This research has investigated the effect of tyre rutting of wheeled construction plant performance traversing in wet and deformable terrain, specifically clay and sand. The purpose was to translate the wheel rutting into performance reduction measured in drawbar-pull. The ultimate goal was to translate the power loss into practical effects on cost, time and other economic variations on construction projects that are characterised by movement of wheeled plant on long haulage deformable roads. In order to achieve this aim, mathematical modelling was deployed based on Newton’s laws of motion, principles of energy conservation and numerical integration. The model is based on a single rigid wheel because construction plant tyres are inflated to high pressure in order to support heavy loads thereby translating the flexible tyres into rigid mode. The results from the mathematical model were verified using a three stage robust verification process which included computational analysis based on two existing semi-empirical methods and real experimental data. Laboratory experiments using Mobility SF- 3713 were also used to check the validity of the results. The results from the mathematical model verify that a flexible tyre can operate in rigid mode if it encounters softer and wet ground. Results further indicate that the soil cohesion, angle of shearing resistance and moisture content play key roles in the subsequent power loss created by motion resistance. All the results from computational analysis and the experiments were found to be consistent with the mathematical model results. The study concludes that there is ample evidence to suggest that there is significant power loss associated with wheeled construction plant traversing in soft terrain which can be assessed. The study further concludes that a combination of economic decisions on variables must be considered with respect to existing ground conditions. This will considerably reduce uncertainty levels in cost and resource management on construction projects.

Indiana University-Purdue University Indianapolis (IUPUI) / A procedure for calibrating a discrete element (DE) computational soil model for various moisture contents using a conventional Asperity-Spring friction modeling technique is presented in this thesis. The procedure is based on the outcomes of two physical soil experiments: (1) Compression and (2) unconfined shear strength at various levels of normal stress and normal pre-stress. The Compression test is used to calibrate the DE soil plastic strain and elastic strain as a function of Compressive stress. To calibrate the DE inter-particle friction coefficient and adhesion stress as a function of soil plastic strain, the unconfined shear test is used. This thesis describes the experimental test devices and test procedures used to perform the physical terramechanical experiments. The calibration procedure for the DE soil model is demonstrated in this thesis using two types of soil: sand-silt (2NS Sand) and silt-clay(Fine Grain Soil) over 5 different moisture contents: 0%, 4%, 8%, 12%, and 16%. The DE based models response are then validated by comparing them to experimental pressure-sinkage results for circular disks and cones for those two types of soil over 5 different moisture contents. The Mean Absolute Percentage Error (MAPE) during the compression calibration was 26.9% whereas during the unconfined shear calibration, the MAPE was calculated to be 11.38%. Hence, the overall MAPE was calculated to be 19.34% for the entire calibration phase.

Tire performance over soft soil influences the performance of off-road vehicles on soft soil, as the tire is the only force transmitting element between the off-road vehicles and soil during the vehicle operation. One aspect of the tire performance over soft soil is the tire tractive performance on soft soil, and it attracts the attention of vehicle and geotechnical engineers. The vehicle engineer is interested in the tire tractive performance on soft soil because it is related to vehicle mobility and energy efficiency; the geotechnical engineer is concerned about the soil compaction, brought about by the tire traffic, which accompanies the tire tractive performance on soft soil. In order to improve the vehicle mobility and energy efficiency over soft soil and mitigate the soil compaction, it's essential to develop an in-depth understanding of tire tractive performance on soft soil. This study has enhanced the understanding of tire tractive performance on soft soil and promoted the development of terramechanics and tire model parameterization method through experimental tests. The experimental tests consisted of static tire deflection tests, static tire-soil tests, soil properties tests, and dynamic tire-soil tests. The series of tests (test program) presented herein produced parameterization and validation data that can be used in tire off-road traction dynamics modeling and terramechanics modeling. The 225/60R16 97S Uniroyal (Michelin) Standard Reference Test Tire (SRTT) and loamy sand were chosen to be studied in the test program. The tests included the quantification or/and measurement of soil properties of the test soil, pre-traffic soil condition, the pressure distribution in the tire contact patch, tire off-road tractive performance, and post-traffic soil compaction. The influence of operational parameters, e.g., tire inflation pressure, tire normal load, tire slip ratio, initial soil compaction, or the number of passes, on the measurement data of tire performance parameters or soil response parameters was also analyzed. New methods of the rolling radius estimation for a tire on soft soil and of the 3-D rut reconstruction were developed. A multi-pass effect phenomenon, different from any previously observed phenomenon in the available existing literature, was discovered. The test data was fed into optimization programs for the parameterization of the Bekker's model, a modified Bekker's model, the Magic Formula tire model, and a bulk density estimation model. The modified Bekker's model accounts for the slip sinkage effect which the original Bekker's pressure-sinkage model doesn't. The Magic Formula tire model was adapted to account for the combined influence of tire inflation pressure and initial soil compaction on the tire tractive performance and validated by the test data. The parameterization methods presented herein are new effective terramechanics model parameterization methods, can capture tire-soil interaction which the conventional parameterization methods such as the plate-sinkage test and shear test (not using a tire as the shear tool) cannot sufficiently, and hence can be used to develop tire off-road dynamics models that are heavily based on terramechanics models. This study has been partially supported by the U.S. Army Engineer Research and Development Center (ERDC) and by the Terramechanics, Multibody, and Vehicle (TMVS) Laboratory at Virginia Tech. / Doctor of Philosophy / Big differences exist between a tire moving in on-road conditions, such as asphalt lanes, and a tire moving in off-road conditions, such as soft soil. For example, for passenger cars commonly driven on asphalt lanes, normally, the tire inflation pressure is suggested to be between 30 and 35 psi; very low inflation pressure is also not suggested. By contrast, for off-road vehicles operated on soft soil, low inflation pressure is recommended for their tires; the inflation pressure of a tractor tire can be as low as 12 psi, for the sake of low post-traffic soil compaction and better tire traction. Besides, unlike the research on tire on-road dynamics, the research on off-road dynamics is still immature, while the physics behind the off-road dynamics could be more complex than the on-road dynamics. In this dissertation, experimental tests were completed to study the factors influencing tire tractive performance and soil behavior, and model parameterization methods were developed for a better prediction of tire off-road dynamics models. Tire or vehicle manufacturers can use the research results or methods presented in this dissertation to offer suggestions for the tire or vehicle operation on soft soil in order to maximize the tractive performance and minimize the post-traffic soil compaction.

<p>A procedure for calibrating a discrete element (DE) computational soil model for various moisture contents using a conventional Asperity-Spring friction modeling technique is presented in this thesis. The procedure is based on the outcomes of two physical soil experiments:</p> <p>(1) Compression and (2) unconfined shear strength at various levels of normal stress and normal pre-stress. The Compression test is used to calibrate the DE soil plastic strain and elastic strain as a function of Compressive stress. To calibrate the DE inter-particle friction coefficient and adhesion stress as a function of soil plastic strain, the unconfined shear test is used. This thesis describes the experimental test devices and test procedures used to perform the physical terramechanical experiments. The calibration procedure for the DE soil model is demonstrated in this thesis using two types of soil: sand-silt (2NS Sand) and silt-clay(Fine Grain Soil) over 5 different moisture contents: 0%, 4%, 8%, 12%, and 16%. The DE based models response are then validated by comparing them to experimental pressure-sinkage results for circular disks and cones for those two types of soil over 5 different moisture contents. The Mean Absolute  Percentage Error (MAPE) during the compression calibration was 26.9% whereas during the unconfined shear calibration, the MAPE was calculated to be 11.38%. Hence, the overall MAPE was calculated to be 19.34% for the entire calibration phase.</p>