Repair of peripheral nerve injury often results in poor functional motor recovery. This deficit has previously been attributed to the failure of axons to regenerate into the muscle. However, we have recently reported that following nerve injury in mice, axons have regenerated to the motor end plate in animals with poor recovery. We proposed that following axonal injury, there is a critical period during which the axon must reach the muscle in order to form a functional neuromuscular junction. We have developed a mouse model of prolonged denervation, in which the sciatic nerve is crushed repeatedly every few days, preventing regenerating axons from reaching the muscle. This multiple crush model allows us to vary the period of denervation by modifying the number of crushes. Motor recovery as assessed using the toe-spreading score occurs after 3 or 4 multiple crushes every 7 days (24 or 31 days of denervation) but not after 5 crushes (38 days). Immunostaining for alpha-bungarotoxin and neurofilament confirmed end plate reinnervation. Thus following denervation > 38 days, a motor deficit persists despite end plate reinnervation. Although the mechanism for the deficit requires investigation, these results suggest that functional neuromuscular junction reestablishment more than end plate reinnervation and that there is a time limit for functional synapse reformation.