The objectives of this research were to compare different types of cocoa and chocolates in the formulation of processed chocolate cheese and aged Cheddar cheese, and to evaluate sensory, physical, chemical and quality parameters of each. Four different varieties of chocolates were utilized along with other ingredients to prepare processed chocolate cheeses and were tested for consumer acceptability for their basic and critical attributes. Chocolate chips of four different types and proportions were incorporated into Cheddar cheese curd, ripened for 105 days, and a trained panel evaluated the sensory parameters. Results indicated that processed chocolate cheese made with Bordeaux chocolate was preferred the most by consumers, followed by those prepared with Ghirardelli, German and Dutch chocolates, respectively. This research provides a platform to pioneer the study of the sensory profiles of the processed chocolate cheeses. Development of a lexiconal study for the Cheddar cheeses with chocolate chips is also necessitated.