The dopamine D2 receptor exists in vitro in two states of agonist affinity: a high-affinity state mediating dopamine’s physiological effects, and a physiologically-inert low-affinity state. Our primary goal was to determine the in vivo relevance of this two-affinity-state model for the agonist PET radiotracer [11C]-(+)-PHNO, developed for measurement of the D2 high-affinity state. Our second goal was to characterize the regional D2 versus D3 pharmacology of [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding and assess its utility for measuring drug occupancy at both receptor subtypes. Using ex vivo dual-radiotracer experiments in conscious rats, we showed that, contrary to the two-affinity-state model, the binding of [11C]-(+)-PHNO and the antagonist [3H]-raclopride were indistinguishably inhibited by D2 partial agonist (aripiprazole), indirect agonist (amphetamine) and full agonist ((-)-NPA) pretreatment. Furthermore, ex vivo [11C]-(+)-PHNO binding was unaffected by treatments that increase in vitro high-affinity state density (chronic amphetamine, ethanol-withdrawal), whereas unilateral 6-OHDA lesion, which increases total D2 receptor expression, similarly increased the ex vivo binding of [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [3H]-raclopride. These results do not support the in vivo validity of the two-affinity-state model, suggesting instead a single receptor state for [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [3H]-raclopride in conscious rat. Importantly, we also demonstrated that the increased amphetamine-sensitivity of the agonist radiotracers [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [11C]-(-)-NPA, commonly seen in isoflurane-anaesthetized animals and cited as evidence for the two-affinity-state model, is due to the confounding effects of anaesthesia. Using in vitro and ex vivo autoradiography in rat and the D3 receptor-selective drug SB277011, we found that [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding in striatum and cerebellum lobes 9 and 10 was due exclusively to D2 and D3 receptor binding, respectively, but in other extra-striatal regions to a mix of the two receptor subtypes. Surprisingly, the D3 contribution to [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding was greater ex vivo than in vitro. Also surprising, several antipsychotic drugs, at doses producing 80% D2 occupancy, produced insignificant (olanzapine, risperidone, haloperidol) or small (clozapine, ~35%) D3 occupancy, despite similarly occupying both receptor subtypes in vitro. These data reveal a significant discrepancy between in vitro and ex vivo measures of dopamine receptor binding and suggest that the D3 occupancy is not necessary for the therapeutic effect of antispychotic drugs.

The dopamine D2 receptor exists in vitro in two states of agonist affinity: a high-affinity state mediating dopamine’s physiological effects, and a physiologically-inert low-affinity state. Our primary goal was to determine the in vivo relevance of this two-affinity-state model for the agonist PET radiotracer [11C]-(+)-PHNO, developed for measurement of the D2 high-affinity state. Our second goal was to characterize the regional D2 versus D3 pharmacology of [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding and assess its utility for measuring drug occupancy at both receptor subtypes. Using ex vivo dual-radiotracer experiments in conscious rats, we showed that, contrary to the two-affinity-state model, the binding of [11C]-(+)-PHNO and the antagonist [3H]-raclopride were indistinguishably inhibited by D2 partial agonist (aripiprazole), indirect agonist (amphetamine) and full agonist ((-)-NPA) pretreatment. Furthermore, ex vivo [11C]-(+)-PHNO binding was unaffected by treatments that increase in vitro high-affinity state density (chronic amphetamine, ethanol-withdrawal), whereas unilateral 6-OHDA lesion, which increases total D2 receptor expression, similarly increased the ex vivo binding of [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [3H]-raclopride. These results do not support the in vivo validity of the two-affinity-state model, suggesting instead a single receptor state for [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [3H]-raclopride in conscious rat. Importantly, we also demonstrated that the increased amphetamine-sensitivity of the agonist radiotracers [11C]-(+)-PHNO and [11C]-(-)-NPA, commonly seen in isoflurane-anaesthetized animals and cited as evidence for the two-affinity-state model, is due to the confounding effects of anaesthesia. Using in vitro and ex vivo autoradiography in rat and the D3 receptor-selective drug SB277011, we found that [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding in striatum and cerebellum lobes 9 and 10 was due exclusively to D2 and D3 receptor binding, respectively, but in other extra-striatal regions to a mix of the two receptor subtypes. Surprisingly, the D3 contribution to [3H]-(+)-PHNO binding was greater ex vivo than in vitro. Also surprising, several antipsychotic drugs, at doses producing 80% D2 occupancy, produced insignificant (olanzapine, risperidone, haloperidol) or small (clozapine, ~35%) D3 occupancy, despite similarly occupying both receptor subtypes in vitro. These data reveal a significant discrepancy between in vitro and ex vivo measures of dopamine receptor binding and suggest that the D3 occupancy is not necessary for the therapeutic effect of antispychotic drugs.