbo Fundido. A Opera??o Chumbo Fundido foi uma ofensiva militar de grande repercuss?o mundial pelo expressivo n?mero de mortes de civis palestinos, pelo uso de armamentos proibidos e pela pol?mica envolvendo a Comiss?o estabelecida pelo Conselho de Direitos Humanos das Na??es Unidas. As organiza??es selecionadas para o trabalho atuam em um grande n?mero de pa?ses, possuem status consultivo especial junto ao Conselho Econ?mico e Social da ONU, al?m de j? terem recebido o pr?mio Nobel da Paz. A atua??o da HRW em 2006 no L?bano permite levantar a hip?tese de que tais organiza??es podem atuar influenciadas por press?es externas e mudar seus posicionamentos.A an?lise comparada aqui proposta visa verificar os apontamentos das organiza??es de modo a testar a hip?tese mencionada.