Return to search

Estimating site susceptibility to Scotch broom dominance in young Douglas-fir plantations for control prioritization in western Washington, USA

Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco var. menziesii), a keystone species in western Washington, faces threats on plantations across this region from the invasive species Scotch broom (Cytisus scoparius (L.) Link), whose invasions on recently established stands can lead to mortality of Douglas-fir through overtopping. The susceptibility of sites to Scotch broom achieving dominance over Douglas-fir has been demonstrated as highly site dependent, however the site conditions that cause this have not yet been identified. Scotch broom has a demonstrated average maximum height of 3m, thus, after Douglas-fir exceeds this height, its risk of being overtopped is significantly reduced. This thesis strives to identify sites that were at the greatest risk Douglas-fir being overtopped by Scotch broom by first, identifying what factors improved growth of Douglas-fir during the period when they are at the greatest risk, and second, identifying factors that led to Douglas-fir outcompeting Scotch broom on sites they cohabitated.
In Chapter 1, we utilized LiDAR scans, Soil Survey Geographic Database characteristics, and management histories to identify conditions that improved growth for Douglas-fir in ages 3-8. Individual tree detection was used to measure Douglas-fir heights, and a correction algorithm for LiDAR measured young Douglas-fir heights was established from field validation data. We identified that young Douglas-fir had improved growth on sites with lower elevation, flatter slopes, and finer textured soils. The factors identified were then transformed into four potential site index models based on mean stand elevation class, Mean stand elevation class and clay class, textural class and slope class, and textural class and Mean stand elevation class.
In Chapter 2, we used paired field plots to examine Douglas-fir and Scotch broom competition on 19 sites across western Washington. Each site had 2 plots with only Douglas-fir and 2 plots with Douglas-fir and Scotch broom. Elevation, soil texture, and soil nutrient composition for carbon, nitrogen and available phosphorous were examined for influence on height and growth rate of both species. We identified that Scotch broom presence was negatively related to Douglas-fir height growth and that sites with either higher percentages of silt, lower concentrations of phosphorous, or higher percentages of Carbon were more likely to have growth patterns close to or exceeding Scotch broom. / Master of Science / Douglas-fir (Pseudotsuga menziesii (Mirb.) Franco var. menziesii) is a valuable timber species across western Washington that is commonly grown in plantations. In western Washington when Douglas-fir are planted on a site they often face competition from the invasive shrub Scotch broom (Cytisus scoparius (L.) Link). When Scotch broom invasions occur on a recently planted Douglas-fir stands, they can cause death of the trees if Scotch broom plants grow taller than the young Douglas-fir and obstruct their access to light, a process called overtopping. The risk of Douglas-fir being overtopped has been shown to be dependent on location, however what causes a location to be at risk of overtopping is yet unknown. Scotch broom has a demonstrated average maximum height of 3m, thus, after Douglas-fir exceeds this height, its risk of being overtopped is significantly reduced. This study aims to identify sites that were at the greatest risk Douglas-fir being overtopped by Scotch broom by first, identifying what sites generate the best Douglas-fir growth when they are young and at risk of being overtopped, and second, identifying site characteristics led to Scotch broom growing faster than Douglas-fir on sites they both occur on.
To identify sites that produced greater young Douglas-fir height growth we used publicly available soil data from the Soil Survey Geographic Database and company management histories to predict tree heights measured through aerial laser scanning (LiDAR). We found that sites with soil textures that had higher percentages of smaller particles, were on lower elevations, and had gentler hillslopes could all produce greater Douglas-fir height growth.
When attempting to identify what causes Douglas-fir to be at risk of being overtopped by Scotch broom we used plots with and without Scotch broom on a variety of field sites. This allowed us to not only identify which characteristics of sites where Douglas-fir was being outgrown by Scotch broom, but also identify if Scotch broom was changing how Douglas-fir grew. We found that reductions in Douglas-fir growth were related to Scotch broom being present and that increases in soil silt percentages, decreases in soil phosphorus concentrations, and increases in soil carbon percentages were related to Douglas-fir having height growth closer to or exceeding that of scotch broom.

Identiferoai:union.ndltd.org:VTETD/oai:vtechworks.lib.vt.edu:10919/116454
Date11 October 2023
CreatorsBoyle, Grady John
ContributorsForest Resources and Environmental Conservation, Carter, David Robert James, Strahm, Brian, Slesak, Robert A., Thomas, Valerie Anne
PublisherVirginia Tech
Source SetsVirginia Tech Theses and Dissertation
LanguageEnglish
Detected LanguageEnglish
TypeThesis
FormatETD, application/pdf
RightsIn Copyright, http://rightsstatements.org/vocab/InC/1.0/

Page generated in 0.0028 seconds