Back to search

Clemson University

Choices of Contention: Decision Making Factors Leading to the Substitute Method Over In-Kind Repairs and Their Effectiveness at Lyndhurst Estate

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Lyndhurst Mansion, located in Tarrytown, New York is a masterpiece of American Gothic Revival architecture designed by Alexander Jackson Davis beginning in 1838. Since its acquisition by the National Trust in 1961, the property has carried out a number of repairs to the mansion and other buildings on the estate in which a substitute material was chosen over an in-kind material. Financial constraints appear to be the driving force behind these decisions. Other factors, durability of materials and preservation philosophy, also played a role. An aim of this thesis is to determine the role these factors played in choosing methods and materials used in these repairs. Another aim is to assess the success of the substitute method compared to in-kind repair. Research conducted in Lyndhurst's archives as well as interviews with current and past employees provided narrative data regarding the decision making process, while assessment of five case studies provided insight into the effectiveness of the decisions. Findings concluded that cost often outweighed the other considerations when choosing a repair method and materials. Substitute materials at Lyndhurst proved overall to be inferior to those of an in-kind replacement. The findings serve as an example of the financial challenges facing many historic sites.

Degree

thesis:*
Name thesis:degree_name
Master of Science (MS)
Level thesis:degree_level
Thesis
Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
Historic Preservation

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Freeman, Kirsten Anne
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Dr. Carter L. Hudgins, Committee Chair
  • Dr. Stephanie Crette
  • Frances H. Ford

Subjects

dc:subject × 3

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Repository record dc:identifier
https://open.clemson.edu/all_theses/2624

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Clemson University
Base URL
open.clemson.edu/do/oai/
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Freeman, Kirsten Anne. Choices of Contention: Decision Making Factors Leading to the Substitute Method Over In-Kind Repairs and Their Effectiveness at Lyndhurst Estate. Thesis thesis, https://open.clemson.edu/all_theses/2624