This thesis reports on a study which investigated the impact of the decisionmaking process under the remit of the Education Act 1996 s. 19, on local education authority (LEA) arrangements for educating children out of school by reason of illness in order to contribute to policy development in the area of parental involvement. A multiple site case study of the administration of exceptional provision in English LEAs was conducted. Fifteen contrasting LEAs were contacted. Seven LEAs volunteered (two shire counties; one metropolitan district; one unitary and three London). Twenty one LEA professionals who were responsible for hospital and home tuition services, and 35 parents of 35 children (24 children residing in case study LEAs; 11 children residing in non case study LEAs) volunteered to participate in the study. In-depth qualitative data were collected between March 1998 and March 1999 by means of semi-structured interviews and document collation. Overall, the dataf rom parentss uggestedth at diversity existedi n the type and quality of provision, but less diversity existed in the quantity of provision that pupils received.C onsistencye xistedi n the pragmaticn ature of factors related to the outcomes described by parents, and the data from LEA documentsa ndp rofessionals'p erceptionsE. nabling legislation and inconsistentl evels of accountabilitya llowed LEA professionalss ubstantial discretion in decisions about the type of provision that pupils received and the quality of the arrangementsT. he diversity of family provision contributed to the diversity of the outcomes for pupils also. The dataf rom LEA professionalss uggestedth at the main effectso f professionald ecision-makingin the administrationo f provision were rationing and displacement of responsibility to the school and parents. Given the pragmatic nature of factors responsible for the diversity in the type and quality of LEA provision that pupils received, together with evidenceo f rationing the quantity of resourcesa llocated,t he study concluded that the determining factor influencing professional decisionmaking was inadequater esourcesto fund LEA provision. The dataf rom LEA documents,p rofessionalsa ndp arentss uggestedth at the main effects of the informal involvement of parents in professional decision making was parental influence on the type and quality of provision, but not the quantity of LEA provision. Given the limiting factor of inadequate resources and the lack of influence of parents on the quantity of LEA resources allocated, it was likely that financial pressure within the LEA caused the displacement of responsibility for provision to schools. The discourse of participants suggested that professionals were in control of the decision-making process and parents accepted responsibility to liaise between stakeholders. The diversity of parents' needs was related to the effectiveness of the parent to influence decisions or situations that impinged on the type of provision and quality of the arrangements that pupils received. The implicationso f the findings for decision-makersa nd possiblea reasf or policy development are discussed.
| Identifer | oai:union.ndltd.org:bl.uk/oai:ethos.bl.uk:390974 |
| Date | January 2002 |
| Creators | Davies, Susan Margaret |
| Publisher | Oxford Brookes University |
| Source Sets | Ethos UK |
| Detected Language | English |
| Type | Electronic Thesis or Dissertation |
Page generated in 0.0019 seconds