Return to search

Desafios da avalia??o em um projeto s?cio-educativo: assist?ncia social, ONG e escola p?blica / Challenges of assessment in a socio-educational project: social assistance, NGOs and public schools

Made available in DSpace on 2016-04-04T18:33:02Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1
Juliana Daros Carneiro.pdf: 952616 bytes, checksum: eaf6399e6fbadcf49a1027d178dccfbd (MD5)
Previous issue date: 2011-02-18 / This is a study of a partnership between the Municipal Secretariat of Citizenship, Welfare and Social Inclusion (SMCAIS), a nongovernmental organization (NGO) and a public school in a town in the state of S?o Paulo (SP) . This partnership is developed through socio-educational activities for children and male adolescents, aged between 6 and 14 years, against the school schedule. The overall objective is to identify as non-formal education has been conceived and proposed within this partnership. Specifically, it aims to examine what they are and who should receive these socio-educational; discuss the presence of instruments and valuation models, both of public policy interest in the field of non-formal education and, finally, to identify the ( s) form (s) of existence of dialogue between the various bodies that compose this public assistance policy. The research methodology consists of: (i) review of key concepts such as non-formal education, evaluation, non-governmental organization, public and social policies, (ii) research on documentary material relating to the partnership, especially SMCAIS and NGOs (Resolution No. 01/2009 municipal, annual management reports, news articles, bylaws, work plans for 2009 and 2010 annual technical report of 2009 activities, organization chart) and (iii) semi-structured interviews with one representative from each of the institutions that make up this partnership (the educational coordinator of the NGO, a psychologist at the City Office and vice director of the school). We used a qualitative approach and the empirical material has been reviewed and organized according to categories constructed along the analytical process. As final results, we found that the non-formal education in our case, seems to be designed in ways contradictory, since while he assumed the defense speech of social transformation, in practice this character is not evident. These contradictions were analyzed in so-called socio-educational activities, forms of dialogue established between the institutions and instruments of evaluation. With regard to assessment procedures used were able to identify weaknesses and limitations, when it is adopted as reference the concept of formative evaluation: the tools are focused on the bureaucratic, technical, financial and quantitative development of the project, and are is centralized by a single institution, the SMCAIS. We believe that this research will bring significant contributions to advancing the discussions on educational concepts present in the forms of partnership between state public sector and private sector, from a broad view of education. / Trata-se de um estudo sobre uma parceria entre a Secretaria Municipal de Cidadania, Assist?ncia e Inclus?o Social (SMCAIS), uma organiza??o n?o-governamental (ONG) e uma escola p?blica estadual de uma cidade do interior do estado de S?o Paulo (SP). Esta parceria ? desenvolvida por meio de a??es s?cio-educativas destinadas a crian?as e adolescentes do sexo masculino, com idade entre 6 e 14 anos, no contra turno escolar. O objetivo geral da pesquisa ? identificar como a educa??o n?o-formal vem sendo concebida e proposta dentro desta parceria. Especificamente, pretendemos verificar o que s?o e a quem se destinam estas a??es s?cio-educativas; problematizar a presen?a de instrumentos e modelos de avalia??o, tanto da pol?tica p?blica como das a??es no campo da educa??o n?o-formal; e, por fim, identificar a(s) forma(s) de exist?ncia de di?logo entre as diferentes inst?ncias que comp?em essa pol?tica p?blica assistencial. A metodologia de pesquisa ? composta por: (i) a revis?o bibliogr?fica dos conceitos chaves, tais como educa??o n?o-formal, avalia??o, organiza??o n?o-governamental, pol?ticas p?blicas e sociais; (ii) pesquisa documental sobre materiais referentes ? parceria, especialmente da SMCAIS e da ONG (resolu??o municipal n?01/2009, relat?rios anuais de gest?o, reportagens, estatuto social, Planos de trabalho de 2009 e 2010, relat?rio t?cnico anual de atividades de 2009, organograma da entidade) e (iii) entrevistas semiestruturadas com um representante de cada uma das institui??es que comp?em esta parceria (a coordenadora pedag?gica da ONG, a psic?loga da secretaria municipal e o vice-diretor da escola). Utilizamos uma abordagem qualitativa e o material emp?rico foi examinado e organizado de acordo com categorias constru?das ao longo do processo anal?tico. Como resultados finais, identificamos que a educa??o n?o-formal no caso em estudo, parece ser concebida de formas contradit?rias, uma vez que ao mesmo tempo em que assume o discurso de defesa da transforma??o social, na pr?tica este car?ter n?o ? evidenciado. Estas contradi??es foram analisadas nas chamadas a??es s?cioeducativas, nas formas de di?logo estabelecidas entre as institui??es e nos instrumentos de avalia??o. No que se refere aos procedimentos de avalia??o utilizados foi poss?vel identificar fragilidades e limita??es, quando adota-se como refer?ncia o conceito de avalia??o formativa: os instrumentos est?o focalizados em aspectos burocr?ticos, t?cnicos, financeiros e quantitativos do desenvolvimento do projeto; e, encontram-se centralizados por uma ?nica institui??o, a SMCAIS. Consideramos que a presente pesquisa trar? contribui??es importantes para fazer avan?ar as reflex?es sobre concep??es educacionais presentes nas formas de parceria entre setor p?blico estatal e setor privado, a partir de uma vis?o ampla de educa??o.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:IBICT/oai:tede.bibliotecadigital.puc-campinas.edu.br:tede/679
Date18 February 2011
CreatorsCarneiro, Juliana Daros
ContributorsRocha, Maria Silvia Pinto de Moura Librandi da, Lopes, Doraci Alves, Fernandes, Renata Siero
PublisherPontif?cia Universidade Cat?lica de Campinas, Programa de P?s-Gradua??o em Educa??o, PUC-Campinas, BR, CCHSA ? Centro de Ci?ncias Humanas e Sociais Aplicadas
Source SetsIBICT Brazilian ETDs
LanguagePortuguese
Detected LanguageEnglish
Typeinfo:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion, info:eu-repo/semantics/masterThesis
Formatapplication/pdf
Sourcereponame:Biblioteca Digital de Teses e Dissertações da PUC_CAMPINAS, instname:Pontifícia Universidade Católica de Campinas, instacron:PUC_CAMP
Rightsinfo:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess

Page generated in 0.003 seconds