This two-article dissertation summarizes the end-of-course survey and formative feedback literatures, as well as proposes actionability as a useful construct in the analysis of feedback from students captured in real-time during their courses. The present inquiry grew out of my work as the founder of DropThought Education, a Division of DropThought. DropThought Education was a student feedback system that helped instructional designers, instructors, and educational systems to use feedback from students to improve learning and student experience. To find out whether the DropThought style of feedback was more effective than other forms of capturing and analyzing student feedback, I needed to (1) examine the formative feedback literature and (2) test DropThought style feedback against traditional feedback forms. The method and theory proposed demonstrates that feedback from students can be specific and actionable when captured in the moment at students' activity level, in their own words. Application of the real-time feedback approach are relevant to practitioners and researchers alike, whether an instructor looking to improve her class activities, or a learning scientist carrying out interventionist, design-based research.

Beef cattle are continuously selected for different traits and the success in improving these traits has been remarkable. However, for certain traits, it is essential not only to improve the average performance, but also to control the variation around the mean. There is evidence that residual variance may be under genetic control, which opens the possibility of selecting for uniformity. In this sense, the objectives of the present dissertation were: 1) to investigate the extent of genetic heterogeneity of residual variance at the pedigree level in birth weight (BW), weaning weight (WW), yearling weight (YW), foot angle (FA), and claw set (CS) in American Angus cattle; 2) to compare the results of different genetic heterogeneity models; 3) to evaluate the effectiveness of Box-Cox transformation in continuous traits; and 4) to address limitations and explore alternative solutions for implementing genetic parameters for residual variance in genetic evaluations. The first study investigated the genetic heterogeneity of residual variances for BW, WW, and YW. Three models were compared: a homoscedastic residual variance model (M1), a double hierarchical generalized linear model (DHGLM, M2), and a genetically structured environmental variance model (MCMC, M3). The results showed significant genetic heterogeneity of residual variances in growth traits, suggesting the possibility of selection for uniformity. The genetic coefficient of variation for residual variance ranged from 0.90 to 0.92 in M2 and 0.31 to 0.38 in M3 for BW, 0.64 in M2 and 0.01 to 0.29 in M3 for WW, and 0.67 to 0.63 in M2 and 0.25 to 0.31 in M3 for YW. Low heritability estimates for residual variance were found, particularly in M2 (0.08 for BW, 0.06 for WW, and 0.09 for YW). The study identified both negative and positive genetic correlations between mean and residual variance, depending on the trait and data transformation. Negative correlations suggest the potential to increase trait means while decreasing residual variance. However, positive correlations indicate that the genetic response to selection for uniformity may be limited unless a selection index is used. Data transformation reduced skewness but did not eliminate genetic heterogeneity of residual variances. The Bayesian approach provided higher estimates of additive genetic variance for residual variance compared to DHGLM. Overall, the findings indicate the potential to reduce variability through selection and lay the groundwork for incorporating uniformity of growth traits into breeding goals. The second study focused on the genetic heterogeneity of residual variance for two foot conformation traits, FA and CS. Using 45,667 phenotypic records collected between 2009 and 2021, three models were compared: a traditional homoscedastic residual variance model (M1), a DHGLM (M2), and a genetically structured environmental variance model (M3). Results showed that heritability estimates for FA and CS means were within expected ranges, although lower in M2. Despite low heritability estimates for residual variance (0.07 for FA and 0.05 for CS in M2), significant genetic coefficients of variation were found, suggesting that selection on trait mean would also influence residual variance. Positive genetic correlations between mean and residual variance in M2 and M3 indicate that selection for uniformity is feasible, but may require additional strategies such as selection indices. The study highlights the potential of FA and CS as indicators for breeding programs aimed at improving production uniformity in beef cattle. Our findings suggest that selection for uniformity in growth and foot score traits in beef cattle may be limited by low heritability of residual variance and moderate to high positive genetic correlations between mean and residual variance. This was observed for most of the traits studied. To overcome these challenges, further research is needed, particularly to explore genomic information to improve the prediction accuracy of estimated breeding values (EBV) for residual variance. Although studies of uniformity using genomic data are limited, they have shown improved EBV accuracy for residual variance. Additionally, alternative methods for measuring uniformity, such as different uniformity or resilience indicators, should be considered, especially with advances in digital phenotyping. Precision livestock farming technologies that allow for extensive data collection on various production traits should be integrated into the development of new uniformity indicators. This dissertation provides valuable insights into the genetic heterogeneity of residual variance in American Angus cattle and highlights the complexity of selecting for uniformity while improving mean traits. Continued research with larger data sets, genomic information, and further methodological refinement will be critical to advance these findings to improve uniformity and productivity in beef cattle breeding. / Doctor of Philosophy / Uniformity in livestock breeding refers to the goal of reducing variability in certain traits within a livestock population to achieve more consistent and predictable outcomes. This is particularly important for traits that affect productivity, economic efficiency, animal welfare, and product quality. By achieving greater uniformity, producers can optimize management practices, improve marketability, and enhance the overall efficiency of animal production systems. Residual variance refers to the variation in traits that is not explained by known genetic or environmental factors. Recent research suggests that residual variance may be under genetic control, meaning that it is possible to select animals that not only have desirable traits, but also have less variability in those traits. Therefore, this dissertation investigates the genetic control of residual variance that may allow selection for uniformity in traits. The research focused on American Angus cattle and aimed to 1) investigate genetic heterogeneity of residual variance in traits, such as birth weight, weaning weight, yearling weight, foot angle, and claw set; 2) compare different genetic models; 3) evaluate the effectiveness of data transformations; and 4) address limitations in genetic evaluations. The first study examined genetic heterogeneity in growth traits using three models. It revealed significant genetic variability, suggesting the potential for selection for uniformity. The study found both positive and negative genetic correlations between trait means and residual variance, indicating varying potential for reducing variance while improving trait means. Data transformations reduced skewness but did not eliminate genetic heterogeneity. A Bayesian approach provided higher estimates of genetic variance than other methods. The second study focused on foot conformation traits with over 45,000 records. The study showed that despite low heritability for residual variance, there was significant genetic variation, indicating the possibility of altering residual variance through selection. Positive genetic correlations suggested that additional strategies, such as selection indices, may be needed to achieve uniformity in practice. Overall, the findings highlight the complexity of selecting for uniformity while improving average traits and underscore the need for further research, particularly using genomic data, to improve prediction accuracy. Integrating precision livestock farming technologies could help develop new indicators of uniformity, improving productivity and uniformity in beef cattle breeding.

This thesis develops and evaluates statistical methods for different types of genetic analyses, including quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis, genome-wide association study (GWAS), and genomic evaluation. The main contribution of the thesis is to provide novel insights in modeling genetic variance, especially via random effects models. In variance component QTL analysis, a full likelihood model accounting for uncertainty in the identity-by-descent (IBD) matrix was developed. It was found to be able to correctly adjust the bias in genetic variance component estimation and gain power in QTL mapping in terms of precision.  Double hierarchical generalized linear models, and a non-iterative simplified version, were implemented and applied to fit data of an entire genome. These whole genome models were shown to have good performance in both QTL mapping and genomic prediction. A re-analysis of a publicly available GWAS data set identified significant loci in Arabidopsis that control phenotypic variance instead of mean, which validated the idea of variance-controlling genes.  The works in the thesis are accompanied by R packages available online, including a general statistical tool for fitting random effects models (hglm), an efficient generalized ridge regression for high-dimensional data (bigRR), a double-layer mixed model for genomic data analysis (iQTL), a stochastic IBD matrix calculator (MCIBD), a computational interface for QTL mapping (qtl.outbred), and a GWAS analysis tool for mapping variance-controlling loci (vGWAS).

This thesis develops and evaluates statistical methods for different types of genetic analyses, including quantitative trait loci (QTL) analysis, genome-wide association study (GWAS), and genomic evaluation. The main contribution of the thesis is to provide novel insights in modeling genetic variance, especially via random effects models. In variance component QTL analysis, a full likelihood model accounting for uncertainty in the identity-by-descent (IBD) matrix was developed. It was found to be able to correctly adjust the bias in genetic variance component estimation and gain power in QTL mapping in terms of precision.  Double hierarchical generalized linear models, and a non-iterative simplified version, were implemented and applied to fit data of an entire genome. These whole genome models were shown to have good performance in both QTL mapping and genomic prediction. A re-analysis of a publicly available GWAS data set identified significant loci in Arabidopsis that control phenotypic variance instead of mean, which validated the idea of variance-controlling genes.  The works in the thesis are accompanied by R packages available online, including a general statistical tool for fitting random effects models (hglm), an efficient generalized ridge regression for high-dimensional data (bigRR), a double-layer mixed model for genomic data analysis (iQTL), a stochastic IBD matrix calculator (MCIBD), a computational interface for QTL mapping (qtl.outbred), and a GWAS analysis tool for mapping variance-controlling loci (vGWAS).

Submitted by ANGEL DE JESUS LAZARO VELASCO null (angelstrauss26@hotmail.com) on 2017-10-25T17:49:03Z No. of bitstreams: 1 DissertacaoAngel.pdf: 1392488 bytes, checksum: 30d16b1c40935e0572a92a6d9c6dc400 (MD5) / Approved for entry into archive by Monique Sasaki (sayumi_sasaki@hotmail.com) on 2017-10-31T17:00:42Z (GMT) No. of bitstreams: 1 velasco_ajl_me_jabo.pdf: 1392488 bytes, checksum: 30d16b1c40935e0572a92a6d9c6dc400 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-10-31T17:00:42Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 velasco_ajl_me_jabo.pdf: 1392488 bytes, checksum: 30d16b1c40935e0572a92a6d9c6dc400 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2017-09-26 / Consejo Nacional de Ciencia y Tecnología (CONACYT) / Há evidências na literatura que a uniformidade das características fenotípicas dos peixes, entre outros animais, pode ser afetada por componentes genéticos, além de fatores ambientais. Maior uniformidade na despesca é desejada, a fim de reduzir a competição entre os animais e, assim, ter uma produção mais homogênea, visando maior retorno financeiro da atividade. O objetivo deste estudo foi estimar se as variâncias residuais do peso e comprimento à despesca de tilápias do Nilo (Oreochromis niloticus) são afetadas por componentes genéticos, para avaliar a possibilidade de seleção para uniformidade de produção. Empregou-se o modelo hierárquico linear generalizado duplo (DHGLM) para calcular os componentes de variância, os parâmetros de herdabilidade, coeficientes de variação e correlações genéticas para peso (não transformado e com transformação Box-Cox) e comprimento à despesca. Foi utilizado um total de 8.725 informações fenotípicas de tilápias provenientes de 271 famílias da linhagem GIFT (Malásia), criados na estação experimental de piscicultura da Universidade Estadual de Maringá. Os resultados apoiaram a hipótese de heterogeneidade genética da variância residual para peso e comprimento à despesca, e a oportunidade de seleção medida através do coeficiente genético de variação da variância residual. Além disso, observou-se a necessidade de um grande número de filhos para a obtenção de estimativas precisas do mérito genético para variação residual, conforme indicado pelas estimativas de baixa herdabilidade. A transformação de Box-Cox foi capaz de diminuir a dependência entre a variância e a média do peso à despesca. A transformação reduziu, mas não eliminou toda a heterogeneidade genética da variância residual, destacando sua presença além do efeito da escala. / There is evidence in the literature that the uniformity of phenotypic traits of fish, among other animals, can be affected by genetic components, as well as environmental factors. Greater uniformity is desired in order to reduce competition among animals and thus have a more uniform production, aiming a greater financial return of the activity. The objective of this study was to assess if the residual variance of the weight and harvest length of the Nile tilapia (Oreochromis niloticus) is affected by a genetic component, to evaluate the possibility of selection for uniformity of production. The double hierarchical generalized linear model was used to estimate the components of variance, heritability, coefficients of variation and genetic correlation for weight (untransformed and with Box-Cox transformation) and harvest length. Phenotypic records of 8,725 individuals from 271 families were analyzed. The results supported the existence of genetic heterogeneity of residual variance on harvest weight and length, and the opportunity to select for increasing uniformity. Moreover, the low heritability estimates showed the necessity of high number of progeny for an accurate estimate of the genetic merit for the residual variance. The Box-Cox transformation of harvest weight reduced the dependency among its mean and variance. The transformation reduced but did not eliminate the genetic heterogeneity of residual variance, highlighting its presence beyond the scale effect. / CONACYT: 579742/410471

<p>Postpartum depression has become a major public health concern for women within a specific time period after delivery. Depression is possibly associated with some risk factors such as socioeconomic status, social support, maternal mental and physical health, and history of anxiety. TOMIS III, funded by the Canadian Institutes of Health Research, is a prospective cohort to study the associations between delivery method and health and health resource utilization.</p> <p>Clinically, we investigated the associations between mode of delivery and outcome of postnatal depression, maternal and infant health, and we implied the risk predictors for outcomes by statistical methodology of marginal model with generalized estimating equations (GEE). Statistically, a variety of regression models, namely, generalized linear mixed effect model (GLMM), hierarchical generalized linear model (HGLM) and Bayesian hierarchical model were applied for this analysis and results were compared with GEEs. Some imputation strategies, namely, mean imputation, last observation carrying forward (LOCF), hot-deck imputation and multiple imputation were employed for handling missing values in this study.</p> <p>Analysis results demonstrated that there was no statistically significant association between mode of delivery and postpartum depression [OR 0.99, 95% CI (0.73, 1.34)]. However, the development of postpartum depression was found to be associated with low income, low mental and physical health functioning, lack of social support, the low number of unmet learning needs in hospital, and English or French spoken at home. Results were consistent for all regression models but GEE provided the best fit and an excellent discriminative ability. GEE models were constructed on different datasets imputed by mean, LOCF, hot-deck and multiple imputation, and LOCF was recommended to handle the missing data in this longitudinal study.</p> <p>Analyses on the outcome of maternal health and infant health stated that method of delivery had a statistically significant influence on maternal health but no significant impact on infant health. Risks of maternal health problems were associated with cesarean delivery, good/fair/poor infant health, low maternal mental and physical health functioning, lack of care for maternal mental health, and good/fair/poor health before pregnancy. Risks of infant health problems were associated with good/fair/poor maternal health before pregnancy and after discharge, inadequate care or help for infant health, fair/poor community services after discharge, low maternal mental health functioning, non-English or non-French spoken at home, and mothers born outside of Canada.</p> / Master of Science (MSc)