Boston University
Profiles in paranoia: the origins of the anti-New World Order movement in the postwar United States
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis dissertation analyzes the early history of the anti-New World Order (NWO) movement and its decades long effort to destroy an elite conspiracy of world domination that existed only in the minds of its believers. Viewed through the lives of four of its most important leaders, and their journeys to and in conspiracist politics, “Profiles in Paranoia” shows how the movement led thousands of Americans to organize against their perceived foes, inspired thousands more to eventually take up arms against the state, and created legions of believers whose worldview still weighs on U.S. political life. The movement began to take shape in the 1950s, responding to many of the same events and political circumstances that would eventually spawn the related conservative movement. The story of the anti-NWO movement offers a unique perspective on the postwar U.S. right. Not merely the chaff to be discarded by an ascendant conservative movement, anti-NWO activists were one of the many concurrent threads of right-wing activism that persisted alongside their more-mainstream counterparts. This analysis of their movement offers a view of the far-right that goes beyond large organizations like the John Birch Society to show just how widespread and impactful smaller groups and individual activists could be. The history of their movement also calls into question scholarly assumptions that conspiracism could be understood as a singular phenomenon, rather than as a class of disparate beliefs with similarly disparate significance for politics and public life. This history, reconstructed from not only conspiracists’ own publications, but from the trail they left in obscure periodicals, public records, and especially local media coverage, shows that belief in the NWO conspiracy theory fueled a persistent political movement, a phenomenon with few equals among other conspiracist ideologies. Chapter one follows the career of Don Bell, a wartime overseas broadcaster of national renown. When Bell’s career flagged in the postwar world, he turned to anti-NWO conspiracism, spread via his newsletter Don Bell Reports. Bell became one of the earliest widely read anti-NWO propagandists and laid out a vision for a movement that could turn belief in the conspiracy into a counterrevolutionary force. Chapter two tells the story of Mary M. Davison, one of Bell’s most dedicated readers. Davison, a longtime foe of local government regulations, took up Bell’s call for action. She began organizing letter-writing and lobbying campaigns against the “Secret Government of the United States.” She was among the early leaders who built a political movement out of belief in the NWO. Davison and her beliefs were embraced and promoted by Women for Constitutional Government, a nationwide network of grassroots women dedicated to right-wing causes. Chapter three examines the career of Lt. Col. Archibald Roberts. Swept up in the Pro-Blue scandal in the early 1960s, Roberts dedicated the rest of his life to defeating the NWO conspiracy. At the head of his Committee to Restore the Constitution he worked to professionalize the movement, and lobbied governments across the country to pass legislation he believed would defeat the conspiracy. At the same time, the first generation of the anti-NWO movement, one which professed a belief in non-violent action, began losing ground to activists who offered a different solution: counterrevolutionary violence. The final chapter focuses on Larry H. Abraham, a John Birch Society regional coordinator who became co-author of one of the bestselling NWO conspiracist books of all time: None Dare Call It Conspiracy. While Abraham and the John Birch Society did more to spread belief in the NWO than anyone had before, they, like most of his contemporaries, failed to translate new believers into new life for the non-violent wing of the movement. Instead, they bolstered the violent wing and left an even larger body of believers looking for a political home; a home they eventually found in the conservative movement and the Republican Party.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Level thesis:degree_level
- doctoral
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- History
- Grantor
- Boston University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Parker, Nicholas J.
- Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Schulman, Bruce J.
- ORCID dc:identifier.orcid
Subjects
dc:subject × 9Rights
- Language dc:language.iso
- en_US
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/2144/53699