Lysine methylation modulates diverse biological processes and is catalyzed by SET domain methyltransferases such as the SMYDs (SMYD1-5), which possess a SET domain split by a MYND motif. Through association with NCoR, the H4 Lys20 methyltransferase activity of SMYD5 represses inflammation by restricting TLR-4 mediated expression in macrophages, yet biochemical and structural features required for SMYD5 methylation activity remain elusive. To determine how SMYD5 catalyses methylation, crystallization screens were conducted with SMYD5 in complex with the co-factor AdoMet and histone H4. Screens yielded lead conditions but no crystals. To determine the motif recognized by SMYD5 and decipher its methylome, peptide arrays were conducted to produce a methylation motif used to identify putative substrates. Surprisingly, arrays revealed that substitution of Lys16, not Lys20, is detrimental to SMYD5 activity. Further enzymatic assays are required to determine if SMYD5 methylates residues other than Lys20 on the H4 tail, or if structural determinants or interacting partners restrict methylation of target lysines.