Boston University
Understanding the European Union’s behavior during the crises: evidence from the rule of law and equality crises
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation explains the European Union’s behavior during the rule of law crisis by examining the policy changes in Hungary and Poland from 2015 to 2023. In this dissertation, I argue that the European Union’s institutions’ responses to the rule of law and equality crises are inadequate, inefficient, and unbalanced. To explain the institutional response to these crises, I analyze the institutional structure, strategic leadership, and domestic political conditions in Poland and Hungary. Based on my research, I reached five conclusions. Firstly, the EU institutions are fragmented, with a hierarchy that places intergovernmental institutions like the European Council and the Council of the European Union above supranational ones like the European Commission and the European Parliament. The intergovernmental bargains in the Council restrict its decision-making capacity during crises, where prompt decisions and equitable outcomes for all member states are essential. This results in a power vacuum that supranational institutions cannot fill, as the European Parliament lacks the necessary competencies, and the European Commission is stymied by the Council and its legal service. Consequently, the European Union’s institutions produce inadequate, piecemeal solutions to systemic crises, which fall short of effectively resolving them. Secondly, the European Union institutions approach the rule of law crisis differently, leading to distinct responses to similar problems from member states. The quantitative and qualitative text analyses indicate that Poland has been punished more harshly than Hungary during the rule of law and equality crises. The sentiment analysis shows that the institutions utilized different linguistic frames towards each country, with some institutions adopting more negative language than others. Furthermore, the topic extraction and structural models demonstrate that the language used in European Union documents has not become more punitive over time, suggesting a lenient approach. These results are supported by an analysis of the equality crisis using a qualitative scoring method. Thirdly, my dissertation demonstrates that the different approaches of European Union institutions result from the distinct strategies adopted by member states. The qualitative evidence suggests that Polish politicians from the ruling coalition have chosen combative strategies, while Hungarian politicians have opted for accommodative strategies. I argue that the differences in strategies stem from two main factors: domestic electoral and government systems, and strategic leadership capabilities. Furthermore, to illustrate the latter, I employ a social network analysis approach to map the relationships between politicians from member states and the European Union. My research indicates that Hungarian politicians have been more active and influential in the European Union than their Polish counterparts, which may explain the lower levels of punishment they receive. Fourthly, my dissertation has theoretical implications for addressing value and norm-based crises in international institutions. The integration theories that explain different stages of the European Union’s political development do not fully account for the duration that its institutions confronted the rule of law crisis. Traditional and new forms of intergovernmentalism, supranationalism, and other institution-based theories have been crucial in explaining how previous crises, such as the Schengen and Eurozone crises, impacted European Union integration, revealing which institutions emerged as winners and which ones were losers in the process. The rule of law and equality crisis, or the crisis of illiberalism, has fundamentally challenged the EU's core values, and none of the existing integration theories have successfully predicted or explained whether this crisis has brought the European Union closer to integration or created further divisions among the member states. Therefore, my research demonstrates that the existing integration theories are inadequate for explaining when a polity crisis occurs instead of a policy crisis. Finally, my overall dissertation demonstrates that democratic backsliding can occur anywhere, and the existing theories of democracy and democratic decline are incomplete. Poland, Hungary, and other countries in Europe’s neighborhood have undergone years of economic, democratic, and other forms of development, strengthening their ties with the West and the world due to globalization. However, these countries were not immune to the impacts of right-wing populism and subsequent democratic downfall exemplified by the weakening of judicial independence, the erosion of free and fair elections, and the challenges to women’s and LGBTQ+ rights. Therefore, my dissertation highlights the necessity for a new theory of dedemocratization.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Level thesis:degree_level
- doctoral
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- Political Science
- Grantor
- Boston University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Kaftan, Gizem
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Schmidt, Vivien A.
- ORCID dc:identifier.orcid
Subjects
dc:subject × 7Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International
- Licence dc:rights.uri
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/2144/53362