Back to search

Carleton University

Using Automated Facial Recognition to Select Fillers for Eyewitness Identification Lineups

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

The current recommendation for selecting fillers for an eyewitness identification lineup is to use the eyewitness’ description of the culprit (match-to-description). I argue that this recommendation is inadequate given eyewitness’ limited recall ability and expanding police resources. Instead, I contend that fillers should be selected based on their match to the appearance of the suspect (match-to-suspect). Specifically, in this dissertation, I suggest using automated facial recognition (AFR) software and the similarity ratings generated to select match-to-suspect fillers. Although researchers have noted problems with match-to-suspect fillers, using objective assessments of similarity offers resolution to those problems. In Study 1, AFR was used to build lineups with three different levels of suspect-filler similarity, resulting in three similarity lineup conditions: low, moderate, and high. The purpose of Study 1 was to determine the suspect-filler similarity level which would result in the greatest discriminability. Participants made an identification decision from a simultaneous lineup (Study 1a; N=1509) or a sequential lineup (Study 1b; N=1416). Comparison of full ROC curves identified that discriminability did not significantly differ between the three similarity conditions using either the simultaneous or the sequential presentation. However, follow-up expected utility analyses identified that the high similarity lineup should be preferred to the low and moderate similarity lineups under assumptions of low base rates of suspect guilt and high costs of mistaken identifications. In Study 2 (N=1044), I compared the high similarity AFR lineup to a match-to-description lineup presented simultaneously. The purpose of Study 2 was to examine how lineups built using AFR performed in comparison to the current recommended match-to-description filler selection strategy. Comparison of full ROC curves identified that discriminability did not significantly differ between the two conditions. Though, follow-up expected utility analyses identified that the AFR match-to-suspect lineup should be preferred over the match-to-description lineup across low, moderate, and high base rates of suspect guilt and under assumptions of high costs of mistaken identifications. Overall, this research suggests that non-human objective assessments of similarity may be the preferred filler selection strategy over the recommended match-to-description strategy, and that identifying an optimal level of filler similarity may be possible.

Degree

thesis:*
Name thesis:degree_name
Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)
Level thesis:degree_level
Doctoral
Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
Psychology
Grantor dc:publisher
Carleton University
Year dc:date.issued
2023

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Thompson, Lauren Elizabeth

Subjects

dc:subject × 2

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Copyright © 2023 the author(s). Theses may be used for non-commercial research, educational, or related academic purposes only. Such uses include personal study, distribution to students, research and scholarship. Theses may only be shared by linking to the Carleton University Institutional Repository and no part may be copied without proper attribution to the author; no part may be used for commercial purposes directly or indirectly via a for-profit platform; no adaptation or derivative works are permitted without consent from the copyright owner.
Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Carleton University
Base URL
carleton.scholaris.ca/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Thompson, Lauren Elizabeth. Using Automated Facial Recognition to Select Fillers for Eyewitness Identification Lineups. Doctoral thesis, Carleton University, 2023. https://hdl.handle.net/20.500.14718/40959