National and Kapodistrian University of Athens
Can Truth be Discovered through Duplicity?
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis thesis explores a central paradox in the life and philosophy of Socrates: whether his method, despite his deceptive rhetorical tactics, can lead to genuine truth. Through a detailed analysis of Plato’s Gorgias, the thesis examines whether Socrates’ these methods, which included “irony”, leading questions, feigned ignorance, and misinterpretation of opponents’ views undermine or serve the pursuit of philosophical truth. Socrates’ acceptance of his death in the Apology and Crito is interpreted as a crucial turning point that may represent a reckoning with his own philosophical practices. His life of debate comes into sharp focus during his trial and imminent execution, when Socrates had to confront the consequences of his life’s work. This period likely forced him to reassess the ethical validity of his methods, perhaps signaling a shift from the competitive ethos of earlier dialogues to a more sincere engagement with truth. The thesis further investigates the continuum between elenchus and eristic, challenging the notion that his manipulative methods were purely in service of intellectual growth. Socrates’ rhetorical traps often guided interlocutors to predetermined conclusions. Yet, despite these ethical ambiguities, Socrates’ philosophy continues to raise crucial questions about the nature of truth, power, and morality. As the thesis argues, Socrates' final reflections in Gorgias and Phaedo reveal a deeper engagement with the soul’s moral condition, particularly as he approaches death. These later dialogues suggest that philosophy, at its best, is a preparation for death - a process of clarifying one’s beliefs and moving beyond the deceits of earlier methods toward an honest confrontation with reality. The thesis contends that Socrates may have recognized the limitations of his own manipulations, pivoting toward a more authentic search for the Good in his final days. Ultimately, the thesis grapples with whether duplicity can lead to truth. While his methods may seem incompatible with the pursuit of a pure and unchanging reality, they may also serve as necessary provocations in an age where truth itself is under the most formidable threat ever experienced in the history of humanity.
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Swanson Todd
Subjects
dc:subject × 2Rights
- Language dc:language
- English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- uoadl:3440756