Carleton University
“Whose Line Is It Anyway”? Message Source Characteristics and Appeal Type Effectiveness in Shaping Pro-Environmental Behavior
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis investigates the effectiveness of appeal types—generic versus normative—in promoting pro-environmental behavior (PEB), with a focus on how message source characteristics shape their impact. Drawing on the elaboration likelihood model, persuasion knowledge model, and social identity theory, it examines two message source characteristics—perceived ulterior motive (present vs. absent) and group categorization (ingroup, outgroup, extreme outgroup)—as moderators of appeal type effectiveness. A multi-method empirical design, comprising one survey, one field study, and three experiments, tested these relationships through the mechanisms of trust and perceived threat. Findings reveal that generic appeals generally elicit greater trust and lower threat than normative appeals, particularly when the message source lacks an ulterior motive or is perceived as an ingroup member. When ulterior motive is present or the source is an outgroup, differences between appeal types diminish. However, when the source is an extreme outgroup (e.g., a non-human agent), normative appeals outperform generic ones—suggesting that a relational tone may foster trust when the source appears distant. These findings help explain inconsistencies in prior literature by identifying certain conditions under which appeal type matters. They contribute to the elaboration likelihood model by demonstrating that message source characteristics shape how people attend to message framing. When motive is absent or the source is an ingroup, participants appear more responsive to differences in message framing. Conversely, when motive is present or the source is socially distant, message framing has less impact. Yet, when the source is an extreme outgroup, message framing scrutiny re-engages, possibly due to the novelty or ambiguity of the source. The findings also extend social identity theory by demonstrating that group categorization influences not only receptivity to an appeal, but also the processing of its framing. By distinguishing between ingroup, outgroup, and extreme outgroup sources, this thesis shows that the messenger’s identity shapes trust and threat responses that mediate persuasion. Together, these insights offer a comprehensive answer to the central question: why do appeal types vary in effectiveness? By integrating message source characteristics into the appeal–response process, this work advances theory and offers guidance for designing effective pro-environmental messages.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy (Ph.D.)
- Level thesis:degree_level
- Doctoral
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- Management
- Grantor dc:publisher
- Carleton University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Banu, Narmin Tartila
Subjects
dc:subject × 3Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Copyright © 2025 the author(s). Theses may be used for non-commercial research, educational, or related academic purposes only. Such uses include personal study, distribution to students, research and scholarship. Theses may only be shared by linking to the Carleton University Institutional Repository and no part may be copied without proper attribution to the author; no part may be used for commercial purposes directly or indirectly via a for-profit platform; no adaptation or derivative works are permitted without consent from the copyright owner.
- Language dc:language.iso
- en