Boston University
Morbid affections: sensational murder trials and the policing of women’s same-sex desires at the turn of the twentieth century
Abstract
dc:description.abstractMorbid Affections examines how changing expectations surrounding women’s sexuality between the 1870s and the 1920s impacted the lived experience of queer women and contributed to popular associations of queer women with violence, insanity, and sexual aggression. At a time when Comstock laws and other censorship barriers sharply restricted American audiences’ access not only to lewd and obscene materials but virtually any publications with sexual content, “yellow journalism” and its frequent coverage of sensational scandals offered a vital and unique forum for public discussions about perceived sexual deviances. Focusing on four revealing murder trials that centered around same-sex female relationships, this dissertation examines how local, national, and international journalists covered and sensationalized these controversies and how they in turn helped shape modern beliefs about the dangers of female intimacy. Historians have pinpointed the 1930s as a turning point moment for the increased policing and persecution of gay men. This dissertation provides further evidence that similar targeting of women’s same-sex partnerships and gender non-conformity coalesced even earlier. Although other historians have analyzed isolated murder cases and their connection to emerging tropes about lesbian women as inherently violent, none have examined how these depictions evolved, or explored how, taken together, these cases highlight the varied experiences of queer women across racial and class lines. By doing this comparative, intersectional work, this dissertation shows how shifting cultural attitudes impacted not only upper-class and white queer women, but also working-class and Black queer women, whose lives have been under researched. Queer women in this period, especially working-class and Black queer women, did not enjoy as much legal and social impunity as often assumed. Chapter One analyzes the trial of Lillian Duer for the murder of Ella Hearn in 1878. This case offers a revealing window onto how same-sex relationships between women functioned and were popularly understood on the eve of the twentieth century. It dramatizes the degree to which intimacies among women were still tolerated by families and communities in the nineteenth century but also hints at the early beginnings of modern American beliefs that queer women posed a threat to the social order. Chapter Two examines the most infamous “lesbian” murder in US history, that of Freda Ward by Alice Mitchell in 1892. The Mitchell trial is often credited for originating the stereotype of the violent and aggressive lesbian; this chapter unpacks how the courts and public observers understood Mitchell’s whiteness and queerness as fundamentally incompatible and how questioning Mitchell’s sanity helped observers reconcile their sexual orientation with their racial identity. Alice Mitchell, not least because of their whiteness, successfully pleaded insane in trial, solidifying cultural and medical associations of lesbianism with insanity. Chapter Three focuses on a direct contrast to the Mitchell case: the trial of Emily Lee for the murder of Estella Weldon in 1905. Lee’s inability to make use of an insanity defense demonstrates how racial prejudice, which painted Black women as inherently sexually immoral, fed into growing fears of queer women. Likewise, the Lee case illustrates how queerness and middle-class Black respectability politics co-existed in smaller Black communities. Chapter Four analyzes the murder of Edna Washington by Alberta Mitchell in 1928. This case, which involved three young Black women within the larger urban queer community of New York, shows how growing anti-queer ideologies coalesced in the 1920s and justified increasingly aggressive policing and persecution of queer women. The conclusion discusses how the ideologies and practices highlighted throughout the dissertation built the foundation for mid-century anti-queer policing. By examining the 1954 execution of Betty Butler for the murder of Evelyn Clark, both of whom were Black women, the ties between the infamous “gay panic” defense and the four primary cases of this dissertation are made clear. Taken together, these cases and the public debates surrounding them make clear that growing fears of women’s gender non-conformity, intimacy with each other, and expression of sexual desires outside of heterosexual marriage were deeply rooted in turn-of-the-century racial and class anxieties—fears which led to the harsh yet disparate persecution of white and Black queer women. These cases provided the legal and cultural foundations of the more well-known fear and persecution of queer women in the mid and late twentieth century.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Level thesis:degree_level
- doctoral
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- History
- Grantor
- Boston University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Sebold, Keara L.
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Blower, Brooke
Subjects
dc:subject × 3Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/2144/53692