The marginalization index for each municipality in Mexico confirms that the country is characterized by substantial economic inequality. Using this index as a tool to measure inequality in urbanization and data from the Consejo Nacional de Población (CONAPO) and the Instituto Nacional de Estadística y Geografía (INEGI), this work first analyzes observed spatial patterns of the marginalization index. Next, this dissertation analyzes the association between marginalization and mortality patterns inside Mexico. Overall, there is evidence of high marginalization linked to high mortality rates. Factors that might influence marginalization like geographical differences do not seem to influence the relationship between marginalization and mortality. Factors like migration and indigenous population percentages show more relevance in explaining the association between marginalization and mortality as a social causation effect. / text

Studier visar att strokesjukvården i Sverige har en ojämn kvalitet. Denna studie syftar till att vidare undersöka möjliga ojämlikheter i strokevården. I uppsatsen undersöktes huruvida födelseland påverkar hur patienter som insjuknat i stroke skattar sin hälsa, nöjdhet med vården och nedstämdhet. Därtill jämfördes två statistiska metoder som kan hantera skillnader i patientsammansättning (t.ex. ålder och andra bakgrundsfaktorer), vilka var multipel logistisk regression och propensity score matching följt av konditionell logistisk regression. Båda metoderna gav signifikanta resultat. Resultatet visade att det är troligare att uppskatta sin allmänna hälsa som dålig, vara missnöjd med vården och vara nedstämd ofta eller ständigt för patienter födda utanför Sverige jämfört med de födda i Sverige, oberoende av vilken metod som användes. Propensity score matching visade större påverkan av födelseland på de undersökta responsvariablerna jämfört med multipel logistisk regression. Däremot var resultaten från multipel logistisk regression mer precisa.

The thesis consists of an introduction and two papers. In the introduction a brief historical survey of empirical investigations into the effectiveness of medicinal interventions is given. Also, the main ideas of the EBM (evidence-based medicine) movement are presented. Both included papers can be viewed as investigations into the reasonableness of EBM and its hierarchies of evidence. Paper I: Typically, in a clinical trial patients with specified symptoms are given either of two or more predetermined treatments. Health endpoints in these groups are then compared using statistical methods. Concerns have been raised, not least from adherents of so-called alternative medicine, that clinical trials do not offer reliable evidence for some types of treatment, in particular for highly individualized treatments, for example traditional homeopathy. It is argued that such concerns are unfounded. There are two minimal conditions related to the nature of the treatments that must be fulfilled for evaluability in a clinical trial, namely (1) the proper distinction of the two treatment groups and (2) the elimination of confounding variables or variations. These are delineated, and a few misunderstandings are corrected. It is concluded that the conditions do not preclude the testing of alternative medicine, whether individualized or not. Paper II: Traditionally, mechanistic reasoning has been assigned a negligible role in standard EBM literature, although some recent authors have argued for an upgrading. Even so, mechanistic reasoning that has received attention has almost exclusively been positive -- both in an epistemic sense of claiming that there is a mechanistic chain and in a health-related sense of there being claimed benefits for the patient. Negative mechanistic reasoning has been neglected, both in the epistemic and in the health-related sense. I distinguish three main types of negative mechanistic reasoning and subsume them under a new definition of mechanistic reasoning in the context of assessing medical interventions. Although this definition is wider than a previous suggestion in the literature, there are still other instances of reasoning that concern mechanisms but do not (and should not) count as mechanistic reasoning. One of the three distinguished types, which is negative only in the health-related sense, has a corresponding positive counterpart, whereas the other two, which are epistemically negative, do not have such counterparts, at least not that are particularly interesting as evidence. Accounting for negative mechanistic reasoning in EBM is therefore partly different from accounting for positive mechanistic reasoning. Each negative type corresponds to a range of evidential strengths, and it is argued that there are differences with respect to the typical strengths. The variety of negative mechanistic reasoning should be acknowledged in EBM, and presents a serious challenge to proponents of so-called medical hierarchies of evidence. / <p>QC 20150413</p>

La résonance magnétique cardiovasculaire sensible à l'oxygénation (OS-CMR) est devenue une modalité d'imagerie diagnostique pour la surveillance de changements dans l'oxygénation du myocarde. Cette technique offre un grand potentiel en tant qu'outil diagnostic primaire pour les maladies cardiovasculaires, en particulier la détection non-invasive d'ischémie. Par contre, il existe plusieurs facteurs potentiellement confondants de cette technique, quelques-uns d'ordre méthodologique comme les paramètres de séquençage et d'autres de nature physiologiques qui sont peut compris. En raison des effets causés par le contenu tissulaire d'eau, l'état d'hydratation peut avoir un impact sur l'intensité du signal. Ceci est un des aspects physiologiques en particulier dont nous voulions quantifier l'effet confondant par la manipulation de l'état d'hydratation chez des humains et l'observation des changements de l'intensité du signal dans des images OS-CMR. Méthodes: In vitro: Du sang artériel et veineux de huit porcs a été utilisé pour évaluer la dilution en série du sang et son effet correspondant sur l'intensité du signal de la séquence OS. In vivo: Vingt-deux volontaires en santé ont subi OS-CMR. Les concentrations d'hémoglobine (Hb) ont été mesurées au niveau de base et immédiatement après une l'infusion cristalloïde rapide de 1000 mL de solution Lactate Ringer's (LRS). Les images OS-CMR ont été prises dans une vue mid-ventriculaire court axe. L'intensité du signal myocardique a été mesurée durant une rétention respiratoire volontaire maximale, suite à une période d'hyperventilation de 60 secondes. Les changements dans l'intensité du signal entre le début et la fin de la rétention de la respiration ont été exprimés relativement au niveau de base (% de changement). Résultats: L'infusion a résulté en une diminution significative de l'Hb mesurée (142.5±3.3 vs. 128.8±3.3 g/L; p<0.001), alors que l'IS a augmenté de 3.2±1.2% entre les images du niveau de base en normo- et hypervolémie (p<0.05). L'IS d'hyperventilation ainsi que les changements d'IS induits par l'apnée ont été attenués après hémodilution (p<0.05). L'évaluation quantitative T2* a démontré une corrélation négative entre le temps de T2* et la concentration d'hémoglobine (r=-0.46, p<0.005). Conclusions: Il existe plusieurs éléments confondants de la technique OS-CMR qui requièrent de l'attention et de l'optimisation pour une future implémentation clinique à grande échelle. Le statut d'hydratation en particulier pourrait être un élément confondant dans l'imagerie OS-CMR. L'hypervolémie mène à une augmentation en IS au niveau de base et atténue la réponse IS durant des manoeuvres de respiration vasoactives. Cette atténuation de l'intensité du signal devrait être tenue en compte et corrigée dans l'évaluation clinique d'images OS-CMR. / Background: Oxygenation-sensitive cardiovascular magnetic resonance (OS-CMR) has become a feasible diagnostic imaging modality for monitoring changes of myocardial oxygenation. This technique has great potential for use as a primary diagnostic tool for cardiovascular disease, particularly non-invasive detection of ischemia. Yet, there are several potential confounding factors of this technique, some methodological, such as sequence parameters and others are physiological and not well understood. Due to T2 effects caused by tissue water content, the hydration status may impact signal intensity. This is one physiological aspect in particular that we aimed at quantifying the confounding effect by manipulating hydration status in humans and observing signal intensity (SI) changes in OS-CMR images. Methods: In vitro: Arterial and venous blood from eight swine were used to assess serial dilution of blood and it corresponding effect on OS sequence signal intensity. In vivo: Twenty-two healthy volunteers underwent OS-CMR. Hemoglobin (Hb) concentrations were measured at baseline and immediately following rapid crystalloid infusion of 1,000ml of Lactated Ringer’s solution (LRS). OS-CMR images were acquired in a mid-ventricular short axis view. Myocardial SI was measured during a maximal voluntary breath-hold, after a 60-second period of hyperventilation. SI changes were expressed relative to baseline (% change). Results: The infusion resulted in a significant decrease in measured Hb (142.5±3.3 vs. 128.8±3.3 g/L; p<0.001), while SI increased by 3.2±1.2% between baseline images at normo- and hypervolemia (p<0.05). Both hyperventilation SI and the SI changes induced by apnea were attenuated after hemodilution (p<0.05). Quantitative assessment showed a negative correlation between T2* and hemoglobin concentration (r=-0.46, p<0.005). Conclusions: There are several confounders to the OS-CMR technique that require attention and optimization for future larger scale clinical implementation. The hydration status in particular may be a confounder in OS-CMR imaging. Hypervolemia leads to an increase in SI at baseline and attenuates the SI response during vasoactive breathing maneuvers. This attenuation in signal intensity would need to be accounted for and corrected in clinical assessment of OS-CMR images.