Back to search

University of Birmingham

Bridging the divide between standardisation and individualisation of care to minimise on-the-day surgery cancellations.

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Reasonably high levels of unintended outcomes (e.g., hospital-acquired infections, delayed discharges, wrong diagnosis, surgery cancellations) in Healthcare Delivery Systems (HDSs) are a global problem. Standardisation of care has been seen as a panacea to minimising unintended outcomes and improving healthcare. Care delivery in modern HDSs has become dominated by various forms of standardised care, such as care pathways, interventions, terminology, protocols, checklists, targets and best practice guidelines. Nonetheless, finding a ‘standard patient’ in a real care setting is hard. Individualised care delivery approaches, careful understanding of patient needs, and individualised diagnoses and treatment plans are fundamental to minimising unintended outcomes and improving healthcare quality. To understand how standardisation and individualisation of care influence unintended outcomes, the thesis investigates On-The-Day Surgery Cancellations (OTDSCs), a widely reported long-standing problem in Scheduled Surgical Care Systems (SSCSs). An OTDSC is defined as any surgery appointment cancelled on the scheduled day. The study design comprises five phases and uses a realist methodology. The study used a multi-method approach for theory gleaning and refining: incorporating examining literature related to OTDSCs (n=55), findings on the feasibility study including results from eight NHS trusts, two feedback events with patient representatives (n=6), eight expert practitioners (n=8), and 28 semi-structured interviews conducted in a “teacher–learner style” with healthcare professionals. The iterative analysis identified OTDSCs resulting from clinical reasons as a complex phenomenon dependent on closely connected variables: micro-context (i.e., clinical autonomy), standardised clinical care planning interventions, individualisation of care related to clinical care planning, and behavioural mechanisms (i.e., compassion, self-efficacy, trust and situational awareness). The realist investigation found that OTDSCs resulting from clinical reasons were preventable through minimising tensions between the standardisation and individualisation of care. The study contributes to knowledge by developing a taxonomy and transferable explanations of how and in what contexts OTDSCs, for clinical reasons, are reduced, developing a reporting tool to categorise OTDSCs that can be useful in minimising OTDSCs. By using findings relating to OTDSCs for clinical reasons, the thesis contributes to knowledge in academic research about the impact on standardisation and individualisation of care in HDSs. The thesis synthesises a theory explaining how individualisation and standardisation of care work together to minimise unintended outcomes that could be used in other HDSs. Behavioural mechanisms activated by the clinical autonomy of clinical actors, namely compassion, self-efficacy and situational awareness, play a vital role in enabling standardisation and individualisation of care to work together. Despite the polarised nature of standardisation and individualisation of care, the thesis findings are associated with the concept of “individualised standardisation” Despite the significant reliance on standardisation of care, it is not a ‘universal’ or simple solution to minimise unintended outcomes. One of the main recommendations emerging from the study highlighted the need to caution policymakers on over relying on the standardisation of care to minimise unintended outcomes and improve quality instead of maintaining a judicious balance between standardisation and individualisation of care delivery in HDSs.

Degree

thesis:*
Name dc:type.qualificationname
d_ph
Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
d_ph
Grantor dc:publisher.institution
University of Birmingham
Year dc:date.issued
2025

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Samarasinghe, Buddhika

Subjects

dc:subject × 3

Rights

Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
eng

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Birmingham
Base URL
etheses.bham.ac.uk/cgi/oai2
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Samarasinghe, Buddhika. Bridging the divide between standardisation and individualisation of care to minimise on-the-day surgery cancellations.. d_ph thesis, University of Birmingham, 2025.